Recommend
3 
 Thumb up
 Hide
1 Posts

Raven» Forums » Reviews

Subject: Raven: A Cool Twist on David Parlett's Ninety-Nine (Game Review by Chris Wray) rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Chris Wray
United States
Harrisonville
Missouri
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Note: This review originally appeared on The Opinionated Gamers at http://opinionatedgamers.com/2017/02/20/raven-game-review-by...

Designer: Bob Kamp
Publisher: Drive Thru Cards
Players: 2 – 6
Ages: 8 and Up
Time: 30+ Minutes
Times Played: > 5 (on Review Copy Provided by the Designer)



Raven, a trick taking card designed by Bob Kamp and available on Drive Thru Cards, is at first glance vaguely similar to David Parlett’s Ninety Nine. But once you get past the bidding system, this becomes a clever design all its own, complete with specialist cards and a scoring system that ramps up the tension.

I was approached by the designer about doing a review of the game, and given my love of the trick taking genre, I agreed to do so. My group and I have played at several different player counts since, and it has been a hit with us. This is a clever, well-designed trick taking game, and I enthusiastically recommend it. Though it is currently

The Gameplay

Note: The first part of the review focuses on the standard rules for 4-6 players. The 2- and 3-player rules, as well a a short game variant, are described in a separate section below.

Raven is played with 56 suited cards. The four suits — Shields, Swords, Axes, and Waters — have cards ranging from 1 (low) to 14 (high). Additionally, there are four specialists in the game: the Raven (the highest trump); the Wolf (the highest non-trump); the Shaman (a half-step higher than the card it immediately follows); and the Dwarf (the lowest card).





The cards are dealt out evenly, and the game will consist of eight hands, with the highest score at the end of eight hands being the winner. The trump rotates each hand (shields, swords, axes, waters, waters, axes, swords, shields).

Like in Ninety Nine, players bid on how many tricks they will take by using cards from their hand. (Three cards are used in lower player counts; two cards are used with 5-6 players.) The value of the cards doesn’t matter for bidding, only the suit does: a shield bets 0 tricks; a sword, 1 trick; an axe, 2 tricks; and a waters card, 3 tricks.



The player in the lead (i.e. this applies only after the first hand) must play with their bid revealed. The other players play with their bids concealed, and they may bluff about what they’ve bid or the cards they hold.

Play then continues like would happen in a standard trick taking card game:

◙ A player who can follow suit must either (1) follow suit or (2) play a specialist.
◙ A player who cannot follow suit may play any card.
◙ A player may not lead the Shaman. Leading the Raven establishes trump as the suit led.
◙ Leading with a Dwarf allows the player to call for the suit (and the Dwarf is then the lowest card of that suit).
◙ Leading a Wolf lead calls for a non-trump suit, but does not establish which one. The next player must play non-trump. If non-trump is played, it becomes the called-for suit.

Points are awarded for tricks taken (1 point each), plus a bonus if the player’s exact bid is made: 3 points with 6 players; 4 points with 5 players; 5 points with 4 players. The player with the most points at the end of eight hands is the winner.

The Short Game, Plus 2- and 3-Player Rules

The rules also contain a variant for a shorter game and rules for 2-3 players.

In the shorter game, there are only 5 hands, the first four listed above, followed by a “ravenclaw round” in which the only trump is the Raven.

In the 3-player game, four hands are dealt, and the dealer, after examining his or her hand, may swap for the extra hand. Each other player in turn order may swap for the extra hand, which may be a hand that was already swapped. Exact bids are worth 5 points.

In the 2-player game, the 1s, 2s, and 3s are removed, and three hands are dealt, but the third hand may not be swapped. There are no revealed bids. Exact bids are worth 6 points.

My thoughts on the game…

Raven is a great trick taking card game, and we’ve loved our plays. This takes the best part of Ninety Nine — the bidding system — and ramps up the tension through use of four Tichu-esque specialist cards and a more equitable scoring system. To me, Raven is a clever design that stands out in a crowded genre.

Raven presents tough choices before the hand is even played: you’re often forced to give up good cards to get the bid you want. And from there, the game gets even more interesting: each trick subtly reveals the bets made by other players.

The specialist cards really make the game. Not only do they factor into how many tricks you can expect to take, they also often force the game from entering “autoplay mode” (my phrase for trick taking games in which the next card to play is obvious). The specialists ramp up the tension, the very element that makes for a good trick taking game.

The scoring system works exceptionally well, and in many ways it distinguishes Raven from mediocre trick taking games. Some trick taking games put too much of a premium on making bid, and Raven strikes a nice balance between points for taking tricks and points for making bid. Games tend to be close: we saw no instances of one player running away wildly with the lead.

Gameplay is typically fast-paced. We prefer the short variant, which comes in between 15 and 20 minutes. Regardless of which version is played, teaching time is short too: I can explain this game to those familiar with trick takers in less than two or three minutes.

I had never played with cards from Drive Thru Cards before, and the print quality and card quality was nice. The artwork on the specialist cards was attractive, and the game came with three clever player aids: one to remember the trump suit based on the round; one to help players remember the bid values of the suits (shown above); and one to remember the setup for each player count.

Overall, I was really impressed by Raven. This took the bidding system I loved in Ninety Nine, plus the specialist cards I love in Tichu, and mashed them together with an improved scoring system that equally rewards capturing tricks and meeting your bid. I play a lot of trick taking games, and this is one of my favorite ones of recent years.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.