My Renae Benson cards are incorrect, too, assuming I’m supposed to have three of each of the non-ID cards. I have some with 1 and some with 4.
Correct, each cop will have 3 copies of each card in their deck. If you need replacements, be sure to reach out to Blacklist here: firstname.lastname@example.org
They may not be able to send replacements until after fulfillment is done, but at least you'll get in the queue.