Todd Raethka
United States
New York
flag msg tools
If you have no trains and need to buy one are you forced to buy a g train that you can pay with treasury or can you use Emergency Funding to buy a normal train that you could not afford with treasury?
 Thumb up
  • [+] Dice rolls
marc magner
United States
New York
flag msg tools
found a thread on the 18xx yahoo groups from the designer that addresses this issue in the rules


> Lonny Orgler wrote:
> > > Suppose a corporation has no train and 500 in its treasury.
> Suppose also
> > > that there are a 3G-train and an 8-train available for purchase
> > > from the bank.
> > > May the corporation go into Emergency Money Raising, have its
> > > president add 100
> > > from hand, and buy the 8? Or is it obliged to buy the 3G?
> [The English
> > > rules are fairly clear on this point--only the 3G can be bought.
> > > They're also
> > > clear that if the corporation has 100 in its treasury, the
> > > president has a choice
> > > of either train. There are those who doubt that this is the
> > > intended rule
> > > combination, though it does exist elsewhere.]
> >
> > You're right, this is not clear enough in the rules. Our
> intention is that
> > in case of Emergency Money Raising one should always have the
> choice between
> > the cheapest "normal" train and the cheapest g-train in the
> bank, no matter
> > how much money the company has.
> The problem is that if the corporation has enough money to buy a
> cheap train
> from the bank, it doesn't need to go into Emergency Money Raising
> at all. In
> fact, as the rules stand, it can't, because EMR only happens if the
> corporation can't buy a train without it.

The rules should be:
A company which has no train and has to buy one can choose any available
train of the bank or offered by other companies no matter how much money it
has. If the company has not enough money for the purchase of the chosen
train the director may add the difference.

> Your answer raises yet another issue. At the moment, the rules
> say that if a
> corporation with no train and almost no money (i.e. less than the
> cost of a
> 3G train) has a 3G, a 5G, and a 10 available, it can choose to buy any of
> these, including the 5G. You say that it should only have the
> choice of the 3G or
> the 10.

My mistake. It's not the CHEAPEST train but ANY train available in the bank
(or offered by other companies).
 Thumb up
  • [+] Dice rolls
Front Page | Welcome | Contact | Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Advertise | Support BGG | Feeds RSS
Geekdo, BoardGameGeek, the Geekdo logo, and the BoardGameGeek logo are trademarks of BoardGameGeek, LLC.