$15.00
$5.00
$20.00
Recommend
2 
 Thumb up
 Hide
1 Posts

Panzer Grenadier: Saipan 1944» Forums » General

Subject: AAR: Golden Journal, Equinox 2015: Massed Armor rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Jay Townsend
United States
Longmont
Colorado
flag msg tools
designer
mbmbmbmbmb
Golden Journal, Equinox 2015: Massed Armor

Ok, I have been wanting to play this for a long time, as it uses my game design but is not my scenario design, so I can give an unbiased AAR! It also uses counters and maps from Saipan, the Equinox 2015 and a few counters from Elsenborn Ridge so it is pretty easy to setup and play. I have always wanted to play with these more modern Japanese armor types. The only thing that will come somewhat close to this, is my yet to be published Philippines 1944-45 design, that has the whole Japanese 2nd Tank Division, with boat loads of Type 97 Shinhoto 47mm tanks, Type 1 Ho-NI 1 75mm and Type 4 Ho-Ro 150mm self-propelled tanks but still nothing like the Type 1, Type 3 and Type 4 tanks in the Equinox, left on the Japanese homeland at the end of the war. Now it is time to finally test them out in a Panzer Grenadier setting.

I found a little errata for this scenario I must mention, so others will be able to play this as well. First the Equinox only provided (5) Type 1 and (5) Type 4 counters and the setup says 6 each, so go with five unless you own two copies of the Equinox which I do and will play with all of the requested counters but it should not make a big difference. Second the Americans should setup first and the Japanese second. Last, the visibility should be two hexes throughout the game. Minor things, but people will ask.

Now the setup for both sides should be straight forward depending on your strategies but the victory in this scenario all depends on if the Americans control any of the east-west road hexes with a unit on or adjacent to these road hexes at the end of game. The Japanese Infantry starts setup on the map as do all the American units including their armor while the Japanese huge armor force of the 26th Tank Regiment enters on the east edge of the map on the first turn. I setup all the Americans on, or adjacent to the road or in supporting defense positions for counter-attacks on the east-west road on map 83. The American armor and AT guns and infantry are pretty intermixed to support each other. The placed the Japanese Infantry on the west edge of map 82, to be able to attack right away as the Japanese armor might take a couple of turns to reach them. I thought about waiting for the armor but decided against it. The American have a large off-board artillery while the Japanese a much smaller amount to call on. This should be interesting.

I ended up playing this scenario on and off again for about 4-5 days and enjoyed it very much. I took about 40 pictures to tell the story but realized I was only going to post 3 of them, as it was way too many photos to post. The Japanese obviously had to go on the offensive to win and clear the east-west road of American units. I pushed the Japanese Infantry head-long into the American lines to try and soften it up a bit for the huge Japanese armor force bring up the rear. But it became obvious to me that they were already taking too many Infantry casualties and needed to wait a bit more for the armor. The Americans only job was to shift units about and position and reposition their armor. At first I thought all the Japanese would bottle up on the one road and would never break through, but I remember the Saipan special rules in the scenario book, where Mechanized units can move through jungle at the cost of 4 movement points and also found two movement areas with not too much jungle to slip armor through and break the bottleneck. Visibility allowed the Japanese to close in adjacent to American units in most case. The Japanese assault bonus off set the dug-in Americans somewhat. The Sherman tanks and Stuart tanks could handle the Shinhotos and Type 1 Japanese tanks but the Type 3s were equal and the Type 4s were better. The Americans having efficiency offset this a little but the Japanese tank numbers were telling with 40 steps to American 18 steps and 2 steps of 57mm AT guns. Once the Japanese eliminated the American armor, they could concentrate on the American Infantry and supporting units. The off-board artillery favored the American but they only rolled high in the beginning of the game and then not so well, trying not to hit their own intermixed units.

The battle took almost all the turns to get an outcome however, as the terrain is rough and it is night but in the end after pushing some American back again and off the adjacent road hexes, the Japanese won a victory in a wild night action, with the Japanese armor I have always wanted to play with since I first started gaming. I would give this scenario a 5 out of 5 but for the errata mentioned above, so I’ll give it a 4.5 out of 5. Great fun in this hypothetical scenario, that is well worth playing!
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.