We can't get enough of Ice Cool. It is flicking fun!
My game group's only issue with this is the scoring. We have some good flickers that get stuck with a bad hand of scoring cards.
I won the last game just by having the luck of drawing only value 3 cards even though I never made it out of the gym in the last round.
Still I'd play this game in a heartbeat.
Remove the random draw element ... as the chaser the 1st touch gets you a 3-point card, second a 2-point card, third gets a 1-point card. Same for fish collection (first fish is 3 points then 2 then 1 ...)
The game should play just as well with this system and the most skilled play should win most of the time.