what about Love at First Turn? it's all love proclamations directed towards games, but one of the comments says:
Alas, for me, this was "love at first turn" that changed quickly to "we need to talk." Based on its ranking, though, I was honestly able to say "it's not you, it's me" as we parted ways.
another possibility is that for whatever reason, the geeklist author decided they didn't want their content on bgg anymore.