Recommend
8 
 Thumb up
 Hide
3 Posts

The Duke» Forums » Reviews

Subject: Chess, Travel Log: Turkey and The Duke rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Michael Mench
United States
Fairfax
Virginia
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
When I was 5 years old I found a chess set in my dad's parent's house and had my uncle teach me to play. I was immediately brought into the grandeur of two royal families battling across distant lands for unimaginable riches and prestige. Bobby Fischer became my hero and I read as much about chess for the next few years as I could. My dad would cut out the weekly chess puzzle from the Philadelphia Inquirer and I would pour over them until I figured it out, and I remember the day I first read about Blitzkrieg and spent an hour teaching my mother how to play chess just so I could move my cheap plastic pieces four times and checkmate her King. I felt like a king! I could do something my parents couldn't and it took me to a world inside my imagination that I could live out on a small board with 32 pieces on 64 magical squares.

When I was 8 years old my grand parents came back from a vacation in Puerto Rico with a gift for me. My second chess set. All marble including the board. It was so heavy, I dented the table with it when I accidentally dropped one of the pieces. In addition to giving 'my chess' validity, it also opened me to life outside my imagination and my home. There were people all over the world too! Like, ACTUAL people. That's a big step in a child's development.

Chess soon gave way to life. Baseball and hockey soon took over and then music became my avocation and then vocation. I don't have that chess set anymore, but I do think it is still at my mother's home in Philly... Will have to check. College brought some monopoly and scattergories and Uno and beer until I met my future wife who had just come back from a choir concert tour of Russia (one week before the tanks rolled into red square!) with a cheap, but artistic chess set that still sits in my collection bookshelf today (that wasn't why I married her.)

Add a few kids and a chance to teach them my lost love of chess, I got my middle son hooked and he soon gave me a run for my abilities. Now we live in Europe and enjoy traveling here quite a bit. We've also started our 'modern gaming' collection and our focus for games has moved into a passion (obsession) that often doesn't have room for those 'simple games' like chess, but my midson's love of it and my interest in cultures keeps us buying more sets and still playing whenever we feel the mood. We bought a beautiful set in Budapest and most recently last week the family was in Istanbul's Grand Bizarre where he found a fantastic set that then found its way onto our sailboat tour of the Greek Islands.

Other than in my youth, pouring over the back pages of Boy's Life drooling over the chance to buy a Star Trek 3D chess board, this is one of the only games since I've never wanted to change or buy an expansion for or modify any other way then just buying a culturally relevant hand made set that pitted armies against armies or fantasy against fantasy. But our sets are a hard game to travel with. We like full sized boards and the Istanbul set just barely fit inside a suitcase and dirty laundry and to be shifted around to backpacks and other suitcases.

But I digress, this is actually a review of Catalyst Game's 2013, The Duke!!

So, I'm sitting on the sailboat one evening playing our 5th or so game of chess, having taken the pieces out of their protective sleeves and it dawned on me that there was a game I heard about but only now thought we'd like. As soon as we got home I drove the three hours up to BraveNewWorld (check them out if you are ever in town!!) in Köln and picked up a copy (along with many other games that will be reviewed later when my wife lets me open them for my birthday in a few weeks.)

I'll be straight with you here (finally): it is a wonderful game but lacks the history, passion, spectacle, grandeur and even (sorry) the strategy of Chess. If you are coming to this review and the game as I did thinking it might be a replacement for chess but don't know much more about The Duke, think of it like chess where every other move your pawn changes to a knight and your queen, after she moves is now a bishop and if you like that idea you might really kinda enjoy this game too.

Thankfully though, The Duke is actually much, much more than that. The pieces are tiles that have movement on each side and after each move that tile is then flipped to its other side. But more than just changing a piece's movement, it adds theme. The Footman, standing guard next to your important Duke can move one square - not leaving the side of the man he is charged to protect, but that then it rallies his muster and jumps forward to lash out with his axe in immediate defense as needed. His next turn he then must relax after that battle. A Marshall can lunge into battle right away and then his next turn command troops in front of him. The Wizard can move any direction and then magically appear somewhere else. A General can lead from the front commanding his troops behind.

All this makes for a fantastic game full of strategy and theme... I think.

I don't know... If you don't mind having wizards pop up in the middle of your feudal wars; if you don't mind, that in the heat of battle when your Duke is in the middle of the field surrounded by enemy pikemen, magically a General appears next to him and saves the day; or that there is a sense of randomness to the play as you only start with three tiles and then must deal with what is next pulled from a bag -- then this might be the best chess replacement there ever was!

Actually... It is the best chess replacement - but it isn't a chess replacement. It is however one of the best Abstract Strategy Theme Filled games we've played. The footprint is 3/4 the size of our standard chess sets, the tiles aren't going to break the table when dropped, everything fits in a small box, the rules are simple, the replay value is high and judging by how many times we've played it so far it is really a high value game for us and except for now wanting each of the five or so $15 expansion packs...

We are still going to play Chess, people all over the world are still going to be playing Chess and artisans will continue to be inspired to create collectable components for a game that will out live us all - but I am glad that we found The Duke, it will go into my travel bag as a permanent addition. And, as I continue to travel the world, I will always be looking for that marble 6x6 grid and marble tiles etched with the dots, stars and pawns of The Duke to give MY grandchildren one day.
13 
 Thumb up
5.00
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Dominik Grottian
Germany
Königswinter
Deutschland
flag msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
Interesting, thoughtful read. Especially because my wife and I also chose The Duke for travelling in Greece this summer. We own all expansions but haven't had the opportunity so far to try them out. We are staying in Greece for two months, so plenty of time to go into some depths. But there is certainly no doubt of The Duke being chess-related, but it's a different animal. Much lighter, much more volatile, unpredictable than chess. Still, it might become a classic in its own right. Speaking of classics, have you ever tried Hive? As a serious chess-replacement while traveling, nothing beats Hive for sure.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Michael Mench
United States
Fairfax
Virginia
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
domin2111 wrote:
Speaking of classics, have you ever tried Hive? As a serious chess-replacement while traveling, nothing beats Hive for sure.


No... One that keeps slipping my mind. I'll look for it next!

Thanks.

M
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.