I decided against this one. I just couldn't see how this could be any better than Memoir 44, which I consider to be the best implementation of the C&C system so far. I don't think the question was ever answered as to what makes this notably different from M44, so that's why I'm out (Duncan Bannatyne eat your heart out!).I have BC150 and found it to be quite enjoyable. This was a natural progression for me...I like the period and the game mechanics seemed easy and fun. M44 was not really my "thing" and the minis didn't really grab me too much. The other games in that genre didn't really grab my attention either since they were block games. Nothing against block games, I have 1812 and really enjoy it...but the minis really caught my attention.