|
Yoki's Top 100 Games of All Time
Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
I have maintained a Top 100 Games list since 2009. I used to just track it in and Excel spreadsheet and share it on GoogleDocs, but decided that a geeklist would be a lot more fun.
I've come to the conclusion that it makes most sense to put together my new Top 100 right on the cusp of SPIEL each year, as afterwards I'm too busy trying all the new hotness.
This year I abandoned my old system of generating my Top 100 Games in favor of the method Tom Vasel uses for his own list. I.e. I printed out cards for each game I considered a potential candidate, shuffled them together, pulled one at random and compared all the other games to it putting better games on its left and worse game on its right. Then I repeated the process with both the better and worse games until I had my list completed. Once any given stack was around 8 or so cards I would manually sort them and continue with another stack. It was a fun process and I hope someone enjoys seeing my results.
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
I have yet to try FFG's Silver Line edition of this game, but really like my old Eurogames Descartes edition. This game is one of the best area control games in my opinion.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
If you have young children you must hunt down a copy of Gulo Gulo to play with them. Nuff said!
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Here's another classic title that surprised me by how highly I ranked it using my new method of ranking. I have always had a soft spot for A&A and would gladly get out a case of beer and challenge a buddy to an evening of WWII-themed world conquest. However the competition from newer hotter titles had made me sort of forget about, plus how it's stored in my collection makes it easy to overlook (it's in a row of extra cabinets on top of the closets housing the rest of my games).
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
I do like Merkator more than most, but with so many variations on the basic gameplay included in the rules I'm having a hard time narrowing down which options I like best and where the game actually shines. So far I'm leaning towards the basic short game to being the best.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
There is no game that is as loud as a game of Isla Dorada with my gaming buddies. My wife and kids are prone to hiding it just so my gaming buddies don't pull it off the shelf. This game is gorgeous and very well produced. On top of that it features some incredibly funny gameplay where you need take heed not to make yourself out to be in the lead or you will get picked on like there is no tomorrow!
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
This is my second highest ranked dexterity game (I count Loopin' Louie as an action game). A la carte while hardly a world-beater is a very enjoyable family game. Flipping crepes in those little frying pans and trying to get just the right amount of the various seasonings make for a very enjoyable game. This game is also helped by both the Dessert and Spielbox expansions, especially the former and its menu cards.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
There's nothing quite so funny as the bloodshed this game causes amongst serious gamers. We've drawn blood on each other on numerous occasions, but still yearn for another shot at the totem. This is much more fun than it should be and I actually hope to score the Raving Rabbids version at SPIEL.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Jamaica is a great production, the game box looks like a pirate's treasure chest and when you open it there's the illusion of it being filled with gold as the back of the board is printed with tons of gleaming gold coins. This box also goes to show that you cannot go wrong with GameWorks in general, they definitely produce some of the best box inserts bar none. This one is no exception. However, the base game is greatly enhanced by the free expansion called Extra Treasures and it is the two in combo that I rank here.
-
-
84.
Board Game: Blokus
[Average Rating:7.14 Overall Rank:214]

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Blokus is not only one of my favorite abstract games, but it is also one of my favorite gateway games. For some reason the 4-player version of this game has just never failed to impress the people I introduce it to and it is a game that holds up to repeated play. I'm including Blokus Duo in this ranking, as I have clearly marked up the smaller 2-player 2-colors only board on my larger Blokus board.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Burg Appenzell (or Château Roquefort) surprises me even now as I enter it on this list, but there's something about this children's game that I really enjoy and once again it is much helped by its two expansions. First you should definitely get Cheesy Gonzola, but if you can be sure to nab a copy of the free promo called Burg Appenzell Erweiterung: Völlig mausgeflippt. The former contains a box insert that works almost as an extension to the main game, making it possible to store the base game ready for play, while the latter contains just two double-sided tiles that manage to add a whole other level to the game. Its the complete package that I rank at #85.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
If you have a large Lego collection at home, then give Mechaton a spin. It's a game for building mechas and duking it out in objective based scenarios. I've even made a Car Wars variant using the same rules and it proved to work quite well at the first test drive.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
I'm not even convinced that Telestrations is a game and not just a party activity, but it's so damn much fun and included in the BGG database that I'm including it at spot #87 of my list.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Seriously, tell me you haven't at least once wanted to smack one of your gaming buddies in the head with a club? Well here's your chance, become an Aargh!Tect and guide your cave-dwelling building crew in erecting cutting edge shelter and avant guard art. Oh, you reward them with a tap on the head for being right, and two giant smacks for being wrong!
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
So this entry is sort of my catch-all category for Car Wars, but the game is greatly enhanced by this expansion and its dueling league rules and how you start and run a corporate auto duel team.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
I bought Das Magische Labyrinth at SPIEL '09 to play with my kids, but have probably played it as much ,if not more, with my gaming buddies. This is a fun little quick game.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Summoner Wars is yet another game that I have tried to use to fill the void left by Magic: the Gathering. I've barely scratched the surface of Summoner Wars yet, but quite like it and hope to play it much more.
-
-
92.
Board Game: Samurai
[Average Rating:7.48 Overall Rank:81]

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Samurai won me over with pure looks, but then backed it up with very enjoyable abstract-like gameplay. That is what the game feels like, an abstract with a veneer of a feudal Japanese theme put on top of it, but as good as the gameplay is and as pretty as the components are you just don't have the will to argue about it and instead settle in to enjoy it.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Okay, I fell in love with Ice Flow at SPIEL '09, have played it very little since but still like it a lot and it has been included on each of my Top 100 lists. It is a racing game across the Bering Straits. The components are great looking and functional, and the game plays much like a good abstract game. It is highly competitive and you can easily screw with the other players.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Wow, Giro Galoppo remained in my Top 100 while Ave Caesar dropped out. Well, this game is great! It looks like a cute little children's game about equestrian races, but is underneath its cute looks a vicious racing game where you do your best to mess up for the other riders.
-
-
95.
Board Game: Le Havre
[Average Rating:8.09 Overall Rank:7]

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
I find Le Havre very enjoyable and not nearly as stress-inducing as Agricola for instance, however I also greatly prefer the latter to the former.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Alright, confession time. I'm a recovered Magic addict. Now I only play it on the PC or console, but would have a hard time resisting temptation should my friends pick it up. It was one of the first games that my wife and I played together.
-
-
97.
Board Game: FITS
[Average Rating:6.75 Overall Rank:578]

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
FITS is most likely in my Top 100 for the last time, but don't take that to mean that it's not a very good game. FITS is quite good and works very well with everything from kids to casual gamers to your gaming buddies. If someone has played Tetris (which is highly likely) then this game is quick to impress.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Fun game that works best with peers and not as well as a mixed-age family game. I've played it mostly with my gaming buddies and we always have a great time playing it.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
My only print-and-play game on the Top 100. This is a brilliant Yahtzee variant with ten different events of massive dice chucking. It plays quickly and is a ton of fun. Be sure to download the great score sheets in the files section as the can then easily be laminated and used over and over for repeated play.
-
-

Yoki Erdtman
Sweden Södertälje
Handsome devil huh?
-
Glory in the Arena is a Roman gladiatorial miniatures combat game that works very well as a filler for miniatures fans. A single 1-on-1 combat plays from start to finish easily in 10 minutes. Given that the game's free what are you waiting for?
-
-
|
|
|