GeekGold Bonus for All Supporters at year's end: 1000!
13 Days Left
GWX Dev Team
The following question on Combat Results is over at ConSimWorld:
In the example, what is the fate of the defending 3-5-3 INF XXX? Must it retreat, too?
Answer: The 3-5-3 INF XXX does not retreat.
If the same defending stack is attacked as a whole and receives the ND result, is the stack forced to retreat or not ?
In the 13.73 example, the attacker did attack the defending stack as a whole (just one attack).
The defender chose to have the 3-3-3 artillery unit defend together with the 4-6-4 INF XXX [as one unit - ed.] (per Rule 13.62). The ND combat result required the defender to lose 6 defense factors. The defender chose to eliminate the 4-6-4 INF XXX. Since the 3-3-3 artillery unit was defending together with the 4-6-4, it is retreated and demoralized. The 3-5-3 INF XXX was not defending together with the 4-6-4; so, it does not retreat.
Generally on ND results, no units retreat. This is a special case resulting from Rule 13.62. If the defender had not chosen to have the artillery unit defend together with the 4-6-4 [as one unit per §13.62- ed.], then it would not have had to retreat. But then the attacker could have attacked the artillery unit separately at high odds and probably eliminated it.