Recommend
36 
 Thumb up
 Hide
6 Posts

Among the Stars» Forums » Reviews

Subject: As a Board Gamer - Among the Stars - An Overview and Review rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Rowdy van Lieshout
Netherlands
Huis ter Heide
Utrecht
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb


Copy of an As a Board Gamer article.
English version of the Dutch review

Designer: Vangelis Bagiartakis
Publisher: Artripia Games
Number of Players: 2 - 4
Playtime:30 minutes
Price (approx.): 35 euro


Overview:

The story:

The universe has been ravaged by a terrible war. Death and destruction were the rule rather than the exception. But peace is on the horizon. All major races have been united in the Alliance. The first task of that alliance is to repair what has been destroyed, starting with the many space stations.

What you get for your money:


Lots of (square) cards, 152 to be precise. A score board, with 4 player markers and a turn marker. 8 Different races on cardboard boards. 50 Credit tokens and 20 energy cubes. Some zip-lock bags and a rulebook.

How do you play the game:

Each player starts with a main power station with 2 energy cubes on it, some money and 6 location cards in their hand. The goal is to make the biggest, most beautiful, most effective space station. The space station must be finished in 4 years and the one does it best within that time-frame wins the game.



It’s a drafting game, so you choose the card you want or you don’t want anyone else to have and you pass the rest to your neighbour. On every card a part of a space station is depicted. It is from a certain district (colour), it has a building cost and it has small bit of text on it that tells you how to score points with this card. You have two types of currency in the game: energy and money. And you basically have two types of point scoring types: you score points with this card now or you score at the end of the game.

In your turn, you can choose to build the chosen card, to discard it for money or to build a power station.

The amount of points you get when you place a card in your station, mostly depends on the location itself, but also on the type of location that is next to that card or the amount of cards that is between the card and the main power station for example. So, it not just depend which card you build, but also where you build it.



In addition to this basic idea, you can add the alien races, which give every player a special ability. You can add objectives, they add end game scoring conditions. And lastly, you can add conflict cards, if you want to play the game more aggressive.



At the end of the game, you add your end game points to your current point total, you get extra points if you have some money left and you get points if you efficiently used your energy cubes. The alien with the most points, wins Among the Stars.

Review:

Theme(1x):

The theme is building a space station to promote trade and diplomatic relations between the alien races and thereby keeping the peace. Is it well implemented? That is a tough one.

You are building a space station, that’s true. Your tableau gets bigger and bigger. The different location types and the way they score point are a perfect match. You don’t want any filthy power plant or any military location near your peaceful garden and why would you want one bus station, you need more to create a transport network, right?? Every card makes thematic sense.

But the promote peace, trade and diplomacy part of the theme is in my opinion not entirely well executed. You build the trading posts and the embassies, but you don’t actually trade or do politics. Your space station or race doesn’t interact with others. It’s like having a phone but never call or text someone.

But they say they are only promoting trade, not doing it. Ok, my bad.

The game can be interactive with the conflict cards, but the Alliance was all about peace keeping right? And why would you want to have a conflict with someone about who has the most office blocks or restaurants in their station??

7

Gameplay (2x):

The gameplay is fairly simple. The choices in the game are limited to: which locations do you want to build and where do you want to build them. In addition, you have to think a little bit about which cards to pass on to your opponent.

The first game will be a little slow and confusing, you don’t really know the best ways to score points and everyone needs time to read their cards. But after that the game will play quite fast and easy.

Some locations will always be in the deck according to the player number, in addition to these cards some random special location cards are added to the deck. So every game is a little bit different.

The rules will tell you differently, but I would add the alien races and the objective cards immediately. These add strategy and variability to the game, without making the game more complicated.

Keep in mind that there is little interaction between players. In the games I’ve played everyone was watching the others, but most of the time they chose the cards that were most beneficial for them, other than choosing a card that they did not want the others to have.

The lack of interaction can be solved with the conflict cards. They give you the ability to take points from other players if, for example, if you have more red locations than they have. But also, you don’t want to give your opponent the opportunity to screw you over, so you keep certain conflict cards for yourself.

They are quite interesting, but I do think it would be better if, to make them more special and worthwhile to use, you have to add fewer conflict cards to the deck or you only have one of every type.

I would not advice to use conflict cards if you play with two players. They do not work that well that way, because you can’t choose the opponent to screw over.

It’s always the same person. They feel like a slap in the face with a flat hand.

The two player variant works pretty well. You are playing the game, if it were a four player game. It is an, even more, multiplayer solitaire game if you play with two.

8

Looks (1x):

The illustrations on the cards are very, very beautiful, you can spend an evening just looking at all the different cards. Odysseas Stamoglou and Antonis Papantoniou did a fantastic job.



The transparent plastic energy cubes are also very nice to watch. Sort of transparent, but not really.



Not so pretty (and this is actually more about functionality) is the score board. Very confusing. You’ll have to look at least twice to see where to put your player marker.

OK, because everything else is so beautiful:

8

Quality of the game parts (1x):

The cards are fine. Not a standard shape, though, so it might be harder to find fitting sleeves.

The cardboard is quite sturdy and the plastic cubes are of good quality.

The turn marker is the only thing that is flawed. There should be two sides that show you to which neighbour you have to give your cards, but both sides show the same direction.

Lastly, the box is far too big.

7

Fun (2x):

Among the Stars is a very fun game. For me, is falls between a Lost Cities(ISH) game and Race for the Galaxy. Lost Cities is shorter, but has the same amount of interaction (AtS a bit more because of the draft). Race for the Galaxy takes about the same amount of time, but it is more complex.

To start with, the game itself looks very nice. At the end of four years you have your own fully built, colourful, space station, with all the different locations, right in front of you on the table. What an accomplishment!

Some will see this as a flaw, but I personally don’t mind the lack of interaction in this game. Every time I think it is a challenge to choose the best cards and put them in the right place, to get the more points than the last game.

The conflict cards only work with more than two players, but I don’t think you need them to have a nice time.

The different races, the objective and the fact that the special locations are randomly put into the deck provide more variety and adds to the replay value.

I also don’t think that there is one way to win the game.

During the game you’ll have to make some small, but sometimes, tough choices. You want to build everything, but you can’t. Plus, you’ll have to press your luck a bit.

This is not a heavy game, but not a lightweight either. A very nice game for weeknights. Two games of Among the stars in a free hour and you’ll have a great time.

8

Final Score

29 
 Thumb up
0.25
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Hassan Lopez
United States
Greenfield Center
New York
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Thanks for the review! I can't wait to get my KS'ed copy (+ expansion).
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Cristian van Loenen
Netherlands
Hilversum
flag msg tools
Being defeated is often a temporary condition. Giving up is what makes it permanent.
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Cannot wait for the expansion, it includes a corrected turn marker and a new much less confusing score board
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Bryan McNeely
United States
Indiana
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
This sounds bad, but do you know what prevents me from buying this game? I don't like tile-laying games when there are cards instead. If I try to imagine playing Suburbia, Glen More or Carcassonne with cards, I cringe.

I wish I didn't feel as such because this one always looked great to me.
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Rowdy van Lieshout
Netherlands
Huis ter Heide
Utrecht
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
kaosmagix wrote:
Cannot wait for the expansion, it includes a corrected turn marker and a new much less confusing score board


The expansion is great. More cards. And the ambassadors are a very cool too.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Whitney Barnes

California
msg tools
Yeah, the Ambassadors expansion really is a must. Having the same set of 18 basic cards gets stale pretty quick. With the expansion, you have a total of 33 basic cards, and you play with 15 in each game. The Ambassador cards are also nice for replayability. They aren't super strong in their effects, but they are another class of choice to make on your turn, which is good.

Also, check out either the Ambassadors rulebook, or one of the boards here on boardgame geek for another 2-player variant.

I picked up pretty much all the promos at Essen; they include mostly more "special" cards, a few new aliens, and two different sets of conflict cards, new Ambassadors, new objectives, and stuff for 5-6 players. Nothing really novel or unmissable there, unless you are really hankering for a meaner set of conflict cards.
5 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.