Poll: Which are the most favourite Scenarios? | Gloomhaven

Tolis Alex

Poll
I figured there was no information about which scenarios are the most favourite ones, so I created this poll to find out. You can pick any scenario that you loved, that you had great fun playing it or that you would easily name 'one of the best gloom-scenarios' for any reason!

Which Scenarios are your most favourite (for any reason)? Pick as many as you want

	1
	2
	3
	4
	5
	6
	7
	8
	9
	10
	11
	12
	13
	14
	15
	16
	17
	18
	19
	20
	21
	22
	23
	24
	25
	26
	27
	28
	29
	30
	31
	32
	33
	34
	35
	36
	37
	38
	39
	40
	41
	42
	43
	44
	45
	46
	47
	48
	49
	50
	51
	52
	53
	54
	55
	56
	57
	58
	59
	60
	61
	62
	63
	64
	65
	66
	67
	68
	69
	70
	71
	72
	73
	74
	75
	76
	77
	78
	79
	80
	81
	82
	83
	84
	85
	86
	87
	88
	89
	90
	91
	92
	93
	94
	95

34 answers

Poll created by tolhs

[+] Dice rolls

Gerry Smit

(GerryRailBaron)

Canada
Toronto
Ontario

+1 for Brute Solo Adventure

[+] Dice rolls

Jerold Wallis

(jerold_wallis)

Missouri

This poll will be heavily biased due to sampling error- for example many more people have done #4 than #64, so you will end up with more votes for #4.

You would get more meaningful results by asking people to rate each one they did on a 0-4 scale, where 2 is average and 4 is great, and zero is much less fun than most.

But since it is just a casual inquiry, whatever is fine. Have fun with it.

Last edited Thu Feb 14, 2019 3:56 pm (Total Number of Edits: 3)
Posted Thu Feb 14, 2019 1:26 pm
- QuickReply
- QuickQuote
- Reply
- Quote

[+] Dice rolls

Stéphane B

(Microsillon)

Gatineau
Québec

I haven't played in quite a while (we finished it last year), but I remember scenario 27 especially.. very tough, but I liked the 'protect at all costs' theme.

[+] Dice rolls

Tolis Alex

(tolhs)

jerold_wallis wrote:

This poll will be hesvily biased be sampling error- for example many more people have done #4 than #64, so you will end up with more votes for # 4.

You would get more meaningful results by asking people to rate each one they did on a 0-4 scale, where 2 is average and 4 is great, and zero is much less fun than most.

But since it is just a casual inquiry, whatever is fine. Have fun with it.

Yes i thought about that, but I thing it would be more difficult for someone to rate for example 50 or 60 scenarios.
Also it would be very hard to remember how you felt for each of these 50 or 60 scenarios in order to rate them accordingly.

On the other hand it would be easier to come and vote for a scenario that made you a very good impression and you remember you had great fun with it 6 months ago.

I think I prefer to know which scenarios stuck in people's minds and stand out, rather than have some not-so-accurate ratings for all scenarios. (Even if the result is biased to the early scenarios)

But of course if someone will create a poll similar to your suggestion I'll be glad to try and vote as accurate as possible

[+] Dice rolls

Darren Nakamura

(Dexter345)

United States
Columbus
Mississippi

http://www.destructoid.com/author.phtml?a=1364

Darren@destructoid.com

After going through the list and putting in my votes, I can say that I enjoyed the heck out of a lot of the retirement quests. I almost wish every retirement had quests associated with them. So much more climactic than just "Oh, I'm done, goodbye."

[+] Dice rolls

Kevin Allenberg

(Uninvited Guest)

tolhs wrote:

jerold_wallis wrote:

This poll will be hesvily biased be sampling error- for example many more people have done #4 than #64, so you will end up with more votes for # 4.

You would get more meaningful results by asking people to rate each one they did on a 0-4 scale, where 2 is average and 4 is great, and zero is much less fun than most.

But since it is just a casual inquiry, whatever is fine. Have fun with it.

Yes i thought about that, but I thing it would be more difficult for someone to rate for example 50 or 60 scenarios.
Also it would be very hard to remember how you felt for each of these 50 or 60 scenarios in order to rate them accordingly.

On the other hand it would be easier to come and vote for a scenario that made you a very good impression and you remember you had great fun with it 6 months ago.

I think I prefer to know which scenarios stuck in people's minds and stand out, rather than have some not-so-accurate ratings for all scenarios. (Even if the result is biased to the early scenarios)

But of course if someone will create a poll similar to your suggestion I'll be glad to try and vote as accurate as possible

May I present a counter-counter-proposal that I think will satisfy both parties?

Instead of rating on a 0-4 scale, one could instead label the radio buttons. For example:

"Haven't attempted/Don't remember"
"Loved it"
"Neutral"
"Hated it"

Just a thought.

Back to topic: not a whole lot of scenarios stick out to me. The first boss scenario does just because of how it introduced mechanics, and Scenario 72 because of the challenge. I feel like most of what I recall from this game has been "Hey, remember when you took out 4 monsters with the Spellweaver?" or "...when I 1 shot that 21 health object?"

[+] Dice rolls

michael ray

(squegeeboo)

Dexter345 wrote:

After going through the list and putting in my votes, I can say that I enjoyed the heck out of a lot of the retirement quests. I almost wish every retirement had quests associated with them. So much more climactic than just "Oh, I'm done, goodbye."

The counter point to that, is for groups who can't play as often those retirement quests mean less main story line, which can be annoying. Esp. if you had a retirement goal that took forever to hit.

Oh, I need to do 4 of X that took forever to get to AND then also pull the party off onto a side thing for 2-3 more scenarios?

[+] Dice rolls

Darren Nakamura

(Dexter345)

United States
Columbus
Mississippi

http://www.destructoid.com/author.phtml?a=1364

Darren@destructoid.com

Uninvited Guest wrote:

May I present a counter-counter-proposal that I think will satisfy both parties?

Instead of rating on a 0-4 scale, one could instead label the radio buttons. For example:

"Haven't attempted/Don't remember"
"Loved it"
"Neutral"
"Hated it"

Just a thought.

Counter-counter-counter proposal: leave off the "Haven't attempted/Don't remember" option. When people add these into polls here, they dominate by far, and they make any actually useful information harder to glean from the rest of the data. Just tell people not to vote on any they haven't played or don't remember.