Luc Jacobs
Belgium Lichtaart

Treachery: Rotting remains (test willpower 3), for each point you fail take 1 horror. Wendy has 4 willpower. Then I draw the automatic failur failure.
How much horror do I take? I guess none? Since 43 = +1 so no negative value.


Dan Bigmore
England Abingdon Oxon

Iliamel wrote: How much horror do I take? I guess none? Since 43 = +1 so no negative value. 3 horror, since Wendy's total skill value for that test is 0.




It is considered '0' for the purposes of math issues.
And to clarify, if you were somehow able to reduce the value you were testing against to zero then it would still be a failure. It's a failure no matter what but when mathing it out it's a value of zero.


Scott Hill
United Kingdom Cambridge Cambridgeshire

Auto fail = result of zero, regardless of skill value.
So, in this instance you would take 3 Horror.


Luc Jacobs
Belgium Lichtaart

Found it. Thanks!




The auto fail (or card effect) case is clear.
But what if, in the OP example, Wendy draw 6? The final modified skill value would be 46=2: how much horror does she take? To succeed she needs, at worst, a 1 (41)=3 > 33=0 > ok. But with 6 she fails the test by 5 points (23), so I guess she must take five horror tokens.
IIRC, in the RR (p.26, ST.6), there is no mention to reduce to zero a negative modified skill value.
Do I get something wrong?
Thanks!




This has been confirmed by FFG (Matt) and will be in an upcoming FAQ. You do the math for each value separately, if either are below zero then it brings it to zero. Then you compare.
It is in the order of steps for resolving skills in the RR.
It becomes clear with a cross reference of a few pages. You modify the skill value before comparison.
Page 15: Modifiers is key.




The rule is in the Rules Reference, but don't feel bad for not stumbling upon it. It's in the entry titled 'Modifiers', p15.
Essentially, apply modifiers to whatever and if they end up at a negative value, that value becomes zero.
Before you begin the skill check, you will have needed to establish a 'difficulty', the number you will check against. Example: location with a shroud of 1, and you spend one use of flashlight to investigate. The shroud goes to 1, so we treat it as zero. We go in to the skill test with a difficulty:0 check.
In step 5 of the skill test, you take the relevant number on your investigator and apply all the modifiers that were committed, that are active on cards in play, that the chaos bag brought to proceedings. Let's say you end up with a final value of 2. We treat it as a value of zero.
Comparing our modified skill value of zero with the difficulty of zero, we succeed!




Thanks!
Sadly, I went insane for no reason! :)


MC Shudde M'ell
United States Utah

cyberdisc wrote: Thanks! Sadly, I went insane for no reason! :)
Welcome to Arkham



