I am looking to get Castles of Burgundy and one of the following three:
1) Champions of Midgard
2) Isle of Skye
3) Gold West
I usually play games with a monthly game group of 3-5, my family with kids ranging from 11-16 years old, and a occasional gaming lunch with co-workers.
1) fun with a variety of player counts
2) 45-90 minute play time range
3) medium weight
You can check out my collection, but the games I've had the most success/fun with recently are (in order):
1) Roll for the Galaxy
2) Lords of Waterdeep
3) 7 Wonders
Thanks in advance!
My pick of the three would be Isle of Skye.
Champions of Midgard seems to be plus/minus Lords of Waterdeep - some people think the one fired the other or that the other is the inferior version of the one - either way, seems (too) close to what you've already got.
And I don't know anything about Gold West