Shelter Island Heights
The short blurb for this game says it has "2 scenarios"
How does this affect the replayability of the game? With only 2 scenarios is it truly a fun and different experience every time?
To be clear there are three possible starts to the game: 1805, 1809 or 1813. The latter two being the two scenarios you mention, but in all cases the game then unfolds until sudden death victory or 1815. The replayability comes from the fact that there are many different ways to go about winning and most of the play is implemented through cards that are randomly drawn from a deck. While I made a clear attempt at preventing totally ahistorical situations, I also tried to avoid straightjacketing the flow of the game and thus no game is like another.