Recommend
15 
 Thumb up
 Hide
8 Posts

Firefly: The Game – Pirates & Bounty Hunters» Forums » Reviews

Subject: First look at P&BH rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Roger BW
United Kingdom
High Wycombe
Buckinghamshire
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
My hopes for the Firefly: The Game – Pirates & Bounty Hunters expansion to Firefly: The Game were that it would increase interaction between players and make
runaway victories more difficult. My copy arrived yesterday. At first glance, how does it do?

There are several new elements, which interact with each other.

The Showdown

This is a mechanism for ship vs ship (or even ship vs individual) conflicts, which can be triggered in various ways. The attacker and defender each choose one of the three skills, and each make a normal skill roll including Gear; the defender wins ties. The specific card that invoked the Showdown will give results for success or failure.

Piracy Jobs

All the new Jobs are Piracy, which involve attacking your fellow players and taking their stuff; there are five for each Contact deck, but they're identical within each deck. As with other Jobs, this isn't freelance: different job cards will give different classes of target (any ship, any outlaw ship, etc.). A Piracy Job is Immoral if and only if the Leader on the target ship is Moral.

Resolving the Job takes a Boarding test (Tech or Negotiate, target 6), followed by a Showdown, with different results for specific Jobs. Generally, if you lose, you'll probably lose crew; if you succeed, you'll take a certain amount of the target's "goods" (Cargo, Contraband, Fuel and Parts: everything in the hold except Passengers and Fugitives) and be paid per item; but goods in the Stash are safe. In other cases, you can take a Job from the target player. Those goods you steal don't have to be taken anywhere; just having deprived your opponent of them is enough for you to get paid. (So you can then sell them to a contact, or use them to complete other Jobs.)

Bounties

There's a new deck of Bounty cards, one card per Wanted Crew in the game. At any time, there are three face up; they're replaced when Crew are turned in or killed, or when the Alliance Cruiser card comes up.

They work a bit like a new sort of Job: you need to apprehend the target (from a supply planet, from a rival's crew, or even from among your own crew), then transport them to a nominated location and hand them over. Other ships can try to board you to steal your prisoner, and may even choose to set the prisoner free (in which case they can join the rescuer's crew for zero cost).

Cortex Alerts pay out on a whole class of fugitives (Bandits, Enforcers, Scrappers) rather than just one target: but there's only a single payday for a single player, as once the bounty is collected (for one or more fugitives) a new bounty card is turned up.

New ships

Two new ships are included in the set, each of which takes a relatively extreme position rather than the general-purpose Firefly. While the setup procedures are unchanged, I think it would be friendly to let people who had particular preferences get a chance at the new ships, just as when I'm playing the standard game I mention the option of the Artful Dodger before ship selection starts in case anyone particularly wants it.

S. S. Walden

The Walden is a salvage ship. It has fifteen cargo capacity and no stash. Its drive core is fixed at range 4, but no extra fuel is needed for the Heavy Load found on some shipping jobs.

It has one special attribute: any Piracy jobs also count as Salvage Ops. That doesn't have any effect in itself, but several existing crew cards get bonus items when they conduct Salvage Ops.

A player with this ship could start the game as a legitimate trader taking heavy loads, and there's plenty of room for fuel and spare parts; ideally you'd want to take several Jobs at once (though note that you're still limited to three active Jobs). Once skills are up a bit, it's definitely going to be time for some piracy.

Interceptor

This is the opposite of the Walden, something like a more extreme version of the Artful Dodger from the original promo pack. Just four cargo, no stash, and only four crew and two upgrade slots, but a range 8 drive with no fuel needed for full burn (though range drops by one with each upgrade).

Clearly this is a ship for a highly-skilled Crew and plenty of Gear, preferably with a Mechanic to avoid the need to carry parts; Crime Jobs and bounty hunting will be most profitable, but without being able to do as many of the easy cargo-hauling jobs to build up wealth reserves the player will have to be careful in how starting cash is spent.

New Leaders

Jubal has the Pilot keyword. His skills are 1-1-1, but he gets +2 Fight when attacking in a Showdown, and can carry two Gear. Clearly someone to take if you're planning on lots of Showdowns.

Sash has 2 Negotiate, 1 Tech, a built-in Hacking Rig and a bonus $500 for each Piracy job completed (stolen from the target). He'll make a good pirate.

New equipment

The new kit mostly ties in with the new game mechanics: the Electronic Defense Suite means rivals can't use tech for boarding tests (and lets you get away from Reavers more easily), while Mag-Grappler Launchers add three Tech for Boarding and boost Salvage Ops.

New characters

Some characters have the Fed keyword, meaning that a warrant is issued to the rival when they lose a showdown. One Lawman can summon the Alliance Cruiser to his sector as a Fly action; that should be effective at discouraging piracy!

Lawman is a new character type keyword. Lawmen don't need to be paid, but don't do illegal jobs; when they turn in a fugitive they get paid a bounty bonus.

New Story cards

Of the three new Story cards, one is the jailbreak: each captain has a friend held prisoner on the Command Cruiser, who needs to be broken out. The hardest part of this is probably the Fight 10 test to do the breakout; getting to two other planets and paying $5,000 should be relatively easy for a crew which can do that.

The other two are focused on player-vs-player gaming, with different scoring mechanisms, and both start with all Piracy jobs face-up. One awards a goal for every Piracy, Crime or Smuggling job, and each time a Bounty is delivered; the other gives each player a Haven (a designated planet in border space), which has to be supplied with contraband, cargo or parts. Both of these are likely to lead to longer games than usual.

Destination markers

Numbered Destination tokens, the other side of the Haven markers, can be used to indicate the sequence of planets which need to be visited in a story. There are no particular rules for this, but it would, informally, allow the existing stories to be changed around for a longer or shorter game.

Overall

The new mechanisms for interfering with players rely on Showdowns, and therefore having at least one skill substantially better than their highest skill, though some characters complicate matters. This isn't a reliable method for underdogs to come from behind, though it offers some high-risk options, which I think is fair; one doesn't want to make gains meaningless. There is plenty more player interaction, and I think that this set will make a welcome addition to the game. (I can certainly see players trading prisoners at a discount.)

For solo play, I'd just ignore this expansion completely: any card with the crossed-rifles symbol doesn't exist, and gets re-drawn. (Though the Walden might still be playable in the solo game.)

I think it's probably worth encouraging leading players not to pick on the underdogs, since while it's not completely safe for the leaders this could quickly render the game non-fun for players who aren't winning.

This review was also posted on my blog
12 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Erik Miller
United States
Cincinnati
Ohio
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Thanks for the review! Eagerly awaiting my copy to arrive from across the pond!

Does this make the game really bitter (aka you just run around and screw with each other the whole time) or does it add some interaction that is helpful at times and can be ignored at others depending on the story/style of play? Like I don't have to do piracy jobs to win but can if I want too? I play with 2 different groups of people and one group would hate it if this was now a crazy pvp game.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
George Krubski
msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
I don't have the game yet, but from what I've read, Piracy is optional -- but easily accessible. Unlike regular jobs, it seems that the Piracy jobs are all placed in the Contact discard piles so they're always there for anyone who wants them. Thus, you COULD play a "gentlemen's game" where no one takes a Piracy job... but it's equally easy to go grab a Piracy job and attack a runaway leader (or someone you just plain don't like!).

I suspect different groups will find different levels of comfort, but even in the most non-cutthroat game, the idea of Piracy and Bounties as DETERRENTS may have impact on play style.

Bounties seem to be an odd bird -- almost the exact opposite of Piracy -- in that you can't depend on them. Only three are in play at a time, and they're only replaced when completed, so it's possible that the same three faces will be staring up at everyone for the entire game. Although there IS more risk in having Wanted Crew on your ship, the chance of having someone in play at the same time their card is up is... well, not nearly 100%. To me, the more dangerous ones are the generic alerts for Enforcers, Scrappers, and Bandits. Since these are some of the best "generic" Crew in the game, if a Cortex alert comes up, it might have widespread consequences.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
George Krubski
msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
Firedrake wrote:
For solo play, I'd just ignore this expansion completely: any card with the crossed-rifles symbol doesn't exist, and gets re-drawn. (Though the Walden might still be playable in the solo game.)


I can see not using the Interceptor and ignoring the Jobs, by I think a lot of the resources are still useful (if not maximized) in a solo game. For example, sure, Chari is most useful during a showdown, but just the fact that she has 2 Talk and isn't Moral makes her stand out. She's the only non-Saffron Crew with that combo right now!

I feel like the designers did everything they could to make most of the Supplies useful even without Showdowns, Piracy, and Bounty Hunting. For the few that aren't, there are easy enough "fixes" (maybe, for example, any Showdown bonus becomes a "once per Work action" bonus).
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
James Rhys
msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
gwek wrote:
Bounties seem to be an odd bird -- almost the exact opposite of Piracy -- in that you can't depend on them. Only three are in play at a time, and they're only replaced when completed, so it's possible that the same three faces will be staring up at everyone for the entire game.


They don't get replaced when you complete the bounty, but when you apprehend the Fugitive - you take the Bounty card and put it and the fugitive next to your dashboard, then draw another, so if several of them are apprehended and being transported around the Bounties can cycle fairly fast (and change hands...!). If the fugitives don't come out of the decks it can still be a bit locked, but they can be replaced by the Alliance Cruiser Nav Card coming out, which happened a good few times when I played, trouble is we forgot about the bounty reset the first couple of times...!

 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
George Krubski
msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
Thanks for the clarification. Not nearly as static as I thought -- but still not as "reliable" as Piracy, Crime, or Shipping. Sounds like fun, though. Can't wait to get my PBH!
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Hardboiled Gregg
United Kingdom
Reading
Berkshire
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
gwek wrote:
Unlike regular jobs, it seems that the Piracy jobs are all placed in the Contact discard piles so they're always there for anyone who wants them.

They're only placed in the discard piles during set up for those two new more PvP-focused story cards. Otherwise, they're in the deck like regular jobs.

Of course, there's nothing to stop you ruling that they start in the discards for every type of game...though I suspect things could get out of hand in certain scenarios.

The interesting thing about the Cortex Alerts is that there's an element of risk/reward there with how many you can get. You earn the bounty reward for each you hand in (2 Bandits = 2 x $2000) but if someone Bounty Jumps you, they take all such prisoners (unlike regular Bounties, where you can only Jump 1 per Work Action).
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Roger BW
United Kingdom
High Wycombe
Buckinghamshire
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I haven't had a chance to play yet, but I get the impression that if you're not playing a PvP-focused story card then piracy is a pretty optional part of the game: you can go for it, just as you could go for a Crime-focused play style, but it won't automatically win or lose you the game. (It'll depend on the story, of course.)
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.