I played a four-player game of Highlander earlier today, and a number of draws occurred, and we wanted to check we got the principles right.To confirm your principles(s) directly:
In each of these scenarios, 3+ immortals are duelling and the Behead fate card is the only one left to draw.
Scenario 1: three immortals roll 5, 5, 2. As there's a tie for highest roll, neither draws the fate card and the lowest roller isn't beheaded.
Scenario 2: four immortals roll 5, 5, 2, 2. Again, the highest rolls tie, neither draws the fate card and the two low rollers aren't be beheaded.
Scenario 3: three immortals roll 5, 2, 2. As there's a clear highest roller, that immortal draws the Behead card and kills both low rollers simultaneously.
Are all of these correct?
Assuming all players have used their quickening tokens and/or passed.
This occurs before the effect of the roll has been determined.(p. 9 of rulebook "Using Quickening Tokens").
Scenario 1: Correct! There is a tie at the top, the effect does not occur.
Scenario 2: Correct! There is a tie at the top, same as in scenario 1, no effect occurs. The fact that there is also a tie for lowest does not matter in this regard. The tie at the highest number takes precedence.
Scenario 3: Correct! The tie occurs at the lowest number rolled. The player who rolled highest draws the behead card and the effect happens to both players who rolled lowest.
This is on p.9 of the rulebook under "Rolling higher or lower" (at the top of the page).
"If two or more immortals roll highest(in the event of a tie), the effect does not occur. If two or more immortals roll lowest, the effect does occur to all immortals that rolled lowest."
Hope this helps!
In the end, there can be only one!