Recommend
35 
 Thumb up
 Hide
7 Posts

Snowdonia» Forums » Reviews

Subject: Snowdonia: A four-sided game review rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Chris Marling
United Kingdom
Cambridge
flag msg tools
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
For more of my reviews:

Four-sided reviews subscription thread

Originally posted here (with images):

http://goplaylisten.wordpress.com/2013/09/28/snowdonia-a-fou...

--

Snowdonia is a pretty complex board game with a strong theme and some interesting innovations. The main gameplay mechanism is worker placement (players place their discs, or ‘workers’, on board spaces that let them do a particular action – such as gain resources, draw cards etc), but the real meat of the game is in seeing and taking opportunities when they arise – both through taking and using cards and placing those workers.

Collectively (but competitively – this ain’t no co-op!) you’ll be building the famous railway up the side of Snowdon, Wales’ highest mountain – when it’s complete, the game will end. The board background is a watercolour mountain-scape painting (I like it, some don’t), with spaces for cards and resources overlaid. There are 66 cards (with a lovely whimsical art style), a bunch of wooden bits and bobs, score pad and a very nice train-shaped wooden start played marker. All in all, Snowdonia is produced to a high standard.

The rulebook is very well laid out, with the first double-page spread dedicated to the game’s set up. Usefully, once you know the game enough not to need this, the bits you may forget are printed on the board so you won’t need to go back to the rulebook. Also worth noting here is that set up is slightly different depending on the number of players; one of many testaments to how rigorously the game was playtested.

Teaching

While complex, the game is relatively easy to teach. This is helped by both the theme and board layout, as all the things you do make sense both visibly and thematically. Snowdonia has lots of moving parts, which may be too fiddly for some (new cubes and cards come out each round, which can have a knock on effect to other parts of the board), but doing this kind of upkeep also keeps player’s involved and helps drive home what all these little things do.

The theme really is a big help. Players are building a railway up a mountain: the actions let you grab resources (iron, stone, coal), clear rubble, upgrade resources (iron to track, rubble to stone) , place track, build stations (with various resources gained), take trains (which use track and coal) and take ‘contract’ cards (which give bonuses to the above actions, and also bonus victory points at the end of the game if you complete certain conditions – build ‘x’ stations, lay ‘x’ track, collect ‘x’ rubble)*.

But don’t get me wrong; there’s a difference between a game being reasonably easy to teach and being able to play it well, see the nuances, and win on your first play. I would very much recommend telling people that the first game is a training game and that they shouldn’t worry about their score the first time out. Most of your points will come from cards you use actions to take – and then hopefully fulfil the requirements of – during the game and you’ll be lucky to nail this at the first attempt.

The four sides

These are me, plus three fictitious amalgams drawn from observing my friends, and their respective quirks and play styles.

The writer: I love worker placement games, but there’s a lot of them about. You have to do something to stand out and Snowdonia does it not once, but twice. Its weather mechanism effects every round of the game randomly, doing anything from improving some actions for the round to making others obsolete (you get a few rounds to prepare though). On top of this, the game actually plays itself; if you draw white cubes during restocking each round, the game can complete parts of the railway. These mechanisms ensure every game is genuinely different.
The thinker: There’s a lot to like here and while the random elements are very strong they affect everyone in the same way, so don’t feel unbalanced in a competitive way. You soon see certain point strategies are higher risk, while the old adage of getting out of sequence and ‘doing what others aren’t doing’ can be a real winner here. And while it isn’t the deepest worker placement game on the market, the constant moving of the goalposts makes Snowdonia one of the most constantly engaging ones.
The trasher: If you like to try and cope with whatever a game throws at you each round, Snowdonia could be a good pick. You can normally plan a round or two ahead, while the contract cards give you little bonuses to actions that can really improve a turn – despite whether you manage to complete them by the end for points. There’s little, but subtle, player interaction too: some actions have multiple spaces that are resolved in order, making clever placement key to blocking others while sweeping in with your own combos to snatch points.
The dabbler: Snowdonia takes a bit of getting used to, while rough luck with the weather and white cubes can be a bit of a downer for everyone; you’re not working together, but are all in the same boat after all. It’s not a game I’d choose, but I am happy to play it. The changing fortunes keep everyone invested, while picking the random cubes from the bag and seeing the reactions makes it nicely interactive too. Finally, as the theme fits the mechanics so well, its simple to pick up again after not playing for a while.

Key observations

While the weather and ‘game playing itself’ mechanisms are clever and work extremely well most of the time, they can lead to plays that feel a little underwhelming – even to experienced players who will have a better chance of coping with the conditions. Some will relish the challenge, but I can see others being left very cold by the experience.

Hundreds of people had given the game an ‘out of 10′ rating on BoardGameGeek and the vast majority of these are positive. The game sits proudly in the top 400 and has a very respectable average rating of just below 7.5. But a look at the comments allied with grades of four-out-of-10 or below paints a very telling picture: if you get a duff first game, which is very possible, you’re not overly likely to come back.

Designer Tony Boydell has been buoyed (apologies…) by its success and a raft of mini expansions are on the way, alongside a reprint which should see the game get better reach in the US and elsewhere.

Maybe he can also spend a little time working out a slightly less punishing introductory game option, even if it simply means removing some fog cards (which scupper some actions) and having an alternative beginner white cube track for the the first few times people play, to help stem this possible exodus.

Conclusion

I’m a big fan of Snowdonia, which I currently rate a nine after about 15 plays. It sits in my top 10 games list alongside other worker placement favourites The Manhattan Project and Tzolk’in, and ahead of Stone Age, Caylus, Troyes, Agricola and the rest.

I’d still recommend Stone Age or perhaps Lords of Waterdeep as introductions to the genre, but experienced players looking for an interesting alternative should certainly give Snowdonia a go. And not just the one play either; it needs a couple of goes to see how the game can play so differently each time (something that will no doubt hurt it a little).

But no, it’s not for everyone. It can feel attritional on a bad day and this is a collective feeling too. You’re working together to build this railway,so a bad game can feel tough for everyone. If you don’t like a challenge, it can suck a bit of the life out of the room for the wrong group. Me? I love the challenge of trying to eke out the win in dire conditions, although do still prefer it when the sun shines and the white cubes stay nicely nestled in the corners of the bag.

Finally, I’ve been lucky enough to be involved in a bit of play-testing for one of the forthcoming expansions, Mt Washington. It adds snow to the weather mix, which takes the action-stopping fog away and replaces it with re-rubble-laying white stuff. This adds an interesting new challenge, some nice variety (there are plenty of new cards) and the chance to sled down the mountain at the end…

* NOTE: there is another action space, the Surveyor, but this plays differently depending on the version of the game you play and I don’t think it needs explanation here.
21 
 Thumb up
5.10
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Shane Larsen
United States
Salt Lake City
UT
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Great review, Chris!

I've struggled with where to place this one on the weight scale. On one hand, it's very simple and straight-forward enough to place it one step above an entry-level game. On the other hand, there are so many moving parts that are constantly changing, and it can be unforgiving enough that it feels more like a medium-heavy weight. And as you mentioned, depending on how the events come out, it can ping back and forth to all ends of this spectrum.

My wife, Ash, is an experienced gamer. She plays most games up to a select few heavy-weights. She was able to grasp the game easily, and pulled off dominating wins her first two times playing. So I was feeling like the game was kind to new players. Then last week I introduced it to a few Monopoly/Scrabble-only players, and while they all did fine picking up the rules, they all scored badly in the end (keep in mind there was a bit of a language barrier too; I was translating all the cards for them since they don't speak English ). But about a month ago, I introduced it to a high-school kid here in Guatemala who understands English at an intermediate level, and he had no problem picking it up. In fact, he beat me the first two games (something I need to remedy soon).

So what I'm getting at is it fits into a game where the conditions are so variable from game to game, that many will like it or hate it based on that element alone. If you want a different game every time you play, with different challenges, and some unexpected/unhoped-for events coming your way, then you'll dig this game (pun intended). If you want something more static, and want to be able to depend on the same game--at macro perspective--every time you sit down to play, this will be a miss. Another game that comes to mind that changes in such dramatic ways from game to game is Troyes. (On a side, I don't categorize Troyes as a worker-placement game. It's pure a dice-manipulation game, IMO.) But the two games are akin in that every game feels fundamentally different, and dealing with those differences is a big part of conducting a win.

Indeed, more than one play is needed to give this game a fair sampling. I hope many people read this review so they understand that, and won't dismiss if they didn't enjoy their first play.

Thanks again for a great review of a great game!
12 
 Thumb up
0.02
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Japan
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Great read, great game!
Personally, I would say that, even if you are new to the genre, it is perfectly possible to skip the lighter Stone Age and LoWD that you suggest, and get straight into Snowdonia, as the official solo variant, which is not present in the other titles, is a perfect testing ground to get used to the mechanics of the game before playing with others.
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Anthony Boydell
United Kingdom
Newent. Glos
Unspecified
flag msg tools
designer
Every homo sapiens needs an outbuilding within the curtelage of their property
badge
Welcome...to my Shed!
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
While Fog is still in, Snowdonia: The Daffodil Line has a much gentler feel to it
5 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Paulo Soledade
Portugal
Leiria
Leiria
flag msg tools
designer
WYG Developer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Great review. I really liked Snowdonia. In fact I was hoping that Tony Boydell would get his new game in Essen this year but apparently he won't. Anyway, for some reason my fellow players didn't like the game as much as I did and I didn't have the chance to play it more. But I still think that Snowdonia was one refreshing design from last year. For sure!
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Steve Blackwell
United Kingdom
Saltdean
East Sussex
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
"I would very much recommend telling people that the first game is a training game..." whistle

Nice!

M B
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Goldfinger
Canada
Burnaby
British Columbia
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Very nicely written. Thank you for the time and effort. meeple
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.