Greg's Design Blog

A collection of posts by game designer Gregory Carslaw, including mirrors of all of his blogs maintained for particular projects. A complete index of posts can be found here:
 Thumb up

A Game Designer at a Comics Convention

United Kingdom
flag msg tools
Context: 3DTotal

So a little while back I went to Comicon to show off the Scandinavia and the World game. Since we're launching in just a couple of weeks now seems like an excellent time to talk about that - but what I really want to talk about is how to be a fish out of water. I've done plenty of board gaming conventions, but the comic convention was something entirely different. I may have been the only person demoing a board game in the room (I might not have been - but in any event there weren't many). So let me tell you the ways in which it was different and what I'd recommend to a game designer who's going to be the only board game person at a convention in the future.

The venue was pretty much the same as any other convention. I had a bit of table, people are walking past looking at all of the neat things, all of the main things that define running a stand at a convention were pretty much the same as normal. Where there were differences it was in the people - but conventions are mostly about the people so that's a big difference.

As will become increasingly obvious as I post photos, everyone looked fantastic! While a games convention isn't populated by people who have gone out of their way to worry about how they look, the comics convention was full of people who've spent months preparing the perfect costume. Not everyone was taking this approach, but I couldn't help but feel later in the day while I was playing someone dressed as Gambit at a card game (which I'm sure made me at least 10% more cautious than I'd usually be) - perhaps I could've picked an appropriate game related getup.

It's probably futile to say "Also learn what everyone else might be dressed as" because of the sheer number of characters that there are. However speaking to a couple of people going and getting an idea of what might be popular seems like a good idea. I'm pretty sure that I offended someone by misidentifying their costume and "I called you the wrong thing" can come across as "The costume you put effort into is bad and I can't tell what it is" rather than "I have literally never encountered the character you're dressed as". I suppose my advice for people going forwards would be don't guess until you've established enough of a rapport that it'll be okay to be wrong.

I don't want to talk much more about costumes, because it's only a skin deep thing and not the most important part of being a board game designer at Comicon, but it's worth a small mention that some types of costume make things more challenging. Not being able to make eye contact with someone is quite disconcerting. Gloves make it harder to handle components. Sweeping sleeves have an inherent desire to clear the table if a player has to reach for something in the middle of the table.

Think about these things when you lay out your stand. If necessary make things inconvenient for yourself in order to make it easier for people who may have a costume disadvantage. For instance by the halfway point I'd got used to either putting draw decks nearer the far side of the table rather than in the middle, or adapting play slightly so that the host hands out cards rather than a player needing to draw them.

So let's move from something quite superficial to something that had a big impact: While there were obviously board game fans around and there was a space in which people were playing board games, almost nobody was demoing them on their stand. Being the only demo game in town has advantages and drawbacks.

A surprisingly big one was: We had chairs. On which people could sit. People who are walking around a large convention floor for an extended period of time would do basically anything if it involved sitting down. While I believe in the game I'm working on and think it's great fun, I suspect that this was one of the main reasons that I barely had a couple of minutes go by without starting a new demo game for the whole con. Perhaps the most useful piece of advice for doing this sort of thing would be: Get more chairs than you think you need.

Another is the novelty value. People are expecting to look at a lot of pretty things and speak to people about awesome things, but they're not really expecting to get to do the thing. It'd be super rude to sit in front of someone's comic stand and read one of their comics from cover to cover and then leave without buying anything, most people wouldn't do it (I'm sure some people do because people are terrible). Getting to join in with a thing and actively engage with it is an activity that you can offer as a game designer and that generates a certain amount of interest.

There is a downside to the novelty though: A lot of the people joining for games weren't gamers. Now on some level's that is perfect for this game, it's aimed at a webcomic audience and doing tests outside of usual playtest groups is desperately important. However it also means that people handle things differently. An audience that's used to thinking of a card as a critical piece of a £80 game that will ruin the game if it's destroyed and an audience that's used to thinking of a card as a disposable thing from an easily replaced £2 deck of playing cards treat cards differently. There's more bending, folding, spindling and mutilating. There's more happiness about holding them alongside drinks or other miscellaneous sticky things. The prototype did not really survive the weekend - so that's another lesson: Carry one more spare prototype than you think you need if you're not dealing with a predominantly gaming audience.

Overall though, the trade off is more than worth it. An advantage I didn't expect to encounter was that for a while I found it easier to work on the game. The novelty of the surrounding meant that people approached it with greater enthusiasm and (hopefully) the quality of the game carried that feeling through the play. Seeing people get enthusiastic about a game is one of my main motivations to design, so it always gives me a boost.

For this convention I was partnered with the Scandinavia and the World team and in truth what I've been referring to as "my table" was really the last few feet of their impressive display. I think it helped a lot to be connected to a webcomic stand, because people would look at all of the things they had out on display and I provided a handy "Would you like to see more? We have a game you can play" when there were no more things to look at and someone else was already looking through the box of prints. I think if I was going to do this again it'd be nice to be partnered with someone. If I had a game that had the Comicon folks as its target audience but wasn't linked to a specific webcomic I might still look to do a deal with an existing exhibitor to go to the convention together. Perhaps commissioning them for a piece of art to put onto a promo card or something like that. It was definitely good to be working with decent people throughout the convention.

All in all it wasn't that different to a regular day demoing at a games convention - but the small differences mattered and I could have been better prepared. Hopefully if you ever do anything similar you'll find some useful advice in this article. Happy gaming in unusual places
Twitter Facebook
Subscribe sub options Sat Aug 19, 2017 1:55 pm
Post Rolls
  • [+] Dice rolls
Loading... | Locked Hide Show Unlock Lock Comment     View Previous {{limitCount(numprevitems_calculated,commentParams.showcount)}} 1 « Pg. {{commentParams.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}
    View More Comments {{limitCount(numnextitems_calculated,commentParams.showcount)}} / {{numnextitems_calculated}} 1 « Pg. {{commentParams.pageid}} » {{data.config.endpage}}




Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.