- Ragingkileak RagingkileakUnited Kingdom
You can find the original review with images here: https://bigbossbattle.com/the-fantasy-trip-legacy-edition-ma...
It’s not every day that you’ll see a re-release like The Fantasy Trip: Legacy Edition. In fact, it’s a game — or rather a system — that I think will surprise a lot of people with both its accessibility and it’s flexibility.
As the re-release of a Steve Jackson classic, The Fantasy Trip has all the smart writing and straightforward systems that you would expect, but how does it compare to more modern RPG systems, including Dungeons & Dragons, that have grown in popularity since it’s original release?
Firstly, let’s talk about what’s in the box. The Legacy Edition of The Fantasy Trip equates to almost ten kilo’s of cardboard tokens, paper maps, manuals and other supporting paraphernalia. The version of the game represents the flagship of Steve Jackson Games’ 2019 re-release and includes all of the available content, which is quite a considerable collection.
In more specific detail, you’ll find the original boxed minigames known as Melee and Wizard, as well as a similar, slightly more advanced boxed game that merges The Death Test and its sequel into a single product. There is also a large, thick booklet that combines several standalone releases from the original line, including The Labyrinth, Advanced Melee and Advanced Wizard. Much of the original text and imagery is unchanged as I understand it, but this new version provides a much more straightforward and accessible layout. Finally, at least in terms of headline content, there’s a large, advanced quest called Tollenkar’s Lair, which comes complete with its own maps.
Whilst these boxed games, booklets and adventures combine to provide the bulk of the actual content — which takes the form of both a straightforward RPG system and a series of pre-baked encounters and adventures — there’s a lot more stuff contained in the sizeable box. Notably, there is easily the largest and most detailed Dungeon Master screen that I’ve ever seen, as well as a large number of tokens, character pads, premade characters, dice and much more. There’s even a quick start guide that explains how players should work their way through each of the products by order of complexity.
Starting on that note, it is indeed wise to begin with Melee, then Wizard. Even when it was first released, The Fantasy Trip was always intended to be a more accessible RPG system than its rivals, and that is certainly true if you and your group chose to begin with the more straightforward boxed games. Melee, for example, offers the perfect introduction to pen and paper RPG’s of this sort, by providing a very simple set of rules for setting up a fight between two teams of up to five players. Rules for movement and basic weapons are introduced, alongside character creation and management in game.
When Wizard is introduced, spells are brought into the mix, as well as more interesting creatures such as dragons, giants and monsters. Melee focuses only really on the strength and dexterity attributes, whilst Wizard brings IQ into the mix and layers in more complex rules to do with movement, including flight. Characters who use magic are capable of summoning, so you can imagine how complexity ramps up with multiple characters in play, spells and complex enemies.
With a sound footing in basic movement, combat and spellcasting, the party will be ready to gather themselves and venture forth into more complex, prebaked adventures like The Death Test and The Death Test 2. Both of these individual quests are pre-configured and come with a manual that sets the scene with quite a lot of story text and some specific rules, as well as various maps and layouts. Inside the Legacy Edition, players will find a large number of dry-erase tiles that can be used to form dungeons, as well as tokens for monsters, heroes and environmental effects to put out onto them.
The Death Test adventures can actually be played entirely by the player party, with no need for a Dungeon Master. This enables all players to learn at the same pace without anyone needing to understand the rules at a more complex level, or to manage rules and circumstances that are not accounted for by the game. Assuming that you still have a willing party after these adventures are over, someone is likely to need to take on the responsibility for running the game in future, because games like Tollenkar’s Quest are much more complex. Beyond that, players will be building their own adventures in any case, which will always require a DM.
At this point, I have to admit that my time as a Dungeon Master both within The Fantasy Trip and outside it is fairly limited when it comes to “proper” RPG’s. I’ve DM’d a few Dungeons & Dragons campaigns though, and as the owner of many games, I’ve also led teams of adventurers through boxed games, including everything from Descent and Mansions of Madness to Heroquest in my time. My experience of good DM’s is an ability to adapt to the needs of the players, whether that be their skill level, the things that appear to be turning them on throughout the quest, or some other unexpected need.
The hallmark of a good roleplaying system, then, is to support the DM in enabling an experience that is appropriately challenging, powerful enough to allow for any circumstance and, most importantly, supportive of having fun. Having designed a couple of short campaigns with it, I can confirm that The Fantasy Trip does these things well, and it is certainly easier to dive into the art of game crafting than it is elsewhere. I felt with The Fantasy Trip that I had as much power to create my world as I’ve seen in any game, but that there was an inherent simplicity that encouraged me to be more adventurous in my designs.
This, I think, harks back to one of Steve Jackson’s original design objectives, which was to build much of the experience around player choice (such as using points to build a character rather than random die rolls) and to minimise complex and highly variable outcomes by channeling much of the experience through one or more D6 outcomes, rather than D20. I haven’t delved deep into my own adventures yet, but I have been able to frame them up, plan them and deliver the first few scenes using the dry-wipe boards that come bundled in The Fantasy Trip, which is all good.
Given that pen and paper roleplaying is experiencing something of a resurgence at the moment, I’m quietly positive about what The Fantasy Trip offers. As an overall package, the Legacy Edition is exceptional value, offering more ready made content (in terms of boxed games and adventures) than many of its peers right out of the box, but also because it includes a role playing system that is accessible enough for relatively novice dungeon masters to come to terms with.
There’s really nothing in the way of gatekeeping to overcome here, thanks to the ease of character creation and the simplicity by which spells and abilities are learned and cast. Everything is driven by the central attributes that are outlined in Melee and Wizards, so if you do begin your journey and progress through it in the logical way that The Fantasy Trip intends, then it’s almost impossible to go wrong. Tollenkar’s Lair introduces everything a burgeoning DM needs to know in order to design their own adventure, but it does it in such a way that is accessible and fun.
I feel that I’ve barely even begun to understand the power of The Fantasy Trip system, but I’m excited about using it to expand upon the adventures that I’ve already built, as well as the characters that have been created within them. I think that this is the essence of a good role playing game — when the DM is able to use the tools provided to create worlds that are fun for everyone to fight through. The Fantasy Trip is certainly such a system, but even if you come into with no experience in role playing, there is enough in this expansive box to enable you to work up to the DM level at any pace you’d like. The Fantasy Trip is, without doubt, the complete toolkit for any would-be adventuring party.
- [+] Dice rolls
Speaking as a person who has been playing TFT classic for 40 years (and has the new Legacy Edition sitting right in front of me), I think this is a very good review of the system.
The biggest advantage to the system in my mind is that it is nearly intuitive once you've played it even just a couple of times; much easier for the players to assimilate and use the mechanics than many other games are. I've literally gotten players who have NEVER played an RPG before up and running in 15 minutes; and players who HAVE played RPGs before can usually be up and running in 5 minutes of less with a fighter type character. Wizards, of course, DO take a little bit longer, but even there I would say the outer limit on time to get players up and running with a Wizard character would be about 30 minutes.
Despite that incredibly quick learning curve, the way the rules interlock and play off one another makes this game a surprisingly rich and complex one to master. Much like chess, where the individual pieces' moves can be learned in a matter of minutes, the way those moves (spell choices, weapon selection, armor choices, and tactical choices on the map) interact mean that you can and will still be exploring different options in this game for decades to come. It's really the best designed RPG I've ever played in terms of combining underlying simplicity with complex play interaction and still keeping the entire experience fun for everyone involved.
If you haven't tried it, please do. I don't think anyone will regret it!
- [+] Dice rolls