Recommend
18 
 Thumb up
 Hide
5 Posts

IKI» Forums » Reviews

Subject: A big, long review of Iki! rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Ben M
United States
Los Angeles
California
flag msg tools
mbmbmb
I may be an unabashed board game nerd these days, but it's only because there are so many fun games out there. Truly — it's a problem. An embarrassment of riches. Just when I think I can ebb the purchasing, another great one comes down the pike, the latest being Iki — a Japanese "game of Edo artisans." Well, if that's not a selling point, I don't know what is.

I first learned about Iki during a particularly fruitful span of procrastination that had me exploring the depths of boardgamegeek.com. First, I came upon a glowing review of the game, and since it sounded interesting, I dug deeper until I found a playthrough on YouTube. After watching a few rounds of Iki, I went to the mirror and saw that I had giant hearts in my eyes. Oh dear. Time to make more room in my Ikea shelving system.

Iki is a nifty game that focuses on the Nihonbashi market in Edo period Japan (a.k.a. Tokyo). It's kind of a very specific setting for a board game, and as per usual, I've already had several friends incredulously chuckle something along the lines of "Where do you find these games?" The truth is that there's a game for seemingly every topic: pig farming in Mallorca (La Granja), winemaking in Tuscany (Viticulture), hotel management in Austria (Grand Austria Hotel), and on and on. At this point, a game about an ancient Japanese market almost seems rote.

Nevertheless, up to four players assume the roles of kobun — vague boss men whose responsibilities land somewhere between pimp and benefactor. You see, as an entrepreneurial kobun, you will undoubtedly hire a handful of people over the course of the game, all of whom will toil away to provide services to you and your opponents. These workers may vary from ear cleaners to geishas to glassblowers to samurais, and at the end of every season (each season spans three months/rounds), they will shower bonuses upon you. They may give you money or lumber or simply the titular Iki, which represents the spirit of the market (or, more technically, victory points). All these humble workers ask for in return is to be fed a few bales of rice. Is that asking too much?? Well, the answer to that is surprisingly tricky.

Should you be unable to feed your workers, they will quit and leave the market for better opportunities elsewhere. However, if you can keep your peeps around long enough, they'll actually gain "experience" over time and eventually retire. Once workers do that, they'll still bestow gifts upon you, but you won't have to feed their hungry asses. Such is the privilege of a DOTING KOBUN. And so it is in your best interest to help your underlings amass experience as quickly as possible in order to shove them into a post-employment state (which also contributes to end game scoring).

So how does one get experience for workers? And where does one procure rice anyway? And how the HELL does anyone have enough money to hire any of these people in the first place??

The answers are in the market, my friend.

You see, after hiring a vendor (alternatively, one can just receive four coins), one advances through the market, which exists as an eternal, eight-space loop — or "rondel" — on the game board. One must circle through repeatedly until thirteen months have passed, at which point the game ends. During each tour of Nihonbashi, kobuns visit shops, amass wealth, acquire food, and occasionally do something perfectly lovely such as nab a fresh bonito fish in the summer months.

There are also opportunities to indulge in tobacco (as well as an accompanying pipe, should you feel so inclined to actually smoke that wacky tobacky) or perhaps grab a few pairs of sandals. Especially intrepid kobuns may collect lumber and a valuable currency known as koban, all in the pursuit of erecting a shrine, a merchant house, or — most excitingly — a kabuki theater!

Each shop allows players to take an action (pay three coins to receive two bales of rice, for instance), and if someone has installed a worker or two at that location, there's an opportunity to take an additional action, as dictated by the worker card. So, for instance, not only can you purchase those bales of rice, you can also receive a few coins from the cloth dyer, if he's hanging around.

What's even more fun is that if an opponent uses your employee's action, that worker gains aforementioned experience — the very experience necessary to hasten retirement. Don't worry though: if no one visits your lonely sushi stand, he will still level-up every time your kobun completes a lap at the market. In fact, all of your workers increase their experience a notch when this happens. Therefore it's in your best interest to zip through the market as quickly as possible in order to advance your worker army towards retirement.

But is that the smartest thing to do? How are you going to feed your people if you're running past the rice peddlers like a madman? And what if you need to pick up that bonito? Or a SEA BREAM?? (I should mention that those fish are worth mucho points at the end of the game). On second thought, you had better slow down, Mister.

But wait... if you just amble through the market with no urgency, your guys will take forevvvver to level up (because, let's face it, none of your competitors are going to help your workers level up unless they truly have to). If you don't sweep your guys into retirement, then you'll have to feed them, and no one likes feeding employees (except, maybe Google). Oh, and there's one other issue: players can only have four workers out in the market at any given time (less if they've constructed buildings). How frustrating to see waves of useful vendors go unhired because your stupid soap bubble man still hasn't retired.

This is one of the central tensions and joys of Iki: does one move swiftly through Nihonbashi to retire workers? Or does one meticulously visit each shop along the way in order to make full use of the market's powers?

One of those extremely important powers is firefighting ability. Since this is a marketplace built of wood and paper, it's not uncommon for a fire to occasionally sweep through and wreak havoc (something that apparently happened with great frequency in Edo period Japan). Fires in Iki will kill workers (RIP Eyeglass Peddler who I did not protect) and burn down structures. Therefore, players can — and should — spend some time improving their firefighting skillz.

Of course, one could simply ignore the firefighting track and gamble that the blaze will break out in a different corner of the market. Orrrr even better, a sneaky person could just place all their workers next to an opponent who has a high firefighting capability and essentially use them as a human shield. But that plan could backfire (no pun intended) should your protector suddenly retire and leave the market, exposing you to the brutal flames of fate.

Having a strong firefighting power not only protects vendors and buildings, but it also offers a unique and important gameplay advantage. Whoever is farthest along on the firefighting track gets first dibs on the "Way of Life" track. This basically is how one determines how far in the market they'll be moving — from one to four spaces. No two players can claim the same spot on this track, which means that if you need to go three spaces and someone else has claimed the 3 spot; you may be screwed (you can alternatively take the 1 spot and then use sandals to get extra movements in the market, but... if you don't have sandals, you're back to being screwed). And I can assure you of one thing: people will intentionally screw you out of movements if they see you're headed towards a specific shop. In a four player game, having priority on the Way of Life track is essential. Whoever's last must be content with whatever spot remains, or they can opt for a special action which allows them to travel any number of spaces — but they must forgo the opportunity to hire or collect money. Rough.

Not all is lost, though. Whoever claims the least number of movements gets to resolve their turn first, which importantly means they'll have first dibs on new workers (or that sea bream, which is in limited supply! Same goes for the tobacco and pipes — also worth many points). This all funnels back into that central tension of how quickly one rushes through the market. Those who fly through will most certainly get last pick of employees, but may get to perform vital actions more frequently. Those who take their time will get the best opportunities and hires — but may fall behind the firefighting / retirement pace.

GAH.


Iki is all about trade-offs. No decision comes without a huge risk. Even placement of artisans can be fraught with multi-layered dilemmas. You might want to place a dice maker where it's advantageous to you and your goals, but then no one may visit him. Alternatively, you might install him someplace where others are highly incentivized to visit him but is inconvenient to you. Also, outer market stalls are more vulnerable to fires, but inner stalls are more expensive. Oh, and did I mention that workers come in five different colors, and players receive seasonal bonuses if a bunch of like-colored workers are placed next to each other? That sounds great, but then at the end of the game, you're rewarded for having a variety of colors. So, do you go for blocks of color throughout the game, or a set of all five colors for the end of the game? And what if someone places a folding fan maker RIGHT where you were going to put your croupier?? Now you have to weigh your options all over again from the start. UGH. (But it's a fun "ugh"). This is just a fraction of the decision-making that Iki forces its players into.

It's amazing if you think about it. All you're really doing in this game is hiring, moving, and transacting, but the layers upon layers of strategy that develop are fascinating. Compounding this is the very high degree of player interaction. Y'all will be up in each other's business. Perhaps you'll be angling to hire the same dumpling peddler as your opponent. Or maybe you both want to land at a coveted shop to nab some firefighting boosts. Or maybe you're both racing to the last tobacco pouch. Or maybe it's an arms race to erect that fancy kabuki theater. Like a real market, there is jostling for position at all times.

As the game progresses, strategies will coalesce, and soon your opponents will be able to anticipate your next move. Suddenly they'll be snagging the Way of Life spot you so desperately need, forcing you to make one more hasty lap through Nihonbashi in order to land at the shop that would ordinarily be mere steps away.

Meanwhile, some of the occupations allow all sorts of nuanced, complicated player interactions. Take, for instance, a certain card that allows players to swap two vendors' locations on the board. This can add such a layer of unpredictability to the game that it might be better to simply retire it off the board before it can do too much damage. But then you risk benefiting your opponent. THE CHOICES! SO MANY!

Yes, the gameplay in Iki is awesome, but making the experience all the more engaging and memorable is the game's theme. Sure, Edo period Japan may not be everyone's go-to setting, but the festive board (based off an 1805 mural titled Kidai Shôran) is an inviting centerpiece, replete with little people scurrying about.

Even better are the occupation cards, each of which features charming artwork and a unique personality. This lends itself to jokey storytelling, and soon, players are proudly boasting about their candy makers and sumo wrestlers, offering up colorful backstories or ongoing commentary about their lives. When my friend Sly proved to be incapable of feeding her vendors on a regular basis, we spun tales of how she was a terrible boss, forcing her workers to churn out goods in return for nary a grain of rice. I believe the term "North Korea" was used. This was fun.

And then there's the inevitable moment when you and your opponent both install vendors in the same shop (each shop can accommodate two), and wouldn't you know it: your guys offer the exact same service. Suddenly, the two of you are wooing a third player, encouraging them to swing by and use YOUR charcoal peddler, not your rival's pine wreath supplier. You'll be a sandwich board and a sample tray away from a full-fledged marketing blitz.

It's worth noting that Iki has a surprisingly large amount of variability. At first blush, this may not appear to be the case: there are always the same six buildings to construct, there are always the same four starter cards to choose from, and many of the occupation cards will resurface time and time again. However, the order in which those occupations emerge from the deck keeps everything — everything — variable. And where those occupations wind up in the market also plays a remarkably large role in keeping each session of Iki fresh and unique. Oh, and then there are those pesky fires. One bad blaze, and the entire balance of the game can be thrown into question.

There's only one significant drawback to Iki: it's not widely available. I tracked down my copy by going to the marketplace at boardgamegeek.com. It was a hassle, but so so worth it. I'm not sure if Iki will find a wide audience, but hopefully awareness will translate into demand, and with any luck, one of the big game publishers will scoop up the rights and give this game the distribution it deserves.

Should you encounter this game somewhere, do not hesitate for one nanosecond. Grab it, invite your friends over, and prepare for a thinky, occasionally rowdy, and totally FUN experience. Iki is perfection (except for its questionably translated rulebook).


Have you played Iki? What do you think?


To see the original post with 20+ photos, check out http://www.bsideblog.com/2016/02/adventures-in-game-time-iki... Thanks!
22 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Dr.NAKAGAWA Kozi
Japan
Kumagaya.City
SAITAMA
flag msg tools
Love ESSEN
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Great review!meeple
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Lutz Pietschker
Germany
Berlin
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
A great, long review that captures exactly what fascinates me about this game. Thank you!
We just played it in my games club for the second week, and people asked me if we could have a third go at it next week. Unprecedented in that group, in my experience.

A bit of nitpicking:
Quote:
… four players assume the roles of kobun …

Not quite – the kobun are the lower rank, the player might be the oyakata or even the oyakata's boss (it is explained here). You have one oyakata and four kobun in the game.

Quote:
IKI … spirit of the market …

A bit deeper than that, more like an attitude towards civic life.

Quote:
… an 1805 mural titled Kidai Shôran …

A paper scroll, actually. 12 metres long, 45 cm wide, showing more than 1600 people.

Quote:
Should you encounter this game somewhere, do not hesitate for one nanosecond.

Seconded!

Quote:
… except for its questionably translated rulebook.

Someone is working on that. The German rulebook is already up to scratch.
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Ben M
United States
Los Angeles
California
flag msg tools
mbmbmb
Thanks for the notes — a review that long was bound to have some errors!
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Gabi Games
msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Great review, capturing the atmosphere and mechanics of the game. A straightforward game where there's a lot going on. It shares the first place with Grand Austria Hotel in my games of 2015.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.