Recommend
28 
 Thumb up
 Hide
6 Posts

Dragon Castle» Forums » Reviews

Subject: This is not Mahjong, This is just a Tribute rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Brandon Kempf
United States
Jefferson City
MO
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb


Disclaimer

The KneeJerk Review series of reviews is a look at games after only a play or two, with hopes of giving an overview of the game play and then some thoughts. Yes, thoughts, not final verdicts, not definites, just general thoughts about the game while it is fresh in my head. Feel free to yell at me or tell me I am an idiot, but be aware and know that these thoughts are subject to change after more plays and are just initial Knee Jerk thoughts. 


Dragon Castle

Designed by Hjalmar Hach, Luca Ricci, Lorenzo Silva

Art by Cinyee Chiu

Published by Horrible Games


In what was kind of a surprise to me, this ended up being the game that I specifically asked friend Chris Wray to bring back from Essen for me this year. Yes, I know, it's not even on my Essen Spiel 2017 Hype List but the more I read about the game and the more I watched the Spiel 2017 news, I kind of realized, this may be the game that takes the longest to get to the North American market via a North American publisher, this being CMON I believe. So I told Chris to forget Otys, it'll probably be here in a couple weeks, forget Altiplano, it had some production issues I had heard, and go ahead and bring home Dragon Castle. 



Dragon Castle clearly takes inspiration from the game Mahjong, but more closely, the Mahjong Solitaire that a lot of us grew up playing on our Windows based computers. Yes, I know, it's not really Mahjong but it is inspired by it. Production wise, this one is fantastic, if only for those nice tiles. They are small but yet they have some heft, I think Chris may have said that this was truly the heaviest game he carried around Essen, and he carried quite a bit. The art is beautiful and while there was some art on the insert in the box, it got tossed pretty quickly as it was really more of just a lightweight cardboard divider than an insert. I think that because this was purchased at Spiel, it came with a nice custom drawstring bag and a rubber playmat for the dragon castle, as those were outside the box, so I assume they were promos for buying directly from Horrible Games at Spiel, so what most people will play with eventually will be some Central boards made of the same material as the player board for the player's castles. 



So, in Dragon Castle, the players are trying to build their own castles in their new realms and try to get out of the shadow of the declining Dragon Castle. You do this by taking 1 of 3 actions on your turn. You can take 2 identical tiles from the Dragon Castle, to do this, one of the tiles has to come from the top level of the castle and has to have at least one long edge free, the second tile can come from anywhere else on the castle as long as it also has, one long edge free. Or, you can take on tile from the top level of the Dragon Castle, and take a Shrine from the general supply and add it to your supply. Or lastly, you can simply discard an available tile from the top level of the Dragon Castle and gain 1 victory point. 



After taking one of those three actions, the player is then going to place any tiles that he kept, ie did not discard, on their player board to begin building their castle. You can place the tiles anywhere on the board, adjacency is not required, the only rules are, you cannot build on top of a tile in your personal Castle that is face up and you cannot build on top of a tile that already has a Shrine on it. Why are you doing this? Well to gain points of course. You see, when you build tiles of the same matching colors(types) together and you have at least four adjacent to each other, you have to consolidate those tiles. This means you flip them over. You will score points based on how many you flipped and then after that you may also add 1 or 2 Shrines to that Consolidated group, this all depends on the type of tiles flipped. The Faction tiles: Yellow(Merchants), Green(Farmers) & Red(Soldiers) will allow you to build 1 Shrine, while the Special tiles: Green(Seasons), Black(Winds) & Purple(Dragons) allow you to build 2 Shrines, and the Dragons will also give you a one victory point bonus as a well. At the end of the game, these Shrines will score you victory points based on how tall they are, ie if they are one tile high, you get one point, 2 gets you 2 points and 3 gets you 3 points. Anything higher is just 3 points. 

In the box, there are also some special cards. The Dragon Cards and the Spirit Cards do a couple different things. At the beginning of the game you will randomly draw one of each, and these will be in affect during the game. The Dragons will score you bonus points at the end of the game based on some kind of building requirement, and the Spirit Cards are kind of rule breakers that you may activate once per turn by discarding a face up tile from your castle, or one Shrine from your personal supply. 

Once there are only tiles left on the very bottom level of the Dragon Castle, players then may take a different action instead of the previous three actions, they may Summon the Dragon. You do this by simply taking the right most Dragon Token that is on the Countdown Track, end of the game, these tokens are worth two points. When the Dragon Token is taken and under it is revealed the exclamation mark, the game will end after the player to the right of the start player takes a turn that round. Most points wins the game!

So once again, a reminder that this is a Kneejerk Review, meaning I have played Dragon Castle only a time or two. 




This was fun, with just enough thinking involved to make you feel like you are doing a bit of work. There is not any player interaction, much to my chagrin, other than possibly discarding tiles that you know others may need or taking one just to keep someone else from getting it, and I can definitely see that becoming more of a thing to do later in the game when you are on that bottom level of the Dragon Castle and your neighbors are trying to complete that set to put in a couple more Shrines. But other than that, you are playing your own board, and you are playing what is available to you on your turn. 

My youngest daughter(7) played with us the first game and while she got it. she didn't want to finish the game when it got down to it, the first game just took a bit too long for her attention span at 7 years old. Now, that isn't saying that this is a long game, it wasn't, if we had sat and played straight through instead of making beverages, popping popcorn or other things, this is probably a 30-45 minute game, just as marked on the box and I think most kids would be able to sit through that and enjoy it. 

I would be remiss if I didn't say, that this really is inspired by Mahjong, much in the same way that movies are often inspired by real events, or by the books that preceded them, but I just don't think there is any getting away from that comparison. When someone sees this setup, their immediate response is going to be, is this like Mahjong, and hopefully the fact that it really isn't, doesn't hinder their enjoyment of this fun tile placement game that has hints of set collection in the Consolidation and Castle building. 

The theme is ultimately just painted on there to give you a reason to enjoy the art in the game. I can see that you are bringing in the Farmers, or the Soldiers from the Dragon Castle to build your own realm, but really, you are collecting like colored tiles to build with in order to collect points, and that's okay, we like our flavoring of games and this can in theory help teach the game, although it's really simple. 

I have zero idea on when or if CMON is really going to bring this to the North American market, but I have to think that they would after the success of Potion Explosion, from the same publishing team and also having name recognition in the designer category as Hach recently brought us the wonderful, similarly abstract, Photosynthesis. So be on the lookout, I think this one has some potential, and I'll try to keep this review up to date or I will write a bit more about Dragon Castle after a few more plays. 
28 
 Thumb up
0.02
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Steve Blackwell
United Kingdom
Saltdean
East Sussex
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I like the idea of this but I think I is a shame they didn’t go for the full MahJong set of tiles, even if not using all for Dragon Castle. Not sure how many pieces are missing or how much extra that would cost.

Then you’d get two games for the price of one! Something for players to move on to once tired of this original game. Having said that, the market for this game is prob not the same for the traditional game.

I would love to play this even so.

M B
8 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Jeff M
United States
Lafayette
California
flag msg tools
mb
"This is not Mahjong, This is just a Tribute"

Good. If I wanted to play Mahjong I would have purchased a Mahjong set.
Not sure how it is a "just a tribute" to Mahjong. Other than the use of Mahjong style tiles for playing pieces and set collection as a game mechanic.....the way tiles are played, scoring, game play decisions and use of a spacial element in game play are all different.
4 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Brandon Kempf
United States
Jefferson City
MO
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
It certainly is different than Mahjong, and I say as much in the preview, but you can't look at the game and not think Mahjong. And also, I imagine the designers got part of the inspiration from Mahjong as well.

Plus, the title was just a good way for me to get everyone to listen to some Tenacious D.



Lowden025 wrote:
"This is not Mahjong, This is just a Tribute"

Good. If I wanted to play Mahjong I would have purchased a Mahjong set.
Not sure how it is a "just a tribute" to Mahjong. Other than the use of Mahjong style tiles for playing pieces and set collection as a game mechanic.....the way tiles are played, scoring, game play decisions and use of a spacial element in game play are all different.
14 
 Thumb up
1.00
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Bill Kunes
United States
Cincinnati
Ohio
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Nice review, Brandon. This one is on my radar, or Watch List. I could see my wife and I really enjoying this in the mornings over coffee.

meeple Keep playing...
 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
David "Davy" Ashleydale
United States
Oakland
California
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Lowden025 wrote:
"This is not Mahjong, This is just a Tribute"

Good. If I wanted to play Mahjong I would have purchased a Mahjong set.
Not sure how it is a "just a tribute" to Mahjong. Other than the use of Mahjong style tiles for playing pieces and set collection as a game mechanic.....the way tiles are played, scoring, game play decisions and use of a spacial element in game play are all different.


Sometimes when people say "Mahjong", they mean the solitaire game where you mix up all the tiles, stack them face up in a certain pattern and then remove tiles in pairs to see if you can successfully remove them all. This game has that same mechanic, although it adds more rules to make it a multi-player game with some added features.

Brandon's review is not referring to the actual game of "Mahjong" where players sit around a table drawing and discarding tiles until someone goes out with a complete set.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.