Recommend
17 
 Thumb up
 Hide
7 Posts

Agricola» Forums » Reviews

Subject: Father Geek's Review of Agricola rss

Your Tags: Add tags
Popular Tags: [View All]
Cyrus Kirby
United States
Farmington
Minnesota
flag msg tools
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
The Basics:
o For ages 8 and up (publisher recommends 12+)
o For 1 to 5 players
o Approximately 20 to 30 minutes per player to complete

Geek Skills:
o Counting & Math
o Logical & Critical Decision Making
o Reading
o Strategy & Tactics
o Hand/Resource Management

Learning Curve:
o Child – Hard
o Adult – Hard

Theme & Narrative:
o Expand your farm, expand your family, and above all, don’t go hungry!

Endorsements:
o Gamer Geek approved!
o Parent Geek approved, but only just (might be considered too difficult for the casual player)
o Child Geek approved!

Overview

Agricola (Latin for “farmer”), designed by Uwe Rosenberg and published in English by Z-Man Games in 2008 (following the runaway success of the German edition published the previous year), is a thrill-a-minute worker placement game about farming. Okay, I admit that the theme itself is not the most exciting one, but if your little geek can play this game, then your child has the makings of a true Gamer Geek. And that is truly exciting!

Agricola is comprised of 5 Farmyard game boards(one per player), 3 Action game boards, 1 Major Improvement game board, 169 Occupation cards, 139 Minor Improvement cards, 10 Major Improvement cards, 14 Round cards, 16 Action cards, 5 Begging cards, 5 Summary cards, 5 Family Member discs, 4 Stables, 15 Fences, 33 Wood counters, 27 Clay counters, 18 Stone counters, 27 Grain counters, 18 Vegetable counters, 21 Sheep tokens, 18 Wild Boar tokens, 15 Cattle tokens, 1 Starting Player token, 33 Field/Stone House tiles, 24 Red Wood/Clay Hut tiles, 36 Food markers, 9 Multiplication markers, 3 Claim markers, and 1 Scoring pad.

Yes, you will need to organize this game.

Game Set Up and Play

A full explanation of the rules is beyond the scope of a brief review. This is not a game that can be explained in 5-minutes, even to hardcore gamers. You can read the full rules from the game’s official web page. Note that the game’s rules are rather long, but they do an excellent job of explaining the game in total detail. We suggest you read this review first, then if the game sounds interesting, dedicate an evening to read the rules in full. Consider this review something like reading the back of a book jacket.

Game setup, on the other hand, is very quick and is even simplified for a Family Game. Simple shuffle a few decks, put a few cards here, a few cards there, give everyone a little Food to start with, and away we go. In less than 5-minutes, you can be playing the game….if you organized it.

This is a relatively orthodox worker placement game. In clockwise order, players take actions from a common pool. Each action may only be taken once per round and allows the players to collect resources or to use these resources to develop their farms. Each player begins with two workers living in a wooden house with two rooms, with additional space available to develop one’s farm.

The resources in the game are represented by painted wooden tokens. They include:

o Food, not surprisingly, required to feed your farmers (2 Food per farmer required each Harvest, or else you’ll receive -3 victory point penalty per shortfall)

o Wood, required for building fences around pastures, or stables to place in pastures

o Clay, required for fireplaces or cooking hearths (improvements that convert crops or animals into food)

o Reed, required for expanding your house (thatched roofs, you see)

o Stone, required for ovens (to bake bread)

o Grain and Vegetables, crops that can be sowed, harvested and converted to food

o Sheep, Wild Boar and Cattle, animals that can be bred and converted to food

Apart from collecting resources (which you will either eat or build with), other actions allow players to:

o Extend their houses by building additional rooms, or renovate wooden rooms to clay or clay rooms to stone

o Make a baby (who will become a new farmer in the next round – no, you do not eat the baby)

o Build Fences or Stables, in order to keep animals

o Purchase Major Improvements, such as fireplaces, cooking hearths and ovens

o Plow Fields, or Sow Fields with crops

Harvests occur at the end of rounds 4, 7, 10, 12, 14 and 15. During a Harvest, grain and vegetables are reaped from the fields, animals are bred (gain one of any animal that you have at least 2 of, so long as you have space) and then any available food is eaten.

The standard game adds a layer of complexity through Occupation and Minor Improvement cards that give players additional ways in which to improve the efficiency of their farming operations.

Ending the Game

The game ends after Round 15 and a final Harvest. Victory points are then scored based on how many rooms, family members, fields, pastures, stables, crops, and animals each player has. The player with the most points wins the game.

To learn more about Agricola and read the full rules, see the game’s official web page.

Prediction

Agricola is unquestionably a “gamer’s game” (Ryan Sturm, of the How to Play Podcast, rates this a “Black Diamond” – a level of difficulty surpassed only by the “Double Black Diamond”), so it was with some misgivings that I decided to try this with my (then) 6-year-old son, a true gamer at heart but way below the recommended age level, and my wife who is not a gamer. My main concerns were, firstly, the introduction of a complex game too early could make a negative impression and spoil future experiences of this game for all of us, and secondly, that my 4-year-old daughter would have to amuse herself for at least an hour and a half, while the rest of us completed the game.

Holding my breath, I proceeded.

Final Word

To my relief, this was a success with my family, although my concerns were well-founded. If anything, I had underestimated the appeal of the farming theme to young children. In retrospect, I should have known that both the pastoral and agricultural aspects would capture their imaginations. On the other hand, the challenge of formulating and implementing a long-term plan was just slightly beyond my son’s gaming abilities. It remains a fun game – for example, I have to adapt to his unexpected strategy – but less competitive than I would like.

Pleasingly, we are able to set up, play, and put away this game in just over an hour with 3 to 4-players. Having the various components sorted in a Plano box is a big help. My daughter even played with us a few times!

As my son’s reading skills flourished, I added in the Occupation and Minor Improvement cards and we played several 2-player games with these. While he still struggled to play competitively, he was ecstatic to be combining literacy with gaming – two activities that he enjoys thoroughly. Again, the scores were not that close, but I still felt that I was challenged and I enjoyed watching his understanding of the game develop over several plays.


My little farmers…

To summarize:

o I expect that Child Geeks will love the theme and the opportunity to apply their reading skills, but the game itself will remain too advanced for them to play competitively - this should not stop them from playing the game and having fun, however.

o Parent Geeks might feel this is a little too much effort for their peer group, especially when there are other interesting games that are less difficult and much more casual, but when playing with family members, this game should be a hit (especially if playing the Family Game).

o Gamer Geeks will prefer to play the more complex standard game but should not complain about the Family Game, either.

After such a good experience with the original Agricola, Rosenberg’s latest offering, Agricola: All Creatures Great and Small, a 2-player game that focuses on raising farm animals, is near the top of my must-have list!

Happy farming gaming!

Written by Meng and published with permission
Respectfully submitted by the Father Geek
fathergeek.com
17 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Mr. Blue
United States
Orange County
California
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I just taught my 8 year old daughter the family version of Agricola over the weekend, and we had a great time. Yes, I did give her tips and hints along the way, but I think after a couple more plays she'll have it down. The family version (play without the minor improvements and occupation cards) is much more forgiving than the standard version, and it's a great place to start with this game.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Adam Kazimierczak
United States
Falmouth
Maine
flag msg tools
designer
publisher
badge
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Interesting.

I don't think my 6 year-old is ready yet, but 8 may be good. Having played Agricola 20+ times I have to say I think the full version is actually easier or more "forgiving" than the Family game, even though it has slightly more complexity. My group started with the family game and had some trouble keeping everyone fed, but with the Occupations and Minor Improvements you can end up with huge surpluses of food and make sprawling plantations/ranches out of your farms with the right draw and choices.

I think even non-gamers can handle the cards after 2 games, and it does help the replay value considerably.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Geoff Burkman
United States
Kettering
Ohio
flag msg tools
badge
Peekaboo!
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
Quote:
Pleasingly, we are able to set up, play, and put away this game in just over an hour with 3 to 4-players.


Nice! Yer a better man than I, Father Geeka Din.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
patrick somers
United States
wyandotte
Michigan
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
most awesome! Agricola witht the kids.
2 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Paul Evans
New Zealand
Wellington
flag msg tools
www.evanswhanau.co.nz
badge
...um, not really.
Avatar
mbmbmbmbmb
I've played about 8 2-player family games with my 5-year-old; and she loves it. The theme really hits the sweet spot for engaging this age group. amazingly - she stays engaged for the whole game (compared to chess where I lose her after about 10 moves every game).

I plan to write up a session report soon.

The 2-player version is easy - loads of food lying around. I tend to get a baking stretegy going to leave her with the farming and other food lying around. Oh, and we work a handicap system where she starts with extra food (a system developed for my 2-player games with my wife). When we played a 3-player game including my wife it didn't go quite as well - my wife played hardball - leaving my daughter starving. Now she respects the importance of food.

Her tactics are simple - starting player is hers, and the wood is hers. If I want wood I need to take starting player first. This can prove formidable if you are unwilling to take 1f starting player just to take 3w.

Can't wait for her reading to get to a level where she can play the full version.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Moe45673
Canada
Toronto
Ontario
flag msg tools
Avatar
mbmbmbmb
It's interesting all the comments about gaming with such young kids. My cousin's son is unusually gifted (about 9 years old), one of those kids who has behavioral problems because he's too smart and therefore bored. Give him a good book, though, and it's like ritalin. Maybe I can get him into the hobby. Enthusiastic and challenging opponents aren't easy to come by.
1 
 Thumb up
 tip
 Hide
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.