1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5  Next »  [12]

User Rating Comment Status
Thomas B.
Germany
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
10
Jun 2013
Owned
paul troke
United Kingdom
hove
East Sussex
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
10
Dec 2012
o.k. so i initially scored this a 1 having problems understanding the rulebook, and whilst i still have issues
with the rulebook once you've gone through it a few times
it begins to make sense certainly what i would call a high complex game but it is worth persevering with as it is a good game although if you are playing with players who haven't played the game before i would suggest you play a couple of dummy rounds first so they get the gist of it
update after 9 plays
it's got to be a 10 really great game which will
generally be my first choice to play
2012-12-29
Owned
stef po
France
flag msg tools
10
Jan 2013
Very nice game with an original mecanism of guessing what other players will do and will expect you to do
2013-01-15
Owned
Yomgi Nostalgy
msg tools
10
Apr 2013
Cyril LE BRIS
France
Montpellier
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
10
May 2013
Owned
Wolfgang Denecke
msg tools
10
May 2013
Owned
Marco Stutzke
Germany
Neumünster
flag msg tools
10
Sep 2013
Owned
Lionel Graveleau
France
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
10
Apr 2014
Owned
Leo Leo
msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
10
Jan 2015
Owned
christophe molon
France
flag msg tools
10
Jan 2014
Owned
alex p
France
flag msg tools
10
May 2014
CycyX
France
Magny en Vexin
Val d'Oise
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
9.5
Feb 2014
Owned
Dries Doornaert
msg tools
9.5
Oct 2012
Owned
Vincent BONNARD
France
flag msg tools
9
Feb 2012
Number of players: 3
Time: 3h (with explanations)

First game for everybody, so we spent a few minutes to look at the components and the rulebook even though two of us have already read them.

Inventory:
We quickly identified each component. The only surprise was about the building tiles, which are printed on both sides (and we did not see that, at first). Cards could be bigger for an easier reading. Other details were a little bit odd but we were playing on a prototype and the author told us it was to be changed. Last but not least, the iconography is more than effective (and the author said it was the only “definitive” part… great!). Drawings should help the immersion, especially on the boards: a big town illustration will definitely put you under the skin of a Marshal.

Preparation:
Here is the moment we found difficulty with the rulebook: the setup of the starting buildings seemed quite confuse to us. Indeed, some buildings are placed on each player’s board, others are the initial ones and can be built by everybody, and the remaining ones are randomly chosen to be played on their front side or their “Dwelling” side (the back one) and are available from turn 1, 2 or 3. Maybe including these statuses on the boards would clarify this point.

Phases of a turn:
Phases 2 and 3 are not easy to understand because they are truly the original part of the game, and the difference between “first player” and “active player” is very important. Having read it twice, it seems quite clear, finally, but the first view requires attention, in particular about the visualization.

Mechanics:
First of all, once the setup done, you really feel the potential of the game thanks to the numerous buildings and the setup cards: at the beginning of the game, each town is different so each player will have to deal with it using what he has and what is available.

Lincoln cards also contextualize each game. They make Western Town kind of a delivery game in which one has to manage at best to satisfy a demand you know in advance.

During phase 2, the disadvantage of first player –who need to guess everything– is balanced by his rank for phase 3, during which playing first can be decisive. In our 3-player game, phase 2 was quickly done. Each one felt like missing actions, which is a proof that WT is a good game with tension.

The fact that you get in hand the card of a building as soon as you built it is quite similar to a deckbuilding game. I even made this funny mistake during turn 2: I discarded the card to draw it later the next turn instead of… This point made me think of the immediate effect of A few acres of snow, and I do appreciate that.

One building seems unavoidable at the beginning: the woodwork. Indeed, all of us used it during the first turns to get a 5- or 6-card hand, and the more the game goes on, the more difficult it is to play it. However, nobody built a second one. When reading this piece of advice, do not forget it was our first play; I am sure we did not see some “building” combos.

Phase 3 is merely awesome. It gives a tactical finesse which is very pleasant and a guessing aspect which is very original in this kind of game. We also found the option of playing a third action quite surprising , but the author told us we made a mistake with this point: a third action does not oblige you to pass. Knowing that, it now makes sense and I guess there are even more possibilities during this phase.

Indians seem well balanced. All of us played carefully and the threat was never too far. They attacked me twice but the consequences were not too dreadful: it only took me little time in my town’s development.

Final score (quite simple):
1/ Black houses. The idea of earning points thanks to who has the majority and also how many players rank after you is great and really original because differences between possible configurations matter.
2/ Lincoln’s wishes are a good idea, too, because they reward the whole game efforts and let the opportunity to come back during the last turns.
3/ Buildings. A way no one shall forget, especially the ones with Heroes and hanged cow-boys.

Even if everything is perfect, here, I think that buildings’ position should also be taken into account. Julien talked about a “main street”, and it is an interesting thing. In Carson City, for instance, position means points depending on the type of buildings and their place on the board. The immersion would be emphasized with this way to earn points during and/or at the end of the game. The author is working on that point, looking for a solution that would keep the game’s fluidity.

Another discussion to have after next game would be about the loop between Peace Pipe and Development points. Indeed, all my Peace Pipe points turned quite quickly into Development ones, so Development was no more important for me at the end of the game. Even if I was the Indians’ best target, was this a bad idea?

To conclude, I truly enjoyed this game. There are many combos, a good turnover with many different setups, and a very original interaction very well thought.

About the experience itself, I tried what seemed natural to me: Lincoln’s wishes. I finally got all the cards, even if Jokerounet was always close to me.

First, I took a Gold for the Nation strategy whereas Jokerounet was playing the Inhabitants and Tomstille was building a big city prison where one cow-boy out of two was hanged. Then, I developed my town to make it more attractive; Indians were not happy with that so they destroyed some dwellings. In the end, result was predictable: Jokerounet’s city was very polyvalent but this was not what Lincoln wanted so he earned less points (hey, this is a combo game, okay?), and Tomstille finally ranked second thanks to a point generator he was the only one to use.

Last word: to play again ASAP. ^^
2012-02-27
Owned
François Lenoir
France
flag msg tools
9
Feb 2012
very original, nervous and tense. After several parties, I think this game has a pretty steep learning curve.

The edition in 2012 is wonderful, I hope she'll see the day. For my part, it's done ! I subscribed to ulule !
2012-02-18
Preordered
Alka Zahr
msg tools
mbmbmb
9
Feb 2012
Owned
Greg Terrier
France
flag msg tools
9
Feb 2012
Preordered
Emmanuel Castanié
France
flag msg tools
mbmb
9
Feb 2012
Preordered
gautier dhordain
France
lille
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
9
Jan 2014
Owned
Benjamin Schoenheiter
Germany
Friedberg
Hessen
flag msg tools
publisher
Editor
badge
mbmbmbmbmb
9
Jun 2012
Had a chance to play this game at this year's Heidelberger Burgevent and it was an absolute blast. Even though it was 1am in the morning when we started - the rules are complex but easy to grasp after two rounds and I can't wait to see it again in Essen.

Thank you Olivier for the wonderful rules explanation

UPDATE: Played the final version now. Just as I remembered it - VERY good game. My first edition had misprinted tile backs - but don't let that discourage you.
2012-10-23
Owned
Henrik Prantl
Germany
Gießen
flag msg tools
9
Dec 2012
Owned
Aurèle Aubert
Switzerland
Vaud
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
9
Feb 2015
Owned
silvia eramo
Italy
Milano
flag msg tools
9
Nov 2012
Owned
Klaas Muurling
Netherlands
Leiden
Georgia
flag msg tools
Terra Mystica is one of my top favorites
mbmbmbmbmb
9
Nov 2012
Owned
Detlef Dölling
Germany
Nordrhein-Westfalen
flag msg tools
9
Oct 2012
Owned

1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5  Next »  [12]

Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.