Recommend
7 
 Thumb up
 Hide
10 Posts

Cosmic Encounter» Forums » General

Subject: Alien Ratings rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Victor Kolbe
msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
So I'm a sucker for numbers and rankings (probably to an unhealthy degree) and was completely enamored by Jack's spreadsheet on the Warp ( http://redamedia.com/warp/cerank.php ) - So much so that I decided to use my arguably excessive free time to compile an average rating out of the votes for the first 3 sets, and thought it could be nice to share.

There may be a few errors for I, in an act of sheer brilliance, decided to do it all by hand. So here we go

BASE SET
Amoeba 71.2%
Anti-Matter 80.8%
Barbarian 59.2%
Calculator 62.4%
Chosen 63.8%
Citadel 68.6%
Clone 84.4%
Cudgel 54.8%
Dictator 72.8%
Fido 67.2%
Filch 70.8%
Fodder 75.2%
Gambler 70.8%
Grudge 64.4%
Hacker 68.3%
Hate 57.6%
Healer 72.7%
Human 64.0%
Kamikaze 75.0%
Loser 91.8%
Machine 73.0%
Macron 56.8%
Masochist 49.6%
Mind 78.2%
Mirror 77.6%
Miser 76.7%
Mite 69.6%
Mutant 76.4%
Observer 59.1%
Oracle 83.8%
Pacifist 87.2%
Parasite 84.0%
Philanthropist 84.0%

Reincarnator 61,7%
Remora 73.6%
Reserve 71.3%
Shadow 68.8%
Sorcerer 80.9%
Spiff 65.8%
Tick-Tock 59.2%
Trader 82.5%
Tripler 64.2%
Vacuum 70.8%
Virus 85.6%
Void 67.0%
Vulch 76.7%
Warpish 70.4%
Warrior 72.8%
Will 65.6%
Zombie 65.9%


COSMIC INCURSION

Bully 71.8%
Chronos 72.2%
Cryo 75.3%
Deuce 71.1%
Disease 78.8%
Ethic 68.8%
Fungus 81.1%
Fury 69.4%
Genius 54.0%
Ghoul 80.0%
Guerrilla 62.4%
Leviathan 74.7%
Locust 28.4% (no surprises here)
Magician 71.6%
Mercenary 78.8%
Merchant 87.1%
Plant 58.9%
Seeker 73.7%
Sniveler 82.0%
Symbiote 58.8%


COSMIC CONFLICT

Cavalry 71.8%
Changeling 53.8%
The Claw 70.0%
Empath 74.1%
Filth 75.6%
Glutton 82.5%
Graviton 62.4%
Industrialist 72.2%
Invader 75.6%
Lunatic 70.6%
Mimic 72.5%
Prophet 70.6%
Relic 66.7%
Saboteur 67.8%
Sadist 48.9%
Siren 73.3%
Trickster 60.0%
Visionary 75.3%
Warhawk 73.3%
Xenophile 76.5%



Once again, there may be a few errors in there but I trust this could somewhat represent an idea of where those people stand with the aliens. It goes without saying that this should not be taken as law by any means! I myself disagree heavily with some of them.

But oh well. Thought it could be interesting.

EDITS: Formatting
5 
 Thumb up
0.02
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Victor Kolbe
msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Oh, shoot. I lost most of my formatting. Forgive me for the lack of proper indentation, everybody
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Just a Bill
United States
Norfolk
Virginia
flag msg tools
designer
badge
No, I said "oh, brother," not "go hover."
Avatar
Your method of summarizing makes the worst possible score 20%. If 1 million voters all gave an alien a 1 for "worst," I would expect this to get a summary score of 0%, not 20%. This is because you've basically used a y-intercept of 1 instead of 0.

If you agree, you can adjust this by simply subtracting 1 from the rank values (removing the y-intercept bias and setting worst = 0, best = 4) and then multiplying your weighted total by 25 instead of 20. Or, if you don't want to re-crunch everything, you can just apply a post adjustment:

new score = ((old score / 20) - 1 ) * 25

which is equivalent to

new score = 1.25 * old score - 25

For example, Locust would go from 28.4 to 10.5, a better representation of the votes. And any score from 0 to 100 would be possible (as it stands, you only allow scores from 20 to 100).
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Victor Kolbe
msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
This was meant more as a method of ranking the aliens among themselves than an accurate grading I suppose, but yes, maybe I'll do that!
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Victor Kolbe
msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
updated with Bill's formula -


BASE SET
Amoeba 64.0%
Anti-Matter 76.0%
Barbarian 49.0%
Calculator 53.0%
Chosen 54.75%
Citadel 60.75%
Clone 80.5%
Cudgel 43.5%
Dictator 66.0%
Fido 59.0%
Filch 63.5%
Fodder 69.0%
Gambler 63.5%
Grudge 55.5%
Hacker 50.4%
Hate 47.0%
Healer 65.9%
Human 55.0%
Kamikaze 68.8%
Loser 89.8%
Machine 66.3%
Macron 46.0%
Masochist 37.0%
Mind 72.8%
Mirror 72.0%
Miser 70.9%
Mite 62.0%
Mutant 70.5%
Observer 48.9%
Oracle 79.8%
Pacifist 84.0%
Parasite 80.0%
Philanthropist 80.0%

Reincarnator 52.1%
Remora 67.0%
Reserve 64.1%
Shadow 61.0%
Sorcerer 76.1%
Spiff 57.3%
Tick-Tock 49.0%
Trader 78.1%
Tripler 55.3%
Vacuum 63.5%
Virus 82.0%
Void 58.8%
Vulch 70.9%
Warpish 63.0%
Warrior 66.0%
Will 57.0%
Zombie 57.4%


COSMIC INCURSION

Bully 64.8%
Chronos 65.3%
Cryo 69.1%
Deuce 63.9%
Disease 73.5%
Ethic 61.0%
Fungus 76.4%
Fury 61.8%
Genius 42.5%
Ghoul 75.0%
Guerrilla 53.0%
Leviathan 68.4%
Locust 10.5% (no surprises here)
Magician 64.5%
Mercenary 73.5%
Merchant 83.9%
Plant 48.6%
Seeker 67.1%
Sniveler 77.5%
Symbiote 48.5%


COSMIC CONFLICT

Cavalry 64.8%
Changeling 42.3%
The Claw 62.5%
Empath 67.6%
Filth 69.5%
Glutton 78.1%
Graviton 53.0%
Industrialist 62.3%
Invader 69.5%
Lunatic 63.3%
Mimic 65.6%
Prophet 63.3%
Relic 58.4%
Saboteur 59.8%
Sadist 36.1%
Siren 66.6%
Trickster 50% (I love life)
Visionary 69.1%
Warhawk 66.6%
Xenophile 70.6%


EDIT: Formatting
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Victor Kolbe
msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
And just for the hell of it:

Top Ratings (Base, CI, CC)

1. Loser
2. Pacifist
3. Merchant
4. Virus
5. Clone
6. Parasite
6. Philanthropist
8. Oracle
9. Trader
9. Glutton
11. Sniveler

Bottom Ratings (Base, CI, CC)

1. Locust
2. Sadist
3. Masochist
4. Changeling
5. Genius
6. Cudgel
7. Macron
8. Hate
9. Symbiote
10.Plant
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Don Clarke
United Kingdom
Nantwich
Cheshire
flag msg tools
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Can this be done for the other aliens?
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Don Clarke
United Kingdom
Nantwich
Cheshire
flag msg tools
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
yangtze2000 wrote:
Can this be done for the other aliens?


I just did it myself. Someone might want to check my workings, but I think it's right, and adjusted according to Bill's formula:

Alliance
Animal 15.05
Bandit 9.16
Butler 6.25
Chrysalis 7.41
Crystal 10.16
Cyborg 24.70
Extortionist 26.43
General 20.94
Gorgon 13.06
Horde 11.76
Lightning 28.66
Poison 21.12
Pygmy 15.05
Reborn 24.77
Remote 10.02
Sapient 22.83
Schizoid 7.43
Skeptic 10.16
Sting 19.58
Winner 15.24

Storm
Arcade 10.02
Brute 11.12
Bulwarks 21.12
Converter 32.36
Coordinator 17.20
Dervish 11.12
Grumpus 60.00
Mouth 24.71
Neighbor 8.15
Outlaw 24.43
Patriot 14.48
Phantasm 43.86
Porcupine 17.11
Roach 14.43
Scavenger 19.97
Sloth 27.25
Sneak 32.36
Squee 8.15
Swindler 3.36
Sycophant 14.56
Tide 7.78
Tyrant 27.78
Vox 21.09
Worm 16.63
Wormhole 17.78

Dominion
Ace 12.14
Alchemist 17.97
Angler 16.63
Aristocrat 25.78
Bride 11.13
Daredevil 37.80
Diplomat 17.97
Doppelganger 10.00
Engineer 23.81
Explorer 25.53
Greenhorn 5.55
Host 27.78
Joker 20.04
Judge 23.81
Laser 24.43
Lizard 12.21
Love 18.95
Mesmer 22.21
Mirage 37.80
Muckraker 23.36
Pentaform 9.14
Pickpockets 11.12
Pirate 18.95
Quartermaster 27.78
Reactor 11.12
Tourist 8.87
Usurper 18.89
Voyager 24.74
Whirligig 31.09
Yin-Yang 16.03

Are there comparable figures for Eons aliens?
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Don Clarke
United Kingdom
Nantwich
Cheshire
flag msg tools
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
This gives the following overall rank order. Letter = expansion (B = base set):

Loser 89.80 B
Pacifist 84.00 B
Merchant 83.90 I
Virus 82.00 B
Clone 80.50 B
Parasite 80.00 B
Philanthropist 80.00 B
Oracle 79.80 B
Trader 78.10 B
Glutton 78.10 C
Sniveler 77.50 I
Fungus 76.40 I
Sorcerer 76.10 B
Anti-Matter 76.00 B
Ghoul 75.00 I
Disease 73.50 I
Mercenary 73.50 I
Mind 72.80 B
Mirror 72.00 B
Miser 70.90 B
Vulch 70.90 B
Xenophile 70.60 C
Mutant 70.50 B
Filth 69.50 C
Invader 69.50 C
Cryo 69.10 I
Visionary 69.10 C
Fodder 69.00 B
Kamikaze 68.80 B
Leviathan 68.40 I
Empath 67.60 C
Seeker 67.10 I
Remora 67.00 B
Siren 66.60 C
Warhawk 66.60 C
Machine 66.30 B
Dictator 66.00 B
Warrior 66.00 B
Healer 65.90 B
Mimic 65.60 C
Chronos 65.30 I
Bully 64.80 I
Cavalry 64.80 C
Magician 64.50 I
Reserve 64.10 B
Amoeba 64.00 B
Deuce 63.90 I
Filch 63.50 B
Gambler 63.50 B
Vacuum 63.50 B
Lunatic 63.30 C
Prophet 63.30 C
Warpish 63.00 B
The Claw 62.50 C
Industrialist 62.30 C
Mite 62.00 B
Fury 61.80 I
Shadow 61.00 B
Ethic 61.00 I
Citadel 60.75 B
Grumpus 60.00 S
Saboteur 59.80 C
Fido 59.00 B
Void 58.80 B
Relic 58.40 C
Zombie 57.40 B
Spiff 57.30 B
Will 57.00 B
Grudge 55.50 B
Tripler 55.30 B
Human 55.00 B
Chosen 54.75 B
Calculator 53.00 B
Guerrilla 53.00 I
Graviton 53.00 C
Reincarnator 52.10 B
Hacker 50.40 B
Trickster 50.00 C
Barbarian 49.00 B
Tick-Tock 49.00 B
Observer 48.90 B
Plant 48.60 I
Symbiote 48.50 I
Hate 47.00 B
Macron 46.00 B
Phantasm 43.86 S
Cudgel 43.50 B
Genius 42.50 I
Changeling 42.30 C
Daredevil 37.80 D
Mirage 37.80 D
Masochist 37.00 B
Sadist 36.10 C
Converter 32.36 S
Sneak 32.36 S
Whirligig 31.09 D
Lightning 28.66 A
Tyrant 27.78 S
Host 27.78 D
Quartermaster 27.78 D
Sloth 27.25 S
Extortionist 26.43 A
Aristocrat 25.78 D
Explorer 25.53 D
Reborn 24.77 A
Voyager 24.74 D
Mouth 24.71 S
Cyborg 24.70 A
Outlaw 24.43 S
Laser 24.43 D
Engineer 23.81 D
Judge 23.81 D
Muckraker 23.36 D
Sapient 22.83 A
Mesmer 22.21 D
Poison 21.12 A
Bulwarks 21.12 S
Vox 21.09 S
General 20.94 A
Joker 20.04 D
Scavenger 19.97 S
Sting 19.58 A
Love 18.95 D
Pirate 18.95 D
Usurper 18.89 D
Alchemist 17.97 D
Diplomat 17.97 D
Wormhole 17.78 S
Coordinator 17.20 S
Porcupine 17.11 S
Worm 16.63 S
Angler 16.63 D
Yin-Yang 16.03 D
Winner 15.24 A
Pygmy 15.05 A
Animal 15.05 A
Sycophant 14.56 S
Patriot 14.48 S
Roach 14.43 S
Gorgon 13.06 A
Lizard 12.21 D
Ace 12.14 D
Horde 11.76 A
Bride 11.13 D
Brute 11.12 S
Dervish 11.12 S
Pickpockets 11.12 D
Reactor 11.12 D
Locust 10.50 I
Crystal 10.16 A
Skeptic 10.16 A
Remote 10.02 A
Arcade 10.02 S
Doppelganger 10.00 D
Bandit 9.16 A
Pentaform 9.14 D
Tourist 8.87 D
Squee 8.15 S
Neighbor 8.15 S
Tide 7.78 S
Schizoid 7.43 A
Chrysalis 7.41 A
Butler 6.25 A
Greenhorn 5.55 D
Swindler 3.36 S
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Don Clarke
United Kingdom
Nantwich
Cheshire
flag msg tools
designer
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Would welcome comments from experienced players on the accuracy of this listing in terms of the relative in-game power of the various aliens.

To this end I've started a new thread led by the full rank order.
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.