Daniel Thurot
United States
Salt Lake City
Utah
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb

The Unbearable Smartness of Pericles

Not to be too hysterical about it, but the Peloponnesian Wars were sort of a big deal. By the time the clash between Athens and Sparta grew to encompass Sicily and much of the middle and eastern Mediterranean, and certainly once they drew in the Persian Empire, they practically qualified as an antique World War. The outcome would cut short the golden age of Greece and pave the way for those perky Macedonians to solidify into the force that would Hellenize much of the known world.

It was Very Serious Business, is what I’m saying, brimming with intrigue, oration, and big stonkin’ battles on both land and sea. And in order to capture the freewheeling nature of the conflict, Mark Herman’s sandbox wargame Pericles just might be one of the maddest — and most maddening — things I’ve ever Greek-wrestled with.

Picture this. Athens is on the cusp of empire. They’ve got unfettered access to the Aegean Sea, a professional navy, and a bunch of pals called the Delian League. Mobility and expansion are their game to lose, and perhaps the only problem is that they’re tethered to their home base in Attica and have a serious food shortage. Fortunately, their aforementioned mobility and sea power will hopefully secure them enough grain abroad to keep everything running.

Just a short distance away even by ancient standards sits Sparta. Renowned for their prowess in combat, they’ve got aspirations of their own, and have formed their own network of allegiances and upstarts simmering with resentment for the too-cool Athenians. They’re tough, almost unbeatable in straight combat, but largely trapped in place by Athens’ superior navy and the physical geography of the Peloponnese.

Which is to say, the situation is deeply asymmetrical. It’s mobility versus mettle, reach versus a strong central force. And what you do with it is entirely up to you.

It would be easy to explain Pericles in terms of its goals, except Pericles has a tendency of not playing out the way you were hoping. Athens can win if they secure foreign granaries and beat up Sparta enough to shame them among the other city-states of Greece, and Sparta is going to look pretty dang fine if they subjugate the golden city of Athens itself or cut them off from a source of food entirely. Instead, it’s almost guaranteed that victory will be won by a hundred small triumphs — a base here, a nettling military victory there — until at last your dominance is assured and all those neutral cities flock to your side.

War in Pericles is deeply complex for a few reasons, two foremost among them. The first is the way the game handles your military orders. Rather than simply passing between Sparta and Athens, with armies and navies marching and sailing and mustering back and forth, each war phase begins with orders being placed out among the various theaters of the Aegean. Tokens are played face-down, and, in a huge twist that alters everything it touches, may be stacked one atop the other, similar to the way they were piled in Starcraft or Forbidden Stars. When it comes time to resolve those stacks, players alternate between themselves to pick up one of their orders and resolve it.

Right away, this presses each placed token between the Scylla of your opponent’s orders and the Charybdis of correctly measuring your own. It’s possible, for instance, to invade a contested theater, sweep away your opponent in glorious battle, undertake diplomacy to persuade the local city-states to join your league, then naturalize them into joining your side entirely. Note that I said it was possible, not likely. Doing so would require not only placing a whole stack of orders in the right sequence, but also avoiding any disruptions thrown down by your enemy. In a system where the best-laid plans can be terminally delayed by the careful placement of an otherwise-worthless rumor token, it’s best to hope for success but plan for setbacks, failures, and frustrations.

The other thing muddying the Aegean waters is that the orders themselves are carefully suited to Pericles’ status as a sandbox game, though that also means there are some hurdles to vault before they become second nature. Diplomatic, League, and Military orders each boast multiple uses. Diplomacy alone can be used to sway opposing city-states to your cause or riddle them with damaging treachery markers, court a neutral city, or purge opposing treachery from your midst. None of these are all that difficult on their own, but when you consider that the game’s five orders multiply into over a dozen possible moves, it’s easy to become overwhelmed.

Now that I’ve done Pericles a disservice by pitching it as a terrifically complicated take on ancient war, it’s only going to get worse because I’ve left out the most infuriating part — though it just so happens to also be the most interesting part.

By focusing on only the war between Sparta and Athens, Pericles might sound like a two-player outing. But it isn’t. Rather, it’s a four-player game and mechanical sequel to Mark Herman’s own Churchill.

For those who aren’t in the know, Churchill tossed you into the uncomfortable alliance between Churchill, Stalin, and Roosevelt. It looked like a wargame in many respects, complete with tank blocks and grand theater maps of Europe and the Pacific, and looked like a cooperative wargame to boot. But while it was true that the Big Three were working together to topple Germany and Japan, Churchill was actually a bitterly competitive affair, complete with temporary factional alliances, ongoing grudges, and real-world above-the-table bickering. In fact, World War 2 quickly faded into a sort of necessary background noise to the conference room intrigue of one-upping your own allies to shape the world once the bullets stopped flying. It was remarkable.

Pericles takes that concept and draws it outward. Where Churchill’s war sometimes came across as perfunctory — you had to be deeply unlucky or deeply stupid to not eventually roll into Berlin and Tokyo — Pericles divides its four players onto teams, then further splits them into feuding political factions. Two of you will helm the Aristocrats and Demagogues of Athens, while the others don the crimson robes and ripped abdominal muscles of the Eurypontid and Agiad kings of Sparta. Before the curtains even rise on the war phase, your order tokens must be earned through argumentation and played cards, an ongoing tug-of-war to determine which political faction will shine in victory while the other sulks in the shadows. And if that wasn’t difficult enough, there are plenty of ancillary issues to debate. Perhaps you’ll want to ostracize an opposing leader to win over your citizenry, or host the games to look sexy while boosting recruitment, or collaborate with your enemy to force a temporary peace and shame your political rival as a warmonger.

It’s hard to overstate how completely this permeates the design of Pericles. Far from feeling bifurcated into two distinct halves, every single order won during the assembly translates into opportunities in wartime, where they not only represent a push against your enemy city-state but also a gain in honor for your faction. You’re fighting both on the battlegrounds and at home, and neither conflict is any less bitter for the presence of the other.

This is brilliant stuff, though it also bears the unfortunate side-effect of making Pericles quite overwhelming to learn. Both the war effort and home intrigues are rife with their own subtleties, and often echo back on one another. It’s a breathtaking design in many ways, and witnessing it in action grazes the complexities of the conflict it seeks to simulate.

But hoplite, it is hard.

The thing is, nearly all of Pericles’ obtuseness is intentional. Its infuriating war-making captures the density of its subject matter, revealing how even the tiniest of disruptions might bring an entire military expedition to its knees. And by dabbling in politics it illuminates the fact that all those soldiers and ships and envoys and schemes and manipulated auguries came from somewhere, and almost certainly came at someone’s expense. The only thing as treacherous as the churning waters beneath a trireme’s oars were the halls where men debated where to send them for their own gain.

Pericles is not necessarily any fun, at least not until you’ve put in the work. Even then it can be frustrating, reveling in the possibility of political gridlock, wasted orders, and horrific setbacks. It’s likely to infuriate you at every turn.

It’s also ambitious, devious, and unbearably smart. Pulling off a sequence of orders that cripples the enemy city-state is a fine thing; doing so when it shames your ally and makes you look like a hero of the people is a work of art. The result is one of the most frustrating and rewarding sandbox wargames ever crafted.




This review was originally published at Space-Biff!, so if you like what you see, please head over there for more. https://spacebiff.com/2017/09/02/pericles/

Also, I suppose I ought to plug my Geeklist of reviews: https://boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/169963/space-biff-histori...
  • [+] Dice rolls
Marius van der Merwe
United States
St. George
Utah
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
As always, a great review. I am jealous that you have a playgroup of at least 3 others who were willing to go the distance with you on this one. I have great friends to play board games with, but Pericles may be a bit too much, even for them. In the meantime, I am carefully raising a young gamer (8 years old at the moment) to play complex games with me in the future. Just need to find two more!
4 
 Thumb up
0.05
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Daniel Thurot
United States
Salt Lake City
Utah
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Sciurus wrote:
As always, a great review. I am jealous that you have a playgroup of at least 3 others who were willing to go the distance with you on this one. I have great friends to play board games with, but Pericles may be a bit too much, even for them. In the meantime, I am carefully raising a young gamer (8 years old at the moment) to play complex games with me in the future. Just need to find two more!

That's the danger of this game's complexity, unfortunately. A number of my COIN buddies found it just beyond their threshold. I do have some friends willing to play it, but the pickings are slimmer than I'm accustomed to.

And best of luck with your gamer-in-training! I introduced my almost-four-year-old to Mario Kart 8 yesterday. The intensity of her stare as she "drove" the cars was a delight.
6 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Aaron Cinzori
United States
Holland
Michigan
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
I didn't find the game mechanically complex. The included player aid does a great job of letting you know what each action does. The internecine cardplay is straightforward. The hard bit is figuring out how to play well. But that's a good thing; that's why we play.
6 
 Thumb up
1.00
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
United States
Ladson
South Carolina
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Just curious--when you were learning the game did you go through all the training scenarios?
2 
 Thumb up
0.05
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Daniel Thurot
United States
Salt Lake City
Utah
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Scottgun wrote:
Just curious--when you were learning the game did you go through all the training scenarios?

Most of them, yes. I'd have to check my rulebook at home, but I know I did at least a battle scenario, a forum one, and the two-round short war.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Mark Herman
United States
New York
Unspecified
flag msg tools
designer
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
The Innocent wrote:
Sciurus wrote:
As always, a great review. I am jealous that you have a playgroup of at least 3 others who were willing to go the distance with you on this one. I have great friends to play board games with, but Pericles may be a bit too much, even for them. In the meantime, I am carefully raising a young gamer (8 years old at the moment) to play complex games with me in the future. Just need to find two more!

That's the danger of this game's complexity, unfortunately. A number of my COIN buddies found it just beyond their threshold. I do have some friends willing to play it, but the pickings are slimmer than I'm accustomed to.

And best of luck with your gamer-in-training! I introduced my almost-four-year-old to Mario Kart 8 yesterday. The intensity of her stare as she "drove" the cars was a delight.


I appreciate that most of my designs are not for everyone, but Pericles is the story I wanted to tell and I did it within a complexity budget based on what I could fit on the playaid, no more no less. If someone feels its too much there are plenty of other choices.

That said, I really enjoyed your thoughtful review.

Mark
28 
 Thumb up
0.05
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Roger Hobden
Canada
Montreal
Quebec
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Very nice review !

Helps me decide if I want to buy this game or not.

4 
 Thumb up
0.05
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
BrentS
Australia
Sydney
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
This is a good and insightful review, thank you.

I do have to say, though, that there is a narrative building around the game (partly generated by Marco's popular reviews), that it has a complexity that is a major roadblock to getting four players up to speed to play it properly. There is definitely some basis to this but I think it's overstated. We're talking about wargamers. The rules themselves aren't that complex at all, it's applying them to effective game play that isn't obvious. I've done a fair bit of solo play and now four player and the switch has flicked, like looking at one of those 3D pictures. It reminds me very much of Napoleons Triumph in this respect. I think the game is brilliant (I don't say this lightly) and utterly engaging and will be appreciated as a classic in years to come. From the front end it might look too difficult to master but with time I expect an increasing groundswell of familiarity and experience with the game in the wargaming community, as more players tackle the 3D and see the Mona Lisa behind the Jackson Pollock, and are able to transmit that experience and vision to others.

Brent
11 
 Thumb up
1.00
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Brian Nygaard
United States
Maryland
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I bought Pericles as my first war game. I haven't gotten it to the table yet, but I don't see the complexity as that big of a barrier. I had to read the rules several times, and plan to do a couple of solitaire games before I start teaching it.

For my group, the sandbox aspect is the barrier. Many in my group freeze up when there isn't a clear path forward. This is where I found Mark's article reassuring. Until the strategy of the game becomes less opaque, we can follow the ai matrix.

I'm happy to have this in my collection. The potential for amazing game experiences seems so high, with the us vs them / me vs you dynamic, and the hidden stacks of for issues.
5 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Jonathan F
United States
Corpus Christi
Texas
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Hopelesst wrote:
I bought Pericles as my first war game. I haven't gotten it to the table yet, but I don't see the complexity as that big of a barrier. I had to read the rules several times, and plan to do a couple of solitaire games before I start teaching it.

For my group, the sandbox aspect is the barrier. Many in my group freeze up when there isn't a clear path forward. This is where I found Mark's article reassuring. Until the strategy of the game becomes less opaque, we can follow the ai matrix.

I'm happy to have this in my collection. The potential for amazing game experiences seems so high, with the us vs them / me vs you dynamic, and the hidden stacks of for issues.

Your first war game?!?! My hat is off to you sir. I started with Washington's War (also Mark Herman) which was just the right size for a newbie to the CDG/true wargame genre and then went straight to FtP which proved to be too much until I found VASSAL and a person on BGG willing to help me play through a learning game or two.

This one is on my shortlist, but I have a feeling it will be the most complex Mark H design I own except maybe Empire of the Sun (also glaring at me from its shrink wrap for not daring to try to learn it yet).
3 
 Thumb up
0.05
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.