Peter Hawes wrote:
Although I agree with what Andrew and Chris have said above, if you interpret the rules literally, I would give the 3rd player home the bonus. The intent of the rule as written was the first player home, who attacked the Spanish gets 2 VP and the 2nd player home (who attacked the Spanish) would get 1 VP. The way the rule is written was meant to infer the first 2 players home who had attacked the Spanish. It was written a little clumsily, sorry.
Hey, just to confirm -- not only must they have attached the Spanish, they must also not have used up their 4th disk, correct?