Recommend
6 
 Thumb up
 Hide
4 Posts

Carcassonne: South Seas» Forums » Reviews

Subject: The Glass Meeple Illuminates Carcassonne: South Seas rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Tina McDuffie
United States
Goose Creek
South Carolina
flag msg tools
designer
Visit TheGlassMeeple.com for game reviews and run-throughs by me.
badge
She who laughs... lasts!
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Carcassonne: South Seas - First Stop Around the World
Originally published on The Glass Meeple (www.TheGlassMeeple.com).
by Tina G. McDuffie


Carcassonne fans and newbies alike will love this stand-alone addition to the Carcassonne family of games. Carcassonne: South Seas features gorgeous artwork depicting an island paradise, new Islander meeples, and 60 wooden wares (bananas, shells and fish) in two sizes. As in the original Carcassonne, up to five players can build the landscape, tile by tile, placing meeples to claim features.

What’s different, besides it being an island paradise instead of a medieval town, is that your islander meeples work as shell collectors, banana pickers, merchants or fishermen who collect wares for you (instead of scoring points) when features are completed. You can then sell those wares to merchant ships docked at the islands for end-game points. The ships are very particular about their orders, though. The player with the most points at the end of the game wins.

Meeple managment is particularly important in Carcassonne: South Seas, as you only have four islanders at your disposal. On your turn, you must place a tile, like landscape to like landscape. After placing a tile, you may optionally place an islander (as a banana picker on an island, as a shell collector on a bridge, as a merchant in a market, or floating flat as a fisherman in the sea) or retrieve an islander you placed earlier. If the tile you placed causes one or more occupied Bridges, Islands, Markets or Sea Regions to be completed, an evaluation is made and Wares or Ships are awarded. You can then, if desired, deliver wares to one ship. The wares required by each ship are depicted on its sail. Ships are where you’ll score the most victory points (two to six points each). Leftover wares at the end of the game are only worth one point per three wares, so you’ll want to acquire as many ships as possible to maximize your score.

As noted above, completed features provide goods instead of points. The number of goods you receive, however has nothing to do with how many tiles make up the feature, but instead with how many wares are depicted in the completed feature. Bridges provide the depicted number of shells when terminated at both ends, while completed islands yield bananas.

Sea Regions are the most unique, in that you can trigger an evaluation in two ways: either by completely enclosing it or by placing a tile depicting a fishing boat in the area. In the latter case, the player who triggered the evaluation covers one group of fish in the region with a fishing boat token, after awarding the appropriate amount of fish to the occupying fisherman. Thus, an open sea region can become overfished as it is occupied, scored, depleted (one fish group covered with a fishing boat), then occupied again... It’s a neat new mechanism.

Markets work like the abbeys in the original Carcassonne: they’re considered complete when surrounded by eight tiles. Then they earn the occupier the highest value ship in port!

As in all Carcassonne games, areas can become contested when multiple meeples occupy the same territory with the majority prevailing and ties awarding points to both players occupying the feature. It takes some creative tile placement to horn in on another player’s territory, however, because just like in the original game, you can only place a meeple in an unoccupied region. You may not find yourself contesting features as much, though as you only have four islander meeples to play with.

A game of Carcassonne: South Seas ends when all tiles have been placed or the last ship has been acquired. Final shells, bananas and fish are then distributed for occupied, but incomplete areas. Players add up the points for their acquired ships (2 to 6 points each), plus 1 point for every 3 wares they have left, regardless of type. The player with the highest score wins and is crowned Ruler of the South Seas!

Carcassonne: South Seas supports 2 to 5 players ages 8 and up and plays in about 30 minutes.


Links:
* The Glass Meeple Illuminates Subscription List
* Original article at The Glass Meeple (www.TheGlassMeeple.com)
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Jorik
Netherlands
Utrecht
Utrecht
flag msg tools
badge
How sticky is your ZOC?
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I'm missing a vital bit of a review.

your opinion about it, for example. this is just an (well written and concise) explanation.
how does it compare to original carc?
those are the questions that are interesting.
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
William Garner

Summerville
South Carolina
msg tools
mbmbmbmbmb
Great job Tina.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Tina McDuffie
United States
Goose Creek
South Carolina
flag msg tools
designer
Visit TheGlassMeeple.com for game reviews and run-throughs by me.
badge
She who laughs... lasts!
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
HerrJork wrote:
I'm missing a vital bit of a review.

your opinion about it, for example. this is just an (well written and concise) explanation.
how does it compare to original carc?
those are the questions that are interesting.

I guess my "reviews" are really more run-throughs, describing everything the back of the box doesn't tell you so you have a better idea of how the game plays, its theme, components, etc. I figure whether I like the game or not is irrelevant to most people. But since you asked:

I really like Carcassonne: South Seas. I thought it was a nice refreshing breeze. It provides a new twist on Carcassonne with its focus on acquiring goods, which may or may not lead to points (depends on if you can deliver them). It requires new strategies - always good for keeping a game fresh and interesting, has lovely and colorful components and is a lot of fun to play - even for Carcassonne die hards who think they've seen it all. I particularly like the way the fish score and rescore. It captures the idea of fishing nicely.

Comparing it to the original Carc: I think it's more colorful and interesting than the plain old Carcassonne base game without any expansions. But I only play that when I'm teaching newbies who've never played a Carcassonne game before. My Carc "base game" includes a base set, a river, Inns & Cathedrals and Traders & Builders, then we build from there. Original Carcassonne has lots and lots more expandability and thus replayability to me. See my Themed Carcassonne Combos Geek List for examples of just how far it can be stretched.

Hope this helps.



5 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls