The Hotness
Games|People|Company
Dominion: Dark Ages
Fantastiqa
Mage Knight: Board Game
Total War
Descent: Journeys in the Dark (Second Edition)
Eclipse
Mice and Mystics
Dungeon Fighter
Collapsible D: The Final Minutes of the Titanic
Lords of Waterdeep
Agricola: All Creatures Big and Small
Libertalia
Android: Netrunner
Virgin Queen
The Lord of the Rings: Nazgul
A Game of Thrones: The Board Game (Second Edition)
Dominion
Star Wars: X-Wing Miniatures Game
Infiltration
The Lord of the Rings: The Card Game
Among the Stars
Twilight Struggle
The Swarm
Agricola
1989: Dawn of Freedom
Goa
7 Wonders
Glory to Rome
Arkham Horror
Village
Ora et Labora
Battles of Westeros: House Baratheon Army Expansion
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Thunder Road
Trajan
Zombicide
The Castles of Burgundy
7 Wonders: Cities
Ace of Spies
War of the Ring
Skyline
Space Alert
Sherlock Holmes Consulting Detective
City of Horror
Race for the Galaxy
Dungeon Command: Sting of Lolth
Twilight Imperium (third edition)
Kingdom Builder
Le Havre
Battlestar Galactica
Recommend
98 
 Thumb up
 Thumb up
118 Posts
1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5  Next »   | 

Merchant of Venus» Forums » General

Subject: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less) w/ pics rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: cheap_MoV_PnP [+] forum [+] watching [+] [View All]
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I've seen a fair number of posts recently despairing over the cost and skill it takes to do the amazing dathkaden remake of Merchant of Venus.

On the contrary, I did mine for under $40 USD (and could have done it for even less by skipping a couple things like a fabric draw bag). And my artistic skill is very limited. Fortunately, dathkaden did all the amazing artistic work of all the graphics and files for this. Also fortunately, doing this mostly requires things like cutting a straight edge (for instance with a paper guillotine chopper which involves just moving a lever with a blade on it), and sticking stickers and squeezing the handle of a circle punch. Granted, it might not look quite as nice as the $200 copies people have done, but it looks pretty decent if I might say so myself


It does take a bit of time, but most of it was spent planning (such as what I wanted to print out and materials to use, and how to do this easily and cheaply) and doing things like working on proofing the rules rewrite (I think I spent more hours on that than actually making it, and I put the effort in so you guys don't have to )
My guess is actual construction time was under 20 hours, and could probably be done less than half that if I did it again.

First the gamebox.
This was a thrift store find that someone generously gave to me. I used sheet labels on it. It came out quite well.


Second the opened game box and the rules.The rules remake printing of just the core booklet cost me a bit over $2 total to print, but there's an artscow sale right now to print a booklet for cheap as well.


Third the wood discs.
I used Rit powdered fabric dye (a $1.50 box at walmart is sufficient to do all the discs needed for the remake). I used the 1/4 tsp per 50ml amount that someone researched in another thread and soaked them for 2 hours. I didn't notice any warping of any of the three sizes at that amount of time. This is MUCH MUCH cheaper and MUCH MUCH less effort than getting painted disks or painting them yourself. Or if you are happy with the unfinished wood look, you can save some time and a little money by skipping this.


Here's the 3 sizes of wood discs and how they turned out when finished. My total label sheet costs for the wood discs was under $2


For the culture markers, I used a dollar store set of felt tip pens (I didn't want to buy a bunch of paints or dyes) to color the edges of the discs. I'm quite pleased with how that turned out, it matched up pretty nicely to the printed labels.


Fourth the gameboard
I used a thrift store old Clue gameboard (just under 20"x20") a friend generously gave me. I printed out four 11x17 sheet labels and cut them to size (the quad fold board had sections of just a bit under 10" so the 8.5x11 sheet labels aren't wide enough) and stuck them down. Bang, done. It cost me under $2 for the finished gameboard. I've seen posts of people paying lots of money for custom prints of the board, or mounting it on foamcore board, etc. I wanted something cheap and portable, and I don't think you can get much cheaper than this


Fifth, market boards, currency, ship boards, etc.
The currency was one of the most expensive parts, costing me nearly $5 to print (I could have cut the costs down about half if I didn't print the backs with the currency backs file).


Sixth, the ships. I just printed and used the ship standees on cardstock (cost me under 50 cents). There's other alternative space ships you can use that have been discussed in the forums, many of them can be found in relatively inexpensive OOP games on ebay.


Oh and I threw in a set of 4 dice from my chessex pound of dice bag I bought a long time ago. You can use any dice, such as from thrift finds.


Finally, I also purchased a fabric draw bag (I don't have pictures of it yet) to draw the tiles out of, that cost me about $5. You can also use a gift bag or some other container if you want to save the cost of doing that.
Here's the fabric I selected:
http://www.equilter.com/cgi-bin/webc.cgi/st_prod.html?p_prod...

Costs:
I used a business color laser printer that is contracted at a flat 9 cents a color page, and is capable of printing a bit over 11" wide (this is important for printing the 11x17 sheets, you can do without the larger size sheet labels if you don't print the box and/or use a smaller or differant game board that doesn't need that size). I used normal copy paper that was on sale for $1.50 a ream (or about 1/3 cent a page). Cardstock I purchased from the local Kellys Paper (they are a paper specialty store) for $11.89 per ream of 110lb (or about 5 cents per page including tax).

Sheet labels were purchased from:
http://www.sheet-labels.com
They seem to work quite well in the color laser I was using, and they sold 11"x17" size which was important for the gameboard and gamebox size and methods I used. And the final thing that decided me on ordered from them was that they guarantee them. In the quantities I ordered them at, it was down to 12 cents per page for 8.5"x11" and 36 cents per page for 11"x17" (that includes shipping/tax). Its almost as expensive to get low numbers of sheets like 20 pages as it is to get 100 pages, so I suggest a quantity of 100 each and use the rest for future projects).

The wood discs were purchased from:
http://caseyswood.com
For a quantity sufficient for the remake including combat (you can save a bit if you skip that) it cost me $13.19 including tax and shipping at the quantities I ordered at (I got some extra to make a 2nd copy for someone). The largest quantity of discs (the 3/4") I got were under 3 cents a piece.

If you only desire to make a single copy and don't want any extra sheet labels (very handy) or discs (also handy), then you can probably team up with a nearby fellow gamer who is interested in those things to reduce the cost.




For tools, I purchased 2 circle paper punches from local craft stores, the 3/4" and the 1" (for the largest number of discs). A scissors was used for the culture 1.25" discs since there are only 14 of them. If I remember right, I got them at Michaels when they were on sale (often you can get 40% or 50% off coupons that you can use on the punches, that should bring them down to something near $5 each). I only included the materials, and not the tools in my total cost estimate. But even if you include two circle punches for say a total of $12, that's still under $50 for the remake.
The other tools I used were things like a razor blade knife, a cutting board, scissors, ruler, a guillotine paper cutter (you can use scissors if you can't get access to one of these, but they REALLY cut down on the time and effort and do a much better job than scissors at the straight cuts).

To help speed up the paper disc punching/sticking it greatly helps to have a second person, but you can do it yourself if needed. Also, if you run the knife (in this case it was a utility knife with a fresh blade) very lightly down the back of each row of stickers, its much easier to crack and peel them to stick onto the discs. The knife comes in handy to separate the very few that don't crack & peel very well or a fingernail works too. If you use a fingernail, curve the sticker as you are holding it to stiffen the edges.

And thats about it!

I will try and get pictures of the draw bag and the game when its being played, and if you have any questions feel free to ask.
55 
 Thumb up
0.86
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Thu May 6, 2010 7:44 pm (Total Number of Edits: 21)
  • Posted Fri Jan 29, 2010 2:10 am
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
The Rit fabric dye thread that I got the concentration from:
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/335295/dying-wooden-game...

A couple of pics of some tools, like the guillotine paper cutter, and a circle paper punch. Be careful when using tools, for instance don't chop your fingers off in the paper cutter.

I was able to cut nearly everything with that paper cutter, since it was all long square cuts. The ship standees I had to use a scissors for, but they are ALSO straight cuts, so its very easy to scissor them. Of course for the discs I used the circle punches on the sticker sheets. The larger 14 culture discs I actually "cheated" on because I asked my sister to cut those stickers out.

The circle punches (especially the 3/4" size) lasted surprisingly well, especially considering that the 3/4" punch was used for about 800 or so punches. I belive the picture below is the actual one I used.I never needed to sharpen it, but I probably will if I do a 2nd copy (you can sharpen them by punching through foil from what I hear).




If you want to see the differance between my $40 copy and a $200 copy, take a look at how wolfzell did his:
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/466460/dathkadan-remake-...

Main differances would be things like 10 euro cents per custom painted wood disc, laminating the sticker sheets (13 euro total for the laminated stickers), laminated vinyl gameboard print (18 euro), special hardened foam type custom cut board for gameboard base and ship boards base (55 euros), etc.

His does look nicer, but my goal with mine was to do it for a low cost. And I don't think mine looks TOO shabby
6 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Fri Jan 29, 2010 5:49 am (Total Number of Edits: 10)
  • Posted Fri Jan 29, 2010 2:11 am
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Anthony Baldassar
United States
Visalia
California
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
Great looking - Thanks for sharing
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
John Snyderâ„¢
United States
Fresno
California
flag msg tools
You and the Cap'n make it hap'n
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
Looks awesome Will, can't wait to give it a spin!
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Rob Rob
United States
La Mesa
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
Quote:
Rit fabric dye

Wow, great idea! surprise
3 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Nick Hayes
United States
Los Angeles
California
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
You really did a fantastic job. Thanks for the link to the label paper company. That solved my box wrapping problems!
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Liam Merlot
Australia
Melbourne
Victoria
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
Do you have a link to the file for the box art? I can't find it.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Joe Aguayo
United States
Fresno
California
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
Having seen Will's version in person, it's hard to believe he actually made it himself. This is the first time I've heard anything about how much it cost. For as good as it looks, I'm amazed.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Re: Making Dathkaden MoV remake on the cheap ($40 or less)
Thanks guys for the comments and compliments!

And thanks for the topic thumbs (at the top). That helps give the thread more exposure and I'm glad to have more people see how you can do the MoV remake without spending a pile of money if they want. Hopefully seeing increased interest in MoV will encourage companies to try and reprint the game at some point in the future as well.

Dr Corey wrote:
Do you have a link to the file for the box art? I can't find it.

Yes, its the reference/market board back graphics from dathkaden. I can't take credit for the idea since I saw it in one of the pics from someone else who did it
I didn't bother to print backs on my market boards, and the reference boards I used the back on them to print the relic reference.

Here's the link:
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/filepage/32521/custom-backs-wit...

Here's the pic that gave me the idea (its one someone else did):

The lighting and angle on my photo in the first post are pretty crappy in comparision to his. I think the quality of my color laser print is pretty good though. I'll try and take a better shot if I can.




Robrob wrote:
Yargo wrote:
Rit fabric dye

Wow, great idea! surprise

It's not actually my idea, but I agree, its a great idea. I linked one of the most usefull rit dye threads (I think its the one where I got the idea, but I'm not 100% sure). I mean its not like people are leaving the wood discs outside in the weather and sunlight to degrade the dye, so it might even last longer than paint since its soaked into the wood. Plus its much cheaper and much less work.

Black Canyon wrote:
You really did a fantastic job. Thanks for the link to the label paper company. That solved my box wrapping problems!

Thanks!
No problem! I've been very happy with my purchase from them. I just bought the cheapest sheet labels but they have a wide range of materials you can get them in (like gloss, foil, weatherproof, etc)

I sized and cut the labels to exactly fit the box (I used one 11x17 for the top, and cut each of the 4 sides out individually from another sheet), but I think what I should have done is made them wrap around a bit longer. Most gameboxes you can see they wrap around the bottom edge so as to look better, I didn't do that and I probably should have. And I should have made the sides wrap up a bit past the top so as to hide the edge. Fortunately the box top was black, so the edge isn't easy to spot anyway. In that case I might end up needing a small bit of glue on the wrapped bit since wrapping around is much harder to stick down than a flat surface.

Just wanted to throw a few of my thoughts out there about the box after I did it, maybe you can make use of them
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Fri Jan 29, 2010 6:02 am (Total Number of Edits: 10)
  • Posted Fri Jan 29, 2010 5:16 am
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Slev Sleddeddan
United Kingdom
Victoria Park
Manchester
What part of "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn" don't you understand?
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Yargo wrote:
working on proofing the rules rewrite (I think I spent more hours on that than actually making it, and I put the effort in so you guys don't have to )


Yeah, it's been a beast, but a big and very public thank-you for the help!

I need to get working on my version and post the finished results here!
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Ok, some more pics (I have a couple more in my gallery as well)

First another one of the game box, a bit better lighting and angle (although still not great).



A couple pics of the start of a 2 player game:



A pic of the 2 player game end:

The final sale of the game put my brother over $1,000 (we were playing a short game), AND it put me over as well since he sold at my spaceport and the commission was enough to put me over $1,000. But since it was his turn he declared victory
7 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Fri Jan 29, 2010 4:12 pm (Total Number of Edits: 1)
  • Posted Fri Jan 29, 2010 4:09 pm
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Robert Cannon
United States
ATLANTA
GA
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I am unable to find a remake of the rules in the file section. Is it there or somewhere else?

Beautiful job. You've inspired me. I wanted to play my original copy with my son, but I think we might have a project first.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
robcannonsoftware wrote:
I am unable to find a remake of the rules in the file section. Is it there or somewhere else?

Beautiful job. You've inspired me. I wanted to play my original copy with my son, but I think we might have a project first.


Wow, thanks. I'm glad to hear that someone else is making this. Its really a fantastic looking game after you finish.

Keep in mind that you can skip making the combat tokens (they are on a separate file), and while you are in the process of making it, you can even start to play before you finish some of the other stuff. For instance, I played a sample game only to $1000 and I hadn't finished the individually colored player spaceport/factory tokens, because usually if you are playing that short of a game, there's not much of that going on. Plus, you can wait on the variants for your first games (or just skip them entirely if you prefer the original gameplay).

You also may be able to get sheet labels cheaper at a local store if you just want a few of them, since you won't have to pay shipping. In my case it was cheaper online since I ordered about 100 sheet labels of each size because I plan to use them for other projects (such as another Merchant of Venus for a friend).

As for the rules, they are in the rules re-write thread. I'm helping (as have several others) with a final proofreading, but they should be done by the time you finish making it

Anyway, there's links in the re-write thread that was just recently posted, and also some links in the older re-write thread posted a while back.

Its not uploaded to BGG yet because its still in progress of being edited. I think the rules themselves are all ok now, its just the grammer/spelling kinda stuff and little tweaks to make things more clear. The core rule booklet and variant booklet are mostly finished proofing, and the main task remaining is the gazateer which is entirely flavor text (like descriptions of the alien races, descriptions of each mercenary band, lore and legends of the MoV galaxy, etc).

The graphics on the re-write are very nice too.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Liam Merlot
Australia
Melbourne
Victoria
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I've started work on my version, but even though I am aiming at similar quality it is looking like more like $100, as for a few key things I just haven't been able to get them anywhere nearly as cheap as you (eg wood from Caseys was about US$40 for me including shipping and the cheapest I can find the labels is US$26).

The one thing holding me up in my planning at the moment is the board. How did you split the file into four for the printing?
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Dr Corey wrote:
I've started work on my version, but even though I am aiming at similar quality it is looking like more like $100, as for a few key things I just haven't been able to get them anywhere nearly as cheap as you (eg wood from Caseys was about US$40 for me including shipping and the cheapest I can find the labels is US$26).

The one thing holding me up in my planning at the moment is the board. How did you split the file into four for the printing?


For me, in california USA, the total wood disc cost to do a basic non variants copy came out as $26 total including shipping.

However, the actual price for the wood parts for the basic copy I did was closer to $15 because of the quantity discount. I bought enough to do more than just 1 copy (I wanted to make one for a friend), and its nice to have extra wood discs even if you only intend to make 1 copy of the game.

The sheet label thing is even more of a discount for larger quantities. If you get 5 sheet labels that are 11x17 and 25 of the 8.5x11 ones, then its a total of $40.88 to ship it to me. However, if you get 100 of each its just over $10 more for the order and the cost per sheet drops hugely. Thats more than enough to do 2 copies, and the cost per copy for sheet labels would drop to around $25 each from $40.

Sheet labels are incredibly usefull for many projects. For instance, if you have Tales of Arabia, there's a little bit on the lower right of the game board map that they forgot to do a connection. Its easy and cheap to patch that up with a label sheet that one of the guys (an admin I think?) uploaded to the BGG file section. You can use sheet labels to do paste-ups on german game components. You can use them on cheap common magic cards if you need to have some custom cards for a project (like if you want to do a larger loyalty deck in BSG to support more players in the base game using the file here on BGG).

The country you live in is Austrailia, so I don't know how much extra the shipping would be to there, etc.

What I did for the file was use a graphics program to cut and split it.

I used the free paint.net program to do that (its far more useful than the paint program that comes with windows and its free and doesn't annoy you by asking for money)
It has a readout at the bottom in the picture dimensions of how far your cursor is over the picture. So I drew a box in exactly the middle and cut out that quarter and pasted it into a new document and saved it. I verified the sizes were 2000x2000 pixels (I belive the original board file was 4000x4000) and did that for each quadrant. I then printed it up. I used the free photo viewing program called irfanview to print it, since you can specify the sizes to print at. In my case the board I think was 19.5"x19.5" and I think I ended up wanting to have it 19"x19" to allow a little margin, so that means each quadrant I told irfanview to go with 9.5"x9.5" for a print size

Paint.net link:
http://www.getpaint.net
IrFanView link:
http://www.irfanview.com


So to summarize:
If you order the wood discs online from caseys at a quantity only enough to do one copy of MoV and no other projects, expect to pay something around $26 in wood costs for MoV if you are in USA. This price is still reasonable.

If you order sheet labels online at the place I linked (and probably others) in a quantity just barely enough to do a single basic copy, expect to pay something around $40 for the costs of doing one MoV and no other projects. I don't consider that price reasonable. At this price and quantity (because of shipping) it would probably be cheaper to get the label sheets locally at a specialty paper shop or at the local equivalent of officemax, rather than order them online. Like I know places like officemax sells label sheets at around $1 per sheet in a pack of 10. Thats almost 10 times more expensive per sheet than my 11 cents per sheet label page cost, but overall paying $10 might work out to be cheaper overall if not using the labels for other things.

Here's an example of a pack of 100 sheet labels at staples for $18:
http://www.staples.com/Staples-White-Inkjet-Laser-Full-Sheet...

Or a pack of 25 for $12.49 at officemax that should be enough for 1 copy of MoV:
Avery White Full-Sheet Shipping Labels for Laser Printers 5265, 8-1/2" x 11", Pack of 25
http://www.officemax.com/catalog/sku.jsp?productId=ARS27945

So, in quantities just enough to do one copy in USA, someone would be looking at $26 for the wood discs online, and $13 for the label sheets locally, so around $40 for the main parts.

That wouldn't cover the 11x17 labels though. I haven't looked into if thats possible to get from local paper specialty store, but even if not, there are other possible options. One could use a smaller board (17"x17" board instead of 20"x20" board that should fit four 8.5x11 sheets), or get a piece of foamcore board and do a 3x3 grid of 8.5x11 sheet labels on it, or get some 11x17 normal paper and glue it down manually, or check into a local copy shop to see how much they'd charge to print up a poster for you. I did a quick check online at a photo place I used before and they do a 20"x30" poster for $20 and only a couple bucks shipping.

So worst case scenario for someone in USA looking to not have any extra materials left over after doing just 1 it's not going to be terribly more in total than what I did it for for those materials.
3 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Mon Feb 1, 2010 4:57 am (Total Number of Edits: 15)
  • Posted Mon Feb 1, 2010 3:24 am
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Liam Merlot
Australia
Melbourne
Victoria
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Thanks for the help.

I think the wood was $22 plus $14 shipping to Oz (so $36 not $40), and I can get 100 labels for $26, but I don't know what else I will use them for so no idea as to how much of that cost to ascribe directly to my copy of MoV. This is one of those projects where the total cost is made up of a lot of little costs so even though the main components aren't too bad, there will be a lot of extra $10-20 costs that will soon start to add up.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Dr Corey wrote:
Thanks for the help.

I think the wood was $22 plus $14 shipping to Oz (so $36 not $40), and I can get 100 labels for $26, but I don't know what else I will use them for so no idea as to how much of that cost to ascribe directly to my copy of MoV. This is one of those projects where the total cost is made up of a lot of little costs so even though the main components aren't too bad, there will be a lot of extra $10-20 costs that will soon start to add up.


I've done a pile of edits to the post right above yours, so check that over again, I added some ideas for other ways to get cheaper on parts if you don't need extra. For instance, getting a small pack of 8.5"x11" sheet labels at the local office supply store (without the combat variant there's only about 10 label sheets you need to print for the discs for front and back, and you can skip the back of some like the culture discs). So getting a 25 pack of label sheets locally would end up being less from my quick price check here in USA.

Also, maybe check into a wood disc source down there? I have no clue where to start in terms of that, but surely someone in the country sells wood discs
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Mon Feb 1, 2010 5:08 am (Total Number of Edits: 1)
  • Posted Mon Feb 1, 2010 5:06 am
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Liam Merlot
Australia
Melbourne
Victoria
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
The costs are all fine and I have ordered my wood from Caseys. It now is a matter of whether it is worth spending a lot of time searching for an elusive $5-10 saving on various parts. I will have a few extra costs but it is within the ball park for what I was looking at spending anyway. What I will end up with will still be better quality and cheaper than buying a copy off eBay.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Slev Sleddeddan
United Kingdom
Victoria Park
Manchester
What part of "Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn" don't you understand?
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Yargo wrote:
robcannonsoftware wrote:
I am unable to find a remake of the rules in the file section. Is it there or somewhere else?


As for the rules, they are in the rules re-write thread. I'm helping (as have several others) with a final proofreading, but they should be done by the time you finish making it

Anyway, there's links in the re-write thread that was just recently posted, and also some links in the older re-write thread posted a while back.

Its not uploaded to BGG yet because its still in progress of being edited. I think the rules themselves are all ok now, its just the grammer/spelling kinda stuff and little tweaks to make things more clear. The core rule booklet and variant booklet are mostly finished proofing, and the main task remaining is the gazateer which is entirely flavor text (like descriptions of the alien races, descriptions of each mercenary band, lore and legends of the MoV galaxy, etc).


Given the file sizes, it's unlikely they'll find their way onto BGG, but if necessary I'll host then for as long as I am able once finished.

It's taken my various collaborators and I ten months (!) to make it this far, and it's *almost* finished. I can hardly wait to hold a finished Artscow print in my grubby hands!
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Michael Ledlow
United States
Overland Park
Kansas
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Will,

Thanks for documenting your project! I LOVE MoV - played it a lot in the nineties. I ended up selling my two copies a year ago due to severe economic circumstances. I couldn't look my wife in the eye and insist on keeping a game, when money was so tight at the time. Recently, I ran a MoV search on eBay. They are selling for $100 - $200 a game! I miss MoV and want to play again!

I hadn't even thought of building my own version, until I ran across Game Board Geek BOARD GAME GEEK (god, I am getting old) and your thread on the forum. I'll be putting together my own MoV soon using your ideas. Thanks so much for taking the time to document this. There is hope for this geek....
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Tue Feb 9, 2010 7:26 pm (Total Number of Edits: 1)
  • Posted Tue Feb 9, 2010 7:24 pm
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Liam Merlot
Australia
Melbourne
Victoria
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Quote:
I used Rit fabric dye (a $1.50 box at walmart is sufficient to do all the discs needed for the remake). I used the 1/4 tsp per 50ml amount that someone researched in another thread and soaked them for 2 hours. I didn't notice any warping of any of the three sizes at that amount of time. This is MUCH MUCH cheaper and MUCH MUCH less effort than getting painted disks or painting them yourself. Or if you are happy with the unfinished wood look, you can save some time and a little money by skipping this.


Any more info on this would be good, as after some more thought this is probably the best approach for me (it will provide a more consistent coating of black than spray paint). How much water was used in each batch and how many disks in each batch? How did you dry them afterwards?
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
1/4 teaspoon to 50 ml water concentration. One package of rit fabric dye (I picked it up at walmart for about $1.50 USD) was enough to do the entire basic set. I did it in several batches since I was testing things out, first I did the medium sized discs for instance.
Two hours worked just fine for me, I don't think any more is nessasary, and that keeps wood warping to a minimum (I didn't notice any warping on the small or medium discs and I didn't dye the large ones). I experimented with very small amounts of dye and water with differant time periods and 2 hours seemed to be the best mix between giving a dark color and how much time it took to dry.

If you have a big enough pot, then you could do it all at once. We used an old stainless steel pot that was a bit smaller (I'm not sure of our pot size, maybe 2 quarts). For my initial batch of medium disks I heated up the water first until just before boiling then added the dye and kept the heat on the absolute minimum the stove could be set to. Do NOT actually boil the water. You just want it hot, not actually boiling. Heat is supposed to help "fix" the dye, but boiling isn't needed. You probably will need to mix up a bit more than you think you need, if you just barely cover your disks some mix will steam off as you cook and the level will drop below your disks. Its better to have a bit extra (you can save it to use another time) than too little.

For the 2nd batch, I actually reused the leftover mixed dye from the first batch, measured out and added what was left of the dye package and appropriate amounts of water, and did all 400 of the small wood disks at once. That filled my smallish pot to capacity. For that 2nd batch I just carefully heated the mixed solution but didn't let it boil.
I would stir it now and then (but slowly because you don't want to splash the dye, a big pot helps keep splashes down), to make sure it got evenly coated and help ensure the wood discs didn't stay stuck in same position the whole time.

After it was done I poured the dye solution into a jar (in case I need some in the future), I had seen a cheap plastic $1 set of strainers at walmart and used 1 in the set for this and the rest for home. Then I rinsed the discs until they weren't showing much black in the rinse water. I then let them dry on paper towels for a week or two (you can speed that up if you are in a hot climate or put them near a heater vent, etc). You want to dry them fairly good since you want to put stickers on them after they have finished contracting back down to pretty close to the original size. As they are drying they WILL leak moisture (with some dye) so make sure its not drying on a nice white towel I took a plastic pan we had and lined it with paper towels to dry the discs.
I used a heater on part of a batch at one point to speed up drying, that can reduce drying time down to a couple days, but electric heaters are expensive to run.
Compare the disk diameter by feel when you first dye it, and then you can see how it shrinks. It might not shrink to exactly original size as it dries, but it should be pretty close. Plus you can replace the paper towel and see if its still weeping water, that will also tell you if its mostly done drying.

One thing I was slightly concerned about was after it was dry, would it turn my fingers black after playing with it? Answer is no it doesn't.

So keys are:
1/4 tsp dye to 50 ml water
2 hours soak time
Week or two dry time

I tried to describe in detail for you, to make it easy. I know thats a wall of text, but its really not very complicated/hard. As long as you get concentration and soak time close to correct, most of the rest someone can kinda feel thier way through. For instance, it would also probably work with 1 hour or 3 hour soak time. If the concentration was 100 ml water or 25 ml water it would still probably work. Similarly if you just used cold water instead of a stove (the fabric dyeing instructions specify hot water to fix the dye, but that might be mostly for fabric. I didn't really experiement with cold water), it would likely work just fine.



Really the main thing that could mess up would probably be putting stickers on it the day after you did it while it was still weeping water

For me, I just liked this idea much better than spray paint. Plus you never have to worry about paint chipping or coming off (the dye penetrates the wood a bit). But if someone is good at spray paint, who knows, it might work better for them. And I've seen cheap $1 or $2 cans of black spray paint before.

As a side note, I tried vinegar (the smell didn't go away after weeks and weeks) and alcohol (didn't dye nearly as well) on a couple disks in some trials because I was concerned about warping. But it turned out water was best, just don't soak it overnight Only a single small disk cracked out of the 400, and I never saw any noticable warping after it was dry when I was putting stickers on (I didn't inspect all the disks for warping closely when they were wet).

Hopefully my gigantic wall of text doesn't scare you off, I sometimes like to blither on.

Anyway, I'm happy to pass on my experiances to help reduce the time/effort someone else has to take. I probably spent more time on trials than I did at the actual dying once I had figured out the time/concentration/liquid Since I spent on the time on trials of just a couple disks at a time with differant concentrations/time/liquids to determine the best ones, once I actually did the full dying it went very smooth. But this way you can skip right past all that straight to the dying process

Update: See below for details on some issues discovered by others during drying process. The main one would be to keep the disks spread out a bit during drying. Piling them all up in a bucket to dry means it takes longer, and there's a chance things may grow on them since its a damp environment. I didn't have those issues, probably because I spread mine out a bit on paper towels to dry.

Update 2:
sunshiny
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/listitem/1277105?commentid=1548...
Ended up using a wide felt tipped marker to do all the discs. The reported time was under 2 hours (about 15 seconds a disc). The most important thing in using a sharpie is probably the rim and edges since the labels should cover most of the top/bottom. This is another inexpensive way to do the discs.
6 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Sat May 22, 2010 5:25 pm (Total Number of Edits: 12)
  • Posted Wed Feb 10, 2010 3:38 am
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
Liam Merlot
Australia
Melbourne
Victoria
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Thanks so much for that. It is a huge help.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Filipe Cunha
Brazil
Rio de Janeiro
RJ
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Yargo wrote:
1/4 teaspoon to 50 ml water concentration. One package of rit fabric dye (I picked it up at walmart for about $1.50 USD) was enough to do the entire basic set. I did it in several batches since I was testing things out, first I did the medium sized discs for instance.
Two hours worked just fine for me, I don't think any more is nessasary, and that keeps wood warping to a minimum (I didn't notice any warping on the small or medium discs and I didn't dye the large ones). I experimented with very small amounts of dye and water with differant time periods and 2 hours seemed to be the best mix between giving a dark color and how much time it took to dry.

If you have a big enough pot, then you could do it all at once. We used an old stainless steel pot that was a bit smaller (I'm not sure of our pot size, maybe 2 quarts). For my initial batch of medium disks I heated up the water first until just before boiling then added the dye and kept the heat on the absolute minimum the stove could be set to.

For the 2nd batch, I actually reused the leftover mixed dye from the first batch, measured out and added what was left of the dye package and appropriate amounts of water, and did all 400 of the small wood disks at once. That filled my smallish pot to capacity. For that 2nd batch I just carefully heated the mixed solution but didn't let it boil.
I would stir it now and then (but slowly because you don't want to splash the dye, a big pot helps keep splashes down), to make sure it got evenly coated and help ensure the wood discs didn't stay stuck in same position the whole time.

After it was done I poured the dye solution into a jar (in case I need some in the future), I had seen a cheap plastic $1 set of strainers at walmart and used 1 in the set for this and the rest for home. Then I rinsed the discs until they weren't showing much black in the rinse water. I then let them dry on paper towels for a week or two (you can speed that up if you are in a hot climate or put them near a heater vent, etc). You want to dry them fairly good since you want to put stickers on them after they have finished contracting back down to pretty close to the original size. As they are drying they WILL leak moisture (with some dye) so make sure its not drying on a nice white towel I took a plastic pan we had and lined it with paper towels to dry the discs.
I used a heater on part of a batch at one point to speed up drying, that can reduce drying time down to a couple days, but electric heaters are expensive to run.
Compare the disk diameter by feel when you first dye it, and then you can see how it shrinks. It might not shrink to exactly original size as it dries, but it should be pretty close. Plus you can replace the paper towel and see if its still weeping water, that will also tell you if its mostly done drying.

One thing I was slightly concerned about was after it was dry, would it turn my fingers black after playing with it? Answer is no it doesn't.

So keys are:
1/4 tsp dye to 50 ml water
2 hours soak time
Week or two dry time

I tried to describe in detail for you, to make it easy. I know thats a wall of text, but its really not very complicated/hard. As long as you get concentration and soak time close to correct, most of the rest someone can kinda feel thier way through. For instance, it would also probably work with 1 hour or 3 hour soak time. If the concentration was 100 ml water or 25 ml water it would still probably work. Similarly if you just used cold water instead of a stove (the fabric dyeing instructions specify hot water to fix the dye, but that might be mostly for fabric. I didn't really experiement with cold water), it would likely work just fine.



Really the main thing that could mess up would probably be putting stickers on it the day after you did it while it was still weeping water

For me, I just liked this idea much better than spray paint. Plus you never have to worry about paint chipping or coming off (the dye penetrates the wood a bit). But if someone is good at spray paint, who knows, it might work better for them. And I've seen cheap $1 or $2 cans of black spray paint before.

As a side note, I tried vinegar (the smell didn't go away after weeks and weeks) and alcohol (didn't dye nearly as well) on a couple disks in some trials because I was concerned about warping. But it turned out water was best, just don't soak it overnight Only a single small disk cracked out of the 400, and I never saw any noticable warping after it was dry when I was putting stickers on (I didn't inspect all the disks for warping closely when they were wet).

Hopefully my gigantic wall of text doesn't scare you off, I sometimes like to blither on.

Anyway, I'm happy to pass on my experiances to help reduce the time/effort someone else has to take. I probably spent more time on trials than I did at the actual dying once I had figured out the time/concentration/liquid Since I spent on the time on trials of just a couple disks at a time with differant concentrations/time/liquids to determine the best ones, once I actually did the full dying it went very smooth. But this way you can skip right past all that straight to the dying process



Awesome wall of text
I dyed some wooden houses and disks for a homemade caylus set, they worked fine, and didn't warp or crack. Used almost the same process as you did, just the concentrations were different. But I dyed mine red, but it really needed regular stirring, since the dye tends to form a fine layer of multicolored weirdness on the water surface (seems like they leak some oil on the water... dunno) and that stain the wood pieces.
The dye I used told me to keep it at boil level for around 30min, I did it for only 15 and it worked just fine.
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
Will
United States
Fresno
California
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I thought I'd make a post on things I'd like to do differantly (or at least consider and examine differant ways) now that I've finished (in case anyone wants to do it in a differant way from the start).

Probably the first thing I'd do is use some sorta plastic or metal ships instead of the cardstock Standees. They work just fine, and since I was going for low cost on that copy, they achived that. But I just really like some of the alternatives that people have found on the geek. A friend of mine has the original MoV and he uses these really cool looking METAL ships from an old 60's game called Wide World:

You'll want to look in the BGG page for that game for details since not all of the copies came with the metal ships (and the game was supposed to be about Jet planes, not rocket ships lol), but I think it should be reasonably cheap to get a copy from ebay (I don't know how often they do). There's other alternatives as well, basically any game which had 6 pawns in the shape of some sorta ships should work. Plus there's those plastic buck rogers ships that have been pointed out. I'm sure some people have used those with MoV, BUT NO ONE HAS POSTED PICS of those with MoV yet
This would be one of the easiest ways to "pimp" the game out, and pretty inexpensive. It also applies to copies of the original game.

Second, I'd do the box better. I think I already mentioned about how I'd improve that, such as printing the sides larger to overhang. Its not much noticible visually on mine since it was a black box underneath, but you can definately feel the edges when touching the box and its one of those things that bugs me. I even took a little moustache trimmer and trimmed down some of the edges on the one I did so they wouldn't be as noticible to feel when touching the box. So anyway, I'd print the side prints larger, and overhang them on the bottom edges for sure and probably the top edge too, and perhaps the sides. Maybe even try to get tricky and print it all out on one sheet, but I'm not sure even the 11x17 sticker sheet is enough for that. Anyway, I'd play around with it. I probably should also find a cheap thrift game and tear the box top off and see how its done when they professionally do it, and see how much of that I can reasonably recreate.
This only applies if you are printing your own box, and then it depends on how much time/effort you want to take. Once I get around to doing my second copy, I'll probably experiment and post on BGG as to reasonable ways to improve the quality of how the box looks and feels.

Third, I found that printing 140lb cardstock double sided on a color laser printer doesn't work too well. The color gets messed up a bit on the 2nd side, I think because not enough toner is adhering to the 2nd side, which is probably due to not enough heat. So for double sided prints with color laser, I'll be using 110lb cardstock, and for single sided I'll go with 140lb. Most people probably will just stick with 110lb (or plain paper) the whole way through so that won't matter to many people.
This is only likely to apply to a very small number of people doing the remake.

Fourth, I'm very curious to see how the slightly larger discs work out for the one guy's project. He's going to use 7/8". The 3/4" that I use are just barely enough to fit the 3/4" stickers, and if you dont get them aligned just right, a tiny bit of sticker can hang off the edge. Its no big deal, and I haven't noticed any danger of separation, the adhesive seems to be pretty good, and if any did separate, well it wouldn't cost me very much to print up another sticker sheet. But its something I would consider if I was ordering parts at this moment (I have all my parts already). I hadn't really thought of it before until the other guy said he ordered that size.
I think this is fairly minor and as you can see from pics, it turned out fine, but its something I'd consider once I saw pics of both ways.

Fifth, I'd probably redo the game board merge file and reapply the the fixes. In other words, I wouldn't use the fixed one, I'd apply the fix on my own and re-upload it. The reason being, is that I think the guy doing the fix saved the JPG as the default quality which is 85 in most programs instead of 100. Normally thats ok. But some of the text color is just SLIGHTLY degraded compared to original JPG, and there's like a tiny practically unnoticable 1 pixel or so offset of the fix on the file, so its not perfect. Again, this is something mostly for perfectionists, because I didn't hear of anything from anyone who saw my board. It was only something I noticed at full zoom of both JPG files while examining them on my computer.
Fortunately, as soon as someone does a fresh fix, no one else needs to do it too

Sixth, for the currency, I might try doing double sided money printing instead of 1 side money and 1 side that special money back file. One thing I really like about the way I did do it (which was using the common money backs file) is that the registration of the printer didn't matter. So if the front and back weren't perfectly aligned (which was my case), it didn't matter. And the graphic of it is great looking. Its just something I'd like to experiment with to see how it looks. And since I can access the service menu of the color laser printer I'm using, I might try to adjust the registration/alignment better In fact, one of the things I like about all these remake files is that there's no case in which registration being off will totally screw things up. Most things are not double sided. The money has a special back that doesn't matter if registration is off. I printed shipboards double sided, but there's enough of overhang on the graphics file you can use a paper cutter until there's no white showing then the overhang wouldn't matter. The stickers are all single sided although you put two of them on each disk. I printed the relic reference on the back of the ship reference card, but since those are differant sizes there's some white paper visible on the back. Thats easy enough to change, just have separate pages for the references (and use the special graphical backs in the file from dathkaden for each of them if you don't want to see white paper).
This is a personal preference thing, so for many people (likely including myself) it probably won't matter

Those are the main things I might tweak, and nearly all of them are very minor things, but I thought I'd throw them out there as food for thought in case anyone was wondering. The replacement ships thing is the main one I'd do, and it applies to even the original MoV. And of course doing a better box sticker printing job.
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Thumb up
  • Last edited Wed Feb 10, 2010 8:13 pm (Total Number of Edits: 5)
  • Posted Wed Feb 10, 2010 7:33 pm
    • Choose your Dice
      • Roll
      • Comment (Optional)
    • QuickReply
    •  
    • QuickQuote
    •  
    • Reply
    •  
    • Quote
1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5  Next »   | 
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.