If you choose to draw then discard cards in lieu of a raid, does it have to be three exactly, or can it be up to three? Thanks
The English version of the rules in the Highland Clans edition does suggest it should be exactly three cards. But all the player aids I've seen say "up to three", and the English translation of the original MacRobber edition also reads: "If the active player chooses not to conduct a raid, he may discard up to 3 of his cards and draw replacements from the draw pile."
In general the English rules of Highland Clans aren't the clearest, and in this instance I would suggest that the intent is indeed that up to three cards can be discarded.