Life is not a game - games are life.
now I just need to find a place for these old cards since I can't bring myself to toss em.
I always save these "extra" cards to use as bookmarks. I can't bear to throw redundant/replaced cards away either and my wife is an avid reader.
Besides, that's a particularly thematic use for them in this case.
[To clarify, I DO still have the old wilds and fame cards in my box sleeved (as I don't think these have necessarily been made redundant with the expansion). I was just sharing what I do with replaced cards in general.]