I headline Red Purge and my opponent (as USSR) headlines Vietnam Revolts, then plays CIA Created in his first AR.
Does he get 1 op or can he get 2 if he uses the points in SE Asia. Red Purge reduces all cards by 1 to a minimum of 1 and Vietnam increases their value by 1 so if you apply Purge first then Vietnam it would be two, if you apply Vietnam first then Purge it will be 1?
"L'état, c'est moi."
Roger's Reviews: check out my reviews page, right here on BGG!
Caution: May contain wargame like substance
He would get 2.
The way to think of it is that he's playing a card for ops (CIA in this case, but it could have been NATO), which is reduced by 1 due to Purge. Purge cannot reduce a card below 1.
He chooses to play in SE Asia, and use all the ops there. Because he does so, he earns 1 bonus op.
It is not clear cut in my opinion. You could argue:
1. Played outside Asia it is a 1 Op, can't be reduced, so it remains a 1
2. Played in Asia it is now a 2 Op therefore it is reduced to 1
So Red Purge removes the Asia bonus.
However I don't disagree with Leroy's interpretation either so I'd toss a coin or just agree with my opponents opinion on it if only to keep the game going.
I suspect there is a ruling already on this somewhere.
- Last edited Wed Jan 4, 2012 1:07 am (Total Number of Edits: 6)
- Posted Wed Jan 4, 2012 12:58 am
I bought this...
...as I had no idea what to spend my GG on!
I'm pretty sure he'd get one OP as the ruling was that you add up all the modifiers then apply them so the overall modifier becomes zero. I believe the ruling was to avoid the 'memory' affect of applying in event order. The same thing is true of Containment and Red Scare hitting each other, you don't have to remember which one came first you just have an overall modifier of zero.(I preferred the idea of an order effect as it makes Containment/Brezhnev just that little bit stronger on headline vs Red Scare, but alas it wasn't to be!).
EDIT: It's in the rules, number 7.4.
7.4 Some event cards modify the Operations value of cards that
follow. These modifiers should be applied in aggregate, and can
modify ‘The China Card’.
EXAMPLE: The US player plays the Red Scare/Purge event
during the Headline Phase. Ordinarily, all USSR cards would
subtract one from their Operations value. However, for his
Headline card, the USSR played Vietnam Revolts. This event
gives the Soviet player +1 to all operations played in SE Asia.
For his first play, the USSR chooses ‘The China Card’. He plays
all points in SE Asia for 5 operations points. This is modified by
the Vietnam Revolts card, giving the USSR player 6 operation
points. However, the US Red Scare/Purge card brings the total
down to 5 operations points.
- Last edited Wed Jan 4, 2012 1:27 am (Total Number of Edits: 1)
- Posted Wed Jan 4, 2012 1:24 am
Russ is correct.
The designers have also clarified this in the past - all modifiers are calculated, then applied in aggregate.