Recommend
16 
 Thumb up
 Hide
2 Posts

Rummikub» Forums » Reviews

Subject: Revisiting the Spiel des Jahres Winners: Rummikub rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Chris Wray
United States
Harrisonville
Missouri
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Designer: Ephraim Hertzano
Publisher: Multiple
Players: 2 – 4
Ages: 8 and Up
Time: 60 Minutes
Times Played: >50



Series Note

This is the second entry in a 37-part series reviewing each of the Spiel des Jahres winners. This series originally appeared on The Opinionated Gamesr in 2015. I originally called the series "SdJ Revisited" and used the English names of the games, but the OG changed the title and went with German names. I'm updating these over the next few days and posting them here on BGG. If you have anything to add to the game history, I'd love to see your comments below. Rummikub is a particularly challenging history, since some of the events described below conflict among various sources.

Game History

Rummikub box Ephraim Hertzano and his wife, Hanna, loved the card game rummy, but playing cards were outlawed when they lived in Romania in the 1930s and 40s. Hertzano, a toothbrush manufacturer, dreamed up a legal way to play the game he loved, replacing cards with elongated plastic tiles that would sit in wooden racks. But as Ephraim knew from his line of work, plastics were rare and expensive in Romania.

Hertazno soon discovered a solution: recycling plastic from airplane canopies. Ephraim made the first Rummikub set by hand. The game was popular with friends of the family, and word began to spread. Soon store owners started requesting copies of the game to sell. The Hertzanos emigrated to Israel in either the late 1940s or early 1950s, and they introduced the game to their new homeland. Ephraim still made the sets by hand, cutting and painting the tiles in a workshop in his back yard. He made a few sets each week, and he sold a few dozen sets in his first year in Israel, often on a door-to-door or consignment basis. To market the sets, the Hertzanos reportedly invited store owners to come play the game in their home.

Production continued to grow, and the game became a pastime in Israel. But Ephraim had bigger dreams, visions of exporting the game on a mass scale. He soon began trying to sell the game to Americans in Israel. U.S. late night comedian Don Rickles visited the country, and at some point during the visit, his wife purchased a copy of the game. (The Hertzano family told me they have “no idea” where in Israel Mrs. Rickles purchased the game.) The Rickles family became obsessed, and Don discussed the game on television. The Hertzanos became flooded with requests for Rummikub.

The rest is history. Rummikub became the bestselling game in the United States in 1977, and it was introduced to Germany that year. The jury awarded Rummikub the SdJ in 1980, describing the game as a combination of rummy, mahjong, and dominoes.

Though Ephraim passed away in 1987, the company he founded – Lemada Light Industries Ltd – continues to produce Rummikub today. The Hertzano children are heavily involved in the company. More than four million games are produced annually by more than 120 employees at a factory in Israel. Rummikub has reportedly sold more than 50 million copies, almost as many copies as the rest of the SdJ winners combined.

The Gameplay


A Rummikub set contains 104 numbered tiles and two jokers. The numbered tiles come in four colors (typically red, orange, blue, and black), with two sets of each color ranging from one to thirteen. Several variations of the game exist, but the explanation below is for the most common variant, the “Sabra” version. Each player draws a tile, and the player receiving the highest tile starts. Every player then receives thirteen additional tiles, for a total initial hand of fourteen.

To enter the game, a player must make an “initial meld” by laying tiles totaling 50 points or more onto the table (30 points in newer editions). Jokers take the value of the number they replace. Tiles can only be placed in one of two forms: a “run” of three or more sequential numbers all of the same color, or a “group” of three or more tiles of the same number but different colors. A player may not use other players’ tiles to make their initial meld. If a player is unable to make an initial meld, he or she draws a tile.



Once a player is in the game, on each subsequent turn he or she must either (1) place one or more tiles from his or her rack, or (2) draw a tile into his or her rack. The player may manipulate any and all runs and sets on the table in order to get tiles onto the table. For example, a player could add a tile to the end of a run, split a single run into multiple runs, substitute a joker, split runs into groups, or split groups into runs. At the end of each turn, all sets on the table must be valid runs or groups, or the table is returned to its initial form and the player draws a penalty of one to three tiles (depending on the variant).

The Sabra variant calls for a two-minute time limit on turns. The first player to rid their hand of tiles wins, although some variants use multiple games combined with a scoring mechanism.

Does it stand the test of time?


Rummikub is a classic, the sort of game that is a favorite of grandparents everywhere, and it is easy to see why. The game can be learned quickly, with a typical rules explanation taking less than two minutes, yet there are elements of strategy. Rearranging the entire table to get two or three challenging tiles into play is an immensely satisfying – if occasionally brain burning – experience.

The game can be tense, especially as players’ hands dwindle in size. The component quality is solid, and it is easy to see how the use of tiles – as opposed to cards – has contributed to the game’s success. Rummikub can actually be played with two decks of standard playing cards, but the tiles take up less space, are easier to manipulate on the table, and are more convenient to manage in hand.

Despite these joys, I rarely pull Rummikub off the shelf. The game has obvious appeal to fans of traditional card games, but in my opinion, the appeal to board gamers is minimal. Player interaction is low, randomness can be high (especially in the two player game), and the game goes a bit long for what it is. Despite the simplicity of the rules, Rummikub can be a brain burner. Most of all, I hate the “initial meld” requirement: by random chance, I’ve found myself simply drawing a tile on each of my turns for half the length of the game, while other players gleefully arrange and rearrange the table.

The game necessarily invites “analysis paralysis.” This can be fixed by using a timer (a two-minute time limit is suggested in the Sabra variant), but even then, there can be significant time between turns, especially in a four-player game. While I suppose the down time ought to be be used for planning, such an effort can be futile, as you never know how other players will rearrange the runs and groups.

Despite these criticisms, Rummikub has a permanent spot in my collection. I have fond memories of playing the game with my grandparents. I might have outgrown Rummikub, but it still occasionally gets played. I’m by no means adverse to playing it: it just isn’t the sort of game I’ll pull of the shelf that often.

Would Rummikub win the SdJ today? I highly doubt it. Recent SdJ juries put a premium on originality, and Rummikub wasn’t that original when it won the award in 1980. Though the SdJ jury said it isn’t just another rummy variant, it really is just basically a re-imagining of the card game rummy using mahjong tiles or dominoes. Additionally, I suspect recent SdJ juries would dislike the “initial meld” requirement every bit as much as I do.
17 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Nick Van Dam
United States
Appleton City
Missouri
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
While I agree with much of what you have written in terms of critique, I think it is a bit unfair to say that Rummikub was unoriginal in 1980 when it won the SdJ when you had already stated the game had been around since the 30s or 40s.
Granted it does incorporate some of the mechanics of popularized card games, but then again so do the majority of games including several SdJ winners. It takes mechanics and designs from existing games and recombines and re-imagines them creating a fun game. Given the Qwirkle won the SdJ in 2011 I suspect a game similar to Rummikub continues to have a chance at going home with the prize.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.