Wow, you're on the ball this year! You tell that Charlie, it's because of his book I found at a GoodWill that I am such an avid brewer!
It's so hard to pick! My kiddos are 8, buy one get one free sale, boy/girl twins. They love games and the ones they are excited about would be Smash UP, Boss Monster, or Forbidden Desert. Mice and Mystics would be fun too, I think they might be ready for some deeper game play too but really any of them would be wonderful.
Thanks again for the note Santa, have a great evening!