$18.00
GeekGold Bonus for All Supporters: 108.04

6,709 Supporters

$15 min for supporter badge & GeekGold bonus
42.3% of Goal | left

Support:

Recommend
4 
 Thumb up
 Hide
3 Posts

Bardagi: The Claim for Gold» Forums » Reviews

Subject: Geeks Under Grace Review: Bardagi rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Chris Hecox
United States
Fort Wayne
Indiana
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
Original Review at: http://www.geeksundergrace.com/gaming/review-bardagi-the-cla...

Introduction

Gamia Games brings us Bardagi: The Claim for Gold, from designer Svavar Björgvinsson. I’d be remiss to mention artist Valentina Scamardì. Scamardì also worked on Master: Become a Hero, also from Gamia Games. The company is also at work on one other title: Ancient Aliens: Creators of Civilization.

Bardagi: The Claim for Gold was successfully funded on Kickstarter within 20 hours of launch in early 2016. At the time of this writing, Bardagi is currently shipping to backers. Svavar also designed Ancient Aliens, along with smaller titles like: Rally, Vikings, and the Xmas Game.

Gameplay

Calling all viking tribesmen! The High Jarl has released an edict to all worthy axe-bearers to take up tools and weapons. The task: conquer lands from the heathen barbarians, command resources, and build a tribal empire. Aye, to please the gods might be a virtuous ploy, but your religious conversions won’t do naught but bring more to the fold for the goal of subjugation of the terra!

Axes! Ore! Magic runes! Leather! Chicken? Wool? What are we going to use wool for?

These are tools of the trade in Bardagi. Players select a color/tribe and set out on a journey for mad viking conquest. Of course, aside from conquering areas with your Berserker, you can also convert barbarians with the magic of your Godi, or even bribe them with the gold from your Kaupmadur trader. Players also have a Knerrir unit (boat) that allows for movement over the treacherous seas.

Each player begins home base with little discs that represent many different game mechanics (i.e. strength of troops, gold to trade, magic power, area domination). Players use cards to play out turns, with each one activating one of their four units. Each unit has a different method of taking over territory, along with special bonuses that can only be activated at villages, or barbarian encampment, for example.

Players will gain resources and glory (victory points) from each area they control at the end of the round. These resources are used to construct building upgrades for their units. Upgrades grant glory, but also increase the discs they can hold, strengthen units, or give extra gold or glory for controlling specific resources. Players can also receive and play magic runes that can double resource production, block a resource, or even increase movement speed.

The game ends either on a decided real-time limit, or once a number of rounds have been played (dependent on player count). Players tally points from their gold, resource trade-ins, and receive extra points for controlling most land or amassing most gold. The player with the most glory at the end of the game is the winner.

Author’s Note: I should be forthright: as you can tell from my photos (on the original review link), my version of the game bears some, not all Kickstarter exclusive components. My review will cover the components I own, but I won’t go into the components I don’t have.

Components, Artwork, and Theme

Bardagi is excellent to look at. The game is bathed in beautiful, vibrant colors. The board is outstandingly detailed, depicting mountainous vistas, encampment, deserted islands, and highly-contested river bridges. The player cards and home base tableaus are also intricate and worth admiring for more than a few minutes. Each unit illustration is fascinating and has a unique flavor. For example, the Kaupmadur isn’t just a bearded local viking trader. He carries a sack of gold, wears eccentric clothing, and grins uneasily.

The component quality varies from mediocre to marvelous. The unit miniatures are muddled and bent out of shape. I’m glad to have them, but I’m spoiled by Star Wars: Imperial Assault, so I’m relatively uninterested. These player discs hearken to a younger time in my life when dropping half-opaque discs on a Bingo mat was acceptable for entertainment. While it’s difficult to teach, I’m okay with utilizing the provided discs for multiple purposes. This reminds me of cards doubling as buildings and gold in San Juan.

Those things said, I adore the upgraded resource components. I can jingle faux-metal coins in my hand, simulating my royal wealth. I can stack cattle and sheep meeples just because. The fat stone blocks pair nicely with the slant on the red ore slabs. The mysterious artwork on the rune chits is eye-catching, even if I need to refer to the on-board legend. The game also ships with trays to hold components, which is lovely.

Strategy in Bardagi

Bardagi straddles the line of civ-building and area control, but doesn’t really fall into either category. Upgrading buildings provides new skills, but it doesn’t feel like a tech tree. Controlling land is integral to winning, but you aren’t really bringing big armies into combat like Kemet or Blood Rage. If anything, it plays as an adventure game, like Runebound. Sure, you aren’t worried about quests, but you definitely have a reason to travel and explore the lands, gaining plunder for your efforts.

Bardagi is clearly a euro at heart. You always end your turn wishing you could have completed just one or two more actions. This feels entirely balanced, because no matter your perceived efficiency, everyone else finished their turn feeling the same. This does pick up a tad in later rounds, as players gain two additional actions a turn. I suppose thematically, this simulates the growth of your land and population, allowing for more production and actions.

What I find interesting is despite a few hot zones early in the game, players keep to themselves. There isn’t a need to fight for land because the bloodshed is too costly, and neither player benefits from the cost. Depending on player count, somewhere around the 6th or 7th round, the game flips a switch. Chaos and war erupt among the tribes, with players viciously planning turns, AP setting in furiously.

With two sides to the game board, players have to decide which expansion is most valuable to them. Quickly claiming the outer regions of your borders will be important to halting late-game expansion from your enemies. This is going to waste lots of turns, and hurt your resource production. Maybe you want to consider taking a boat out and claiming islands? A player must decide which islands to bolster with units, and how many actions they can spend before they need to return home. I didn’t mention earlier, but once a unit runs out of discs, they must return to home base and pay a sum of wool, meat, or leather to refill their disc count. This back-and-forth limits your reach, and forces you to return home and report back to the village after long voyages for glory.

Of course, there are plenty of other benefits to units and board spaces. Players will want to capture gold to boost glory per turn. By capturing a village, you receive a free recruit every turn to add to a unit of your choice. By overtaking a barbarian encampment, you can drop axes onto key areas to boost its defense by two points. By visiting holy rune sites, you can collect additional runes for casting spells on your foes.

The Good and the Bad

Bardagi appeals to a very specific audience. These people like games that seem heavy upfront, but devolve into simple gameplay after a few games. The complexity comes from other players. You can get boxed into your home base pretty early in the game, but maybe you’d rather push into enemy territory and make it difficult for them to expand. Aside from random building tile and rune drawing, Bardagi is completely devoid of luck. Player skill and optimization are king. Gameplay is deterministic.

It feels like what Small World could be: fun. Here, the complexity of units and becoming most efficient with your order of actions is critical to success. Of course, your carefully laid plans could be entirely ruined by smart counterplay of your opponents.

Each turn bears so many things to think about. Where do you leave your Godi for extra resource gain? Why did you need your Kaupmadur to end 2 spaces from that village instead of 3? Did you need to refill your Berserker on the last action, or was it fine to use his last two discs on the ore deposit? Opening moves seem apparent, but I can definitely imagine optimal opening plays developing from an experienced group.

While I have received some clarification from Svavar on rules, I did find the rulebook overly comprehensive and confusing. We had to take some time figuring out how to move onto and around areas with rivers or harbors.

I’m not sure if it’s a bad thing about the game, but strategy is not at all apparent. There are many routes to victory and glory. You will gain from controlling land, and from controlling gold, but you also have to balance your resources and upgrades. There is a lot to think on, but figuring out how and why you need to place all of your discs is a bear.

Finally, I think the game is fun, but long. Even though in one game we chugged along nicely at 2 players, I felt it stretched for no reason. I think you can get the same amount of fun from 5-6 rounds, but the game doesn’t really develop fully until after an hour in. Once you approach 7-8 rounds, things become cutthroat and exciting, but also drawn out. When you realize it’s time to overtake enemy lands, analysis paralysis kicks in hard. This isn’t a bad thing about the game, but by the time it gets really interesting, I’m mentally checked out, because I’ve already been scheming and planning my inefficient turns up to this point.

Final Thoughts

Overall, I think Bardagi: The Claim for Gold works. The components are wonderful, the game has lots of variability baked in, and it offers plenty of room to try wacky strategies and destroy your enemies. It might be worth watching a gameplay video to see if this fits your fancy, however.

I’d like to write more but… I must rally, for I need to board the Knerrir forward to glory! Toodles.

POSITIVES
+ Beautiful artwork and component quality
+ Lots of variety in unit powers, resources, and upgrades
+ Scales reasonably well with more players

NEGATIVES
- Rulebook is mostly comprehensive but feels a tad messy and jumbled
- Strategy is not apparent and requires examples and personal failure to reveal itself
- Games are longer than they should be


A copy of Bardagi: The Claim for Gold was provided by Gamia Games for a fair and honest review.
See more of our reviews on our Geeklist: https://boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/211382/geeks-under-grace-...
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Ray Smith
United States
Newburg
Pennsylvania
flag msg tools
designer
Stay thirsty my friends.
mbmbmbmbmb
Thank you so much, Chris, for the fine overview!

Bardagi has fascinated me since it's release, apparently being right up my play alley. I'm a bit underwhelmed from its lack of buzz, but for me, different is always good.

After watching the well done tutorial, my only concern is the prolific typos exhibited. The rules look nicely cleaned up, but you voice a slight concern. Is it an organization thing, or is it just a different style game to wrap your head around? Also, you still enjoying its play?

Thanks again, and best wishes.

Ray
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Chris Hecox
United States
Fort Wayne
Indiana
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
rdsmith wrote:
Thank you so much, Chris, for the fine overview!

Bardagi has fascinated me since it's release, apparently being right up my play alley. I'm a bit underwhelmed from its lack of buzz, but for me, different is always good.

After watching the well done tutorial, my only concern is the prolific typos exhibited. The rules look nicely cleaned up, but you voice a slight concern. Is it an organization thing, or is it just a different style game to wrap your head around? Also, you still enjoying its play?

Thanks again, and best wishes.

Ray


Thanks for the thoughts, Ray!

I actually have not played it with my group since my review, so it's been a while (mostly because of my glut of other review games, atm).

If you enjoy area control with definitive euro elements, resource allocation, player powers, and a minimal tech tree, I think this could be a choice for you. So much, insofar, as I would say it's worth overlooking the rulebook issues. I would say that for any game though.

The rulebook is far from exceptional, and I remember having a lot of problems figuring out what means what and why things are organized the way they are.

It's not a particularly innovative game, but I think it does area control in a cool way. Granted, in our games, there wasn't too much conflict, except towards the very end. Lots of chances to negotiate other players from creeping too closely into your territory.

It's a fine game, just depends on your tastes, I suppose.
2 
 Thumb up
1.00
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.