Thumb up
1 Posts

NOIR: Deductive Mystery Game» Forums » Reviews

Subject: A little black box with a whole lot of game inside. rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Jason Johnson
United States
flag msg tools
The Overview

Noir: Black Box Edition is a clever collection of six deduction games.

The Good

Quick. The simplest games are designed to take less than 15 minutes and the most complex take an hour.

Tense. Winning requires wits and luck.

Variety. Includes six different games. Supports 2 to 9 players!

Small Footprint. Comes in a small box and requires relatively little table space.

The Meh

Tight Storage. The box insert barely holds the cards. It can be difficult to get the cards out of the insert.

Unclear Rules. Some of the rules are written awkwardly and take time to decipher.

The Bad

Loopholes. Some game rules naturally lead to bad game experiences.

In Killer vs Inspector, once the Killer figures out the detective's identity, the detective is trapped in a Monopoly-style death spiral. Unfortunately, due to the Killer's abilities to canvas and change identity, this issue occurs frequently.

In Hitman vs Sleuth, the impact of the issue is lessened by the Sleuth having three possible identities. However, exhausting the deck still swings the game heavily in the Hitman's favor, especially if the Sleuth has lost any identities.

The Notable Mechanics

Random Setup. A critical part of the game. Without randomized starting conditions there wouldn't be any deduction or variety!

Identity Swapping. Without the ability to change their identity the criminal would be cornered very quickly.

The limited swapping used in Master Thief vs Chief of Police limits the Thief to a pool of three identities. This is a superior version of the swapping mechanic that preserves tension and avoids Loopholes.

Canvasing. When you play a card onto the field your opponent(s) must reveal if their identity is adjacent to that card. This simple mechanic is a powerful and tactical action. However, it is also a major part of what causes Loopholes.

Shifting & Collapsing. Moving rows or columns (shifting) and removing rows or columns (collapsing) are how players maneuver closer to their targets. They can also be used to distract and mislead your opponents.

Capture. Knowing their identity isn't enough. Your opponent(s) must be captured (or killed). You must also be adjacent to an opponent to capture them. This system often creates a tense chase where players need to pin down their opponent(s) without revealing their own identity.

Roles. Each game has a different set of roles for players. Many roles are similar, however, there are meaningful differences in each game, and the more advanced roles in games like Mafia vs FBI add more variety and depth to the mix.

The Summary
Noir: Black Box Edition is a fun & fast collection of deduction games and a great addition to our collection.

+ quick
+ variety
+ tense 'cat & mouse'
+ small package
+ simple clever mechanics
• box insert too small
• some confusing rules
- loopholes

For more information about Noir: Black Box Edition visit

This review with images is available at
More reviews available at
 Thumb up
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.