Just two come to mind this morning after our session last night.
1) The cult leader showed up right when it was time to take a
break. When we got back from completely true and delicious
I forgot to move him from the front door, and then he set the room on fire.
Cult Leader took a little bit of damage, and he was going to die of smoke inhalation so the investigators left him to go deal with a shoggoth. When the Cult Leader died of fire, I ruled his clue and cultist robes burnt up with him. I was going to drop them in the room with the fire, until I re-read the event card, and it very clearly says if 'an investigator' kills the Cult Leader.
2) Michael McGlen got scared and dropped his tommy gun, so Joe Diamond picked it up with the intention of shooting a Shoggoth and then giving it back on the trading step. Then I played the out of ammo mythos card on him. Does the mythos card stick to the item, or the player? And once the player doesn't have the item any more, does it stay with them or is it discarded?
Removed failed attempt to insert geekbadge image