There must have been a moment at the beginning, where we could have said no. Somehow we missed it. Well, we'll know better next time.
So I've contacted Fantasy Flight and they're unable to provide a replacement box for the game. My box is pretty beat up, enough that I was able to buy the game in retail at a huge discount.
Does anyone have any ideas on how to acquire a new box?
Any new box? Go thrifting. Pick up a $1 game at Goodwill or something where the box is in good shape and big enough for the Isla Dorada components. Get some advice from some Print-N-Players on how to paste Isla Dorada images on your new box.
A new Isla Dorada box? Now that might be trickier...