Thought I'd share my new obsession - making or repurposing items into custom chaos tokens or "bags". I'm playing the game frequently love to really shake up the tokens in a custom wooden container that feels more thematic than a bag. I became frustrated at the cardboard chaos tokens showing wear quickly so decided to make my own. Here's some examples of the wooden tokens and chaos containers.
(And no, I don't try to pick the good tokens by trying to read them with my fingertips. . Not easy to do and pretty obvious bad behavior that might call down the disfavor of the Old Ones.
Minis from Mansions of Madness = much better for moving characters around than cards imho, and love Othello tokens (half white and half black) for action tokens for the investigators.