-
-
Alright - I have an update for everyone (this is a continuation of part 1 of this blog-post: http://boardgamegeek.com/blogpost/6041/whats-your-gateway-ga...).
Played a bunch of games yesterday:
7 Wonders (my first plays)
Dominion
Pandemic (my first plays)
Battlestar Galactica
The Resistance
Buccaneer (my first plays)
7 Wonders was every bit as good as I hoped it would be - a fantastic game that supports larger crowds than average (up to 7 players for now, but soon the Cities expansion will allow for up to 8 in team play). I agree with Kevin (a commenter on a previous post of mine) - it's likely not the best gateway game, but it is a great game to introduce folks to after they've been somewhat roped into the world. It's was fairly easy to get used to, and very fun and strategic gameplay (a la Puerto Rico, Race For The Galaxy, etc.).
Dominion is always a crowd-pleaser, and I think I would still endorse it as a good starting point for new players. Perhaps it's on the tail end of acceptable for this purpose, but it is easy to teach the rules and there are never more than 10 cards out that you need to understand. Perhaps it comes down to a personality / group dynamic thing.
Pandemic was also every bit as good as I expected - it's like Forbidden Island on steroids, though I do not think I would introduce this to a new player - stick with FI for that. However, this is more fun to play than FI - it's got more choices, more intrigue, and more depth. The level of suspense is perhaps equal to FI... both excellent games I would highly recommend!
BSG requires no further explanation - I talk about that more than any other game in my blog. Don't use it as a gateway, plain and simple!
Interestingly, we've been using The Resistance to introduce new players to the scene, and it's worked incredibly well! My father and brother played it on Thanksgiving and really got into it - neither are into any kind of hobby gaming. What's even more interesting is if you're clever about how to do it, that could segue into pulling someone into BSG... eventually. You still need people who are definitely interested in longer gameplay and many rules to understand, but clearly The Resistance is the very heart of what makes BSG good.
Enter Buccaneer!! My friend brought this one over and we played several games - it's a very fun and simple game, and it plays very quick. I put it on par with FI - very fast and easy to get newcomers into, and enough fun and strategy for others to still enjoy. It would absolutely make a great gateway game!!
Gaming rules!!! Jason
|
|