Okay this is it. I hate having a game rating scale where people cannot really use the full scale but have most of their rating in the range from 5-10. So when you read my rating I've used more or less this scale.
10: Fantastic game. I'll sell my wife to have an opportunity to play this. I might also sell her for less - GM me with offers. 8-9: Great game. I really enjoy these games and it's quite likely I'll buy them given the chance. These are the games I'd drag along for a game night with the gaming buddies. 6-7: Good/Decent games. I enjoy these but they wouldn't be my first pick if I could choose. Some are here because they're great to play with non-gamers. Some are here because they're ... well ... decent. 5: Average game. I don't mind playing it since I like playing games but it wouldn't be something I'd ever suggest. 3-4: These games need a successful fast talk skill roll to get me to play. I'll try my best to wriggle my way out or to convince the other players to play something else but I might play them for the social aspect rather than the game. But in all honesty I'd rather go to the dentist and have a tooth removed. 2: I'll play this game if my kids begs me to play it or if the wife says she'll cuddle after the game is over (ha like THAT is going to happen), but I wont be enjoying it (the game I mean). 1: I will never play this game (again). I'd rather go and stuff a pineapple up my nostril