BoardGameGeek News

To submit news, a designer diary, outrageous rumors, or other material, contact us at
 Thumb up

Traverse Sumatra with Reiner Knizia as Your Guide

W. Eric Martin
United States
North Carolina
flag msg tools
Board Game Publisher: Ludonova
Board Game: Polynesia
In May 2020, I posted an overview of Peer Sylvester's Polynesia, an October 2020 release from Spanish publisher Ludonova, and in August 2020, Sylvester posted a designer diary about the creation of that game.

Ludonova has another title due out in late 2020 that's set a few thousand miles west of Polynesia: Reiner Knizia's Sumatra, a set-collection game for 2-5 players. Here's a detailed overview of the setting and gameplay:
Join this expedition, and you will have the unforgettable opportunity to explore Sumatra, from the top of its majestic volcanoes to the depths of its tropical rainforest. Find the most exotic animals and the most exuberant flowers, and discover the endless variety of cultures that coexist on the largest island in Indonesia. Your expedition sets out with the mission of writing a travel notebook that will help raise awareness of one of the richest ecosystems in the world. Whoever makes the best contribution to this exciting mission will win.

Board Game: Sumatra

In Sumatra, players move around the island to explore its multiple landscapes. On a turn, your possible actions depend on where you're located in relation to the travel notebook token that starts the game in base camp with all the players:

• If you're one space behind the token, you move to the notebook's space and end your turn.
• If you're on the same location as the token, either you move ahead one space or you stay put, take a tile from the pool of "available information" tiles, and add it to your personal notebook.
• If you're one space ahead of the token, you move the token to your space, move all the "available information" tiles to the "known information" pool, draw tiles from the bag equal to the number shown at your location, add those tiles to the pool of "available information", then take one of these new tiles and add it to your notebook.

Board Game: Sumatra

Thus, you're catching up with the group, researching with the group to add info to your notebook, moving ahead, or digging into new tiles ahead of everyone else.

Tiles score and have effects in various ways, for example, with players gaining or losing points for meeting the most or fewest inhabitants. Flora and fauna tiles score only if you have a pair in a column, but only the highest-valued of this pair scores. Villages score only if you have more pairs of reception and GPS tiles than the number of villages, while the reception and GPS pairs net you no points, but allow you to get a tile from the pool of "known information". Equipment makes it safe to explore volcanoes on the island, and if you don't have enough equipment, you might lose other tiles you've collected.

Board Game: Sumatra

Sumatra also includes badges that players can collect. Be the first to collect, say, three flora tiles or a combination of two inhabitant and two craft tiles, and you can claim the badge for this, which is worth 3 points at game's end. You can also claim one diversity badge for having at least one tile in at least six rows of your notebook. The more rows you have a presence in, the higher the value of the diversity badge, but you can claim at most one during the game — and if someone else claims the six-row badge, then you'll need to have a tile in at least seven rows for the next one...
Based on a reading of the rules, Sumatra seems like a typical rules-light Knizia design in which player interaction drives everything in a quiet way.

On a turn, you either take a tile or move without taking a tile. When you move ahead of the token, you guarantee yourself first pick at the next spot, and if no one else moves, then you'll have the first two picks; additionally, by moving ahead, you guarantee that everyone else can take at most one more tile from the current location because they'll be forced to move forward on the next turn.

As for the tiles, you're trying to navigate a web of scoring conditions that isn't point salad-y since many of the conditions relate to one another. For the most part, you fill the tile rows of your notebook from left to right, and if you don't collect enough equipment of different colors, then you'll lop off the rightmost columns before you tally the endgame score. If you collect three equipment of the same color, that's worth 5 points; if you also have the volcano of that color, you collect another 5 points, whereas a volcano without sufficient equipment is worth -5 points. Villages are worth 5 points each, but only if you have enough of both GPS and reception to "cover" those villages; otherwise you score nothing for them.

Sumatra is due out in November 2020.

Board Game: Sumatra
Twitter Facebook
Subscribe sub options Mon Sep 14, 2020 1:00 pm
Post Rolls
  • [+] Dice rolls
Loading... | Locked Hide Show Unlock Lock Comment     View Previous {{limitCount(numprevitems_calculated,commentParams.showcount)}} 1 « Pg. {{commentParams.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
    View More Comments {{limitCount(numnextitems_calculated,commentParams.showcount)}} / {{numnextitems_calculated}} 1 « Pg. {{commentParams.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}