GeekGold Bonus for All Supporters at year's end: 1000!
21 Days Left
I know this is like a heresy (everybody knows everybody needs both!), but what would you choose and why?
Atlantic Wall... my friend says it is HUGE and perfect.
The Greatest Day... well, I know it is more detailed in scope, does not cover so much time as Atlantic Wall...
What do you prefer and why?
"...the art of manoeuvering armies...an art which none may master by the light of nature. but to which, if he is to attain success, a man must serve a long apprenticeship." -- G.F.R. Henderson
It all depends on what you are after. The Greatest Day: Sword, Juno, and Gold Beaches is tactically focused; each turn is only a few hours and the game covers just the first ten days of the situation opposite the British beaches. There's a reason that this is part of the Grand Tactical Series; it's just--well--grandly tactical! Lots of great chaos and tactical narrative. Tons of opportunity for maneuver, making sure your leaders are where you want them, trying to out-OODA Loop your opponent's decision cycle! Quite a number of scenarios, even if you can't get to the campaign games (but you'll dream about it!)
Atlantic Wall: D-Day to Falaise is more of a study as a simulation than a competitive game. The focus truly is on the operational level and the complex system shows it. Remember, this is the Grand Operational Simulation Series -- the name says it all. There's not going to be a lot of excitement; the scenarios are even a grind-fest for the most part. You'll be thinking more of firepower and logistics than maneuver, leadership, and C2 decision cycles! I cannot even imagine playing the campaign games for this one. I just can't. Maybe if I were younger, I could....
Pick your poison!
Runs with scissors
The die is cast.
You say OCD like it's a bad thing.
I'd ask whether you prefer tactical or operational. I think that a comparison of Atlantic Wall to The Battle for Normandy and maybe the expansion The Battle for Normandy Expansion might be more appropriate.
Typically the GTS games will only cover a week of time or so. I think that Greatest day might be 10 days, but don't quote me. I've found that when playing GTS games they also go slower than real time. You might end up spending several hours playing a turn that represents two hours of time. This is particularly true when you are ramping up and need to do a lot of rules checking.
The other big question is how much table space do you have, and what can you support. Also how long can you leave it up without getting in trouble with other people who share the living space. Not a problem if you're going to be using vassal. I'm playing Where Eagles Dare right now. We've been meeting every 2-3 weeks, and we've been going at it for 5 months. I think that we've had about 7 day long sessions so far and have done about 3-4 days.
My view is skewed because I primarily play the campaign games and am not so interested in shorter scenarios other than as a learning tool.
Another factor to consider is that I'm pretty sure that Omaha and Utah Beaches will be added in future modules so that you can link all 5 beaches together. They only practical way to play that is going to be with teams, an maybe only at conventions due to table space requirements (or via vassal).
- Last edited Tue Dec 29, 2015 5:44 am (Total Number of Edits: 1)
- Posted Tue Dec 29, 2015 5:43 am