BTW, shouldn't this be in the Citadels base game forum? The Smithy card is part of the base game. I personally don't mind this topic being here, but I just had to point that out
Great Dane wrote:
You keep all the cards - just as the cards says!Yeah, BSW implements it that way in which it was based off that older version. On the other hand, Citadelles.net has it as "pay 2 draw 3"
However, I was very puzzled by your question as it appears that Fantasy Flight has changed the text from the original version, in which you bought 2 cards for 3 gold...!
Not sure whether this is an intentional change or an error.