$10.00
Information
Designer
Artist
Publisher
Year Published
2009
# of Players
1
User Suggested # of Players
Best with 1 players
Recommended with 1 players
(20 voters) [poll]
Mfg Suggested Ages
 
Playing Time
240 minutes
User Suggested Ages
12 and up
(8 voters) [poll]
Language Dependence
Extensive use of text - massive conversion needed to be playable
(13 voters) [poll]
Honors
Subdomain
(23 voters) [vote]
Category
Mechanic
Family
Primary Name
Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic
Alternate Names
I Counted Them All Out (formerly)
Website
wrong website?
Website
 
 Corrections
 Customize View
xml RSS Feed 
Facebook Twitter Delicious Google
ObjectID: 35614
Description Edit | History

"Where there is discord... may we bring harmony." -- Margaret Thatcher, quoting a prayer ascribed to St. Francis of Assisi

At 16.28 hours on the afternoon of Saturday, 1 May 1982, an AIM-9L Sidewinder missile fired from the Sea Harrier of Royal Naval Air Squadron Flight Lieutenant Paul Barton struck the Mirage III of Lieutenant Carlos Perona of Fuerza Aerea Argentina, destroying it on impact. The Falkland/Malvinas War had begun in earnest.

Over the next 45 days, the armed forces of the United Kingdom and Argentina locked in a deadly struggle, as both attempted to assert their right to govern a small, inhospitable South Atlantic island unknown to most of the world and to many of those fighting over her.

In this solitaire military simulation boardgame, you have the opportunity to recreate those fateful summer days, commanding the British Task Force as it attempts to defend itself from concerted attacks by Argentine air and naval forces, and mount a successful amphibious landing on the disputed islands. You will have to manage and deploy the Royal Navy’s limited Sea Harrier assets, coordinate the defence of the fleet with a wide range of vessels and weapons systems, and plan a landing strategy that enables you to consolidate a bridgehead before Argentine forces can respond. Modeled closely on historical events, you will confront issues including variable rules of engagement, surveillance and intelligence gathering, submarine warfare, Argentine carrier and surface fleet operations, the Exocet missile threat, third-party operational support and interference, fleet logistics, supply interdiction, and uncooperative weather. At the same time you will have to walk the tightrope of public opinion, deal with “oversight” from the politicians back in London, and overcome unforeseen events ranging from the sabotage of supply lines up to orders to take the fight to the mainland.

Will the Falklands remain in British hands, or will the Malvinas return to Argentina? Their fate is in your hands..

Updating...
Thumbs Up
Marketplace
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No items found
{{product.numforsale}} for sale {{product.price}}
{{product.prettycondition}}
{{product.listdate|truncate:"10"}}
Updating...
Thumbs Up
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No items found
{{item.title}} {{item.timeleft}}
{{item.currentprice}}
More Information Edit | History

Box contains:

  • 104cm x 72cm mounted mapboard
  • 176 thick one-inch counters
  • 60-page Rules & historical booklet
  • 56-page Intelligence Briefing booklet
  • 60 playing cards
  • Two reference cards
  • Twenty 4,6,8,10, and 12-sided dice

All profits from original sales of this game were donated to: the Royal British Legion and the Argentine Veteranos de Guerra].

Additional Playtesters: Chris Foord, Ian Taylor

Special Thanks: Captain Carlos Castro Madero, Viswan Nair and Derrick Walker

Additional Thanks: Gill Howie, Nicola Hunt, Group Captain Juan Carlos Montoya, Ray Mudie,
Thomas Phillips, Colonel Carlos Mariano Saini, Christopher Shea, Katherine Tattersall

formerly known as "I Counted Them All Out"

Microbadges:
mb Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic Fan - Royal Navy Air Force
mb Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic Fan - Argentine Air Force
mb Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic Fan

Versions
Sort: Nickname | Year Published
[Browse] [Add Version]
Pg. 1
Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic
Nick: 
First edition, third printing
Publisher: Fifth Column Games
Artist: George Bieda, Ugo Crisponi, Mark Mahaffey
Year: 2014
Size: 11.30 x 16.80 x 3.50 inches
5.50 pounds
English
Release Date:  
Released
View
Corrections
Link Image
Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic
Nick: 
First edition, second printing
Publisher: Fifth Column Games
Artist: George Bieda, Ugo Crisponi, Mark Mahaffey
Year: 2010
Size: 11.30 x 16.80 x 3.50 inches
5.50 pounds
English
Release Date:  
Released
View
Corrections
Link Image
Where There Is Discord: War in the South Atlantic
Nick: 
First edition
Publisher: Fifth Column Games
Artist: George Bieda, Ugo Crisponi, Mark Mahaffey
Year: 2009
Size: 11.30 x 16.80 x 3.50 inches
5.50 pounds
English
Release Date:  
View
Corrections
Link Image
Updating...
Thumbs Up
Images
Gallery:
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No images found
Updating...
Thumbs Up
{{title}}
Category: Language:
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No videos found
{{video.numrecommend}} {{video.title}} {{video.language}} {{video.username|truncate:"10"}} {{video.numcomments}}
Updating...
Thumbs Up
{{data.config.moduletitle}} Relationship:
[] [Forums »] [Post »] [Search »]
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No threads found
{{thread.numrecommend}} {{thread.subject}}
Last Post {{thread.lastpostdate|truncate:"10"}} Posted {{thread.postdate|truncate:"10"}}
{{thread.user.username|truncate:"10"}} {{thread.numposts-1}}
Updating...
Thumbs Up
{{data.config.moduletitle}} Relationship:
[] [Forums »] [Post »] [Search »]
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No threads found
{{thread.numrecommend}} {{thread.subject}}
Last Post {{thread.lastpostdate|truncate:"10"}} Posted {{thread.postdate|truncate:"10"}}
{{thread.user.username|truncate:"10"}} {{thread.numposts-1}}
Updating...
Thumbs Up
{{title}}
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No posts found
{{post.numpositive}} {{post.title}}
by
{{post.numcomments}}
Files
Title | Hot | Recent
[Browse »]  [Upload File »] Language:
Pg. 1 of 2 »
3 Let us bring Harmony Realtime Number Generator v2015.01
A spreadsheet use to generate the events, weather, and so on for the Let us Bring Harmony real time plays.
English
2015-04-25
30 WTID Setup and Detailed Sequence of Play
Detailed guide for setup and sequence of play for Where There Is Discord. Version 2 - corrected typos and die wording "black" to "colored".
English
2014-12-17
20 Sequence of Play
This is a real step by step sequence of play with most tables. You don´t have to look all the time in the rulebook or tables anymore. I use this also in my playthrough videos. It doesn´t cover the errata though...
English
2014-10-31
29 Combined Charts and Sequence of Play
While playing WTID I find the sequence of play and charts are the papers I am looking at most frequently. In an effort to reduce clutter and simplify finding things, I have combined all the charts and the sequence of play onto a single letter sized sheet. While the type does get small with this, I hope you find it a useful aid when playing.
English
2013-07-30
30 WTID Game Record v2.2
Updated: now version 2.2. An excel 2003 spreadsheet I created to track the statistics,events, and outcome of my campaign in the Falklands. The "Summary Sheets" worksheet is designed to record your campaign assessment. It contains a lot of drop down menus to make things convenient. You can print and enter your results with a pen, or enter information into the worksheet and print if you like. The document is protected without a password, and only the cells needing input may be selected. The "Game Turn Records" sheet contains a log to record the events and information generated each turn. It's useful if you want to do an AAR, check back to ensure you're playing the game correctly, or are just obsessed with recording your experience like I am. The entire document is protected...
English
2011-01-30
19 WTID Reinforcement Chart v1-3
This zip folder contains 3 PDF documents. I created this to organize my reinforcement counters. The reinforcements are organized by date, do it's easy to plan at a glance, and the counters are easy to grab when you need to deploy them. Version 1 is the simplest and will go easiest on your printers ink. No graphics of the ship counters are included. Version 2 contains full color representations of the reinforcement counters and will be hardest on your printers ink. Version 3 contains grayed out representations of the reinforcement counters and shouldn't use too much color ink. If you have any ideas on how I can improve these files, please let me know! I'd be happy to hear them.
English
2011-01-30
12 AAR of WTID - Newer Excel format
This is a record of 3 of my plays and includes a blank sheet for recording your own play. It is compatible with Excel 2007.
English
2010-07-09
2 AAR of WTID - Older Excel format
This is a record of my 3 plays of WTID which includes a blank sheet for those interested in chronicling their plays. It's compatible with Excel '97-'03
English
2010-07-09
64 WTID Errata and Clarifications v0.1
A compilation of most of the errata and questions answered here at BGG and at ConsimWorld - digested, rewritten and ordered as per the rulebook.
English
2010-07-05
42 Guide for playing without forgeting rules v2.0
Hi, Here's the corrected version 2.0...please feel free for comments, i maybe made mistakes Gilles
English
2010-06-24
Updating...
Thumbs Up
GeekLists
[Browse »] [Summary »]
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No lists found
{{list.numpositive}} {{list.title}} {{list.username|truncate:"10"}} {{list.numitems}}
{{list.lastreplydate|truncate:"10"}} {{list.postdate|truncate:"10"}}
Statistics
Board Game Rank: 1075
War Game Rank: 68
Num Ratings: 317
Average Rating: 8.09
Standard Deviation: 1.56
Num Views: 236235
GeekBuddy Analysis: Analyze
Similarly Rated: View
Avg. Game Weight: 3.1
Fans: 106
Personal Comments: 200
Users Owning: 811
Users Wanting: 211
Users Trading: 23 [find trade matches]
Has Parts For Trade: 0
Want Parts In Trade: 0
Price History: View
Total Plays: 474
Plays This Month: 2
Linked Items
Relationship: Sort: Category: Mechanic:
Pg. 1
No Items Found
Linked Podcasts/Periodicals
Relationship:
Pg. 1
I've Been Diced! episode 50: Joel Toppen
2014-02-05
I've Been Diced! episode 30: The games that got away
63.14 MB
2012-01-25
Where There Is Discord
5:48
3.39 MB
2009-10-03
Updating...
Thumbs Up
Web Links
Category: Language:
1 « Pg. {{module.params.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
No Web Links Found
Link {{cat}} {{lang}}
{{weblink.postdate|truncate:"10"}}
Tags
User Information
Use this tool to rate games, save comments, and manage your collection.
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.